TLDR
Charming ambiance, but a concerning decline in food quality and a recent health department closure.
Amber Sutherland-Namako reviews the revamped Figaro Café in Greenwich Village, noting its attractive ambiance but ultimately finding the food and drinks to be underwhelming. While the space is comfortable and well-suited for various occasions, the culinary experience doesn't quite live up to the charming decor.
Details
This Greenwich Village establishment, previously known as a neighborhood hangout, has undergone a revamp with a new look and feel, featuring a comfortable and attractive ambiance. However, recent reviews suggest a significant decline in food quality, with instances of terrible meals and even health code violations leading to closure [1], [2]. While some recall positive experiences with drinks in the past, the current consensus points to an unsatisfactory culinary experience.
Food Overview
Recent feedback overwhelmingly criticizes the food quality at Figaro, with one user describing it as 'terrible' [1]. The restaurant has faced significant issues, including being closed by the Department of Health due to violations such as the presence of filth flies and adulterated food [2]. A review also noted issues with colossal shrimp being slightly fishy and plant-based scallops being only palatable with their accompanying purée [3]. While some past patrons remember it as a place to hang out, its food has never been its strong suit, and recent reports suggest it has worsened considerably.
One user specifically praised the bread knots, describing them as doughy and rich, possibly with a honey butter glaze [1]. However, other dishes have received poor reviews.
Caveats
The restaurant has been closed by the Department of Health due to multiple serious violations, including the presence of filth flies, lack of rodent control, and adulterated food [1]. It had previously received a C grade, and subsequent inspections showed a worsening situation, indicating a lack of care [1], [2]. Financial issues, including unpaid rent, vendors, and employees, were also noted [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About FIGARO
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: On The Hunt For For Good Or Interesting Bread
"Figaro in Greenwich Village has amazing bread knots, possibly with a honey butter glaze, described as doughy and rich."
PositiveFrom post: Figaro Closed
"This comment explains that Figaro had significant financial issues, including unpaid rent, vendors, and employees, and had open lawsuits since its opening."
NegativeFrom post: Figaro Closed
"This user mentioned a prior comment panning Figaro and linked to a relevant post. The restaurant had a C rating."
NegativeFrom post: Figaro Closed By Dept Of Health
"This user commented on the closure of Figaro, stating they were not surprised due to observing customers primarily ordering drinks rather than food, which might indicate a lack of focus on kitchen maintenance."
NegativeFrom post: Figaro Closed By Dept Of Health
"This user noted that Figaro had also received a C grade in July 2025, referencing the CleanPlate app for information on recently graded and shut down restaurants."
Negative