NYC bagel fave w/ a perfect chew & wide variety of flavors. Get your coffee & baked goods fix here too!
For a taste of classic New York, look no further than this beloved bagel shop. They're known for their consistently great bagels, with a texture that's often praised as being close to traditional NYC style. Beyond bagels, they also offer a variety of coffee and baked goods, making it a reliable spot for a quick breakfast or snack.
This spot is highly acclaimed for its bagels, noted for their excellent chew and texture, with many considering them among the best in Manhattan. They also offer a range of coffees and baked goods, including a well-regarded black and white cookie. Some users have noted that while considered great, their bagels may not be the most traditional New York style.
"Customers frequently praise the bagels, with specific mentions of the egg & cheese on an everything bagel and the honey bacon sriracha cream cheese. The black and white cookie is also highlighted as a favorite."
Customers rave about the quality and texture of the bagels, often calling them a top choice in the city. The establishment is frequently recommended for its coffee and baked goods as well.
Important Note
One reviewer noted that while their bagels are excellent, they might not be considered a classic New York style bagel.
"Brooklyn bagel is the biggest repeat restaurant for this user, although they don't dine out often."
Positive"This commenter prefers Brooklyn Bagels over Pop Up bagels, stating they are always great."
Positive"This user regularly buys Brooklyn Bagels and Coffee Co. bagels to take home and states they freeze great."
Positive"This user stated that Brooklyn Bagels remains their preferred choice for the best bagel, expressing a strong positive opinion of the establishment."
Positive"The commenter states that Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee is the best bagel outside of Long Island, and specifically recommends their honey bacon sriracha cream cheese."
Positive"Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee is considered the author's favorite bagel spot in the city, praising the large bagels with great texture, particularly the egg & cheese on an everything bagel."
Positive"The commenter's comfort food consists of a bagel with scallion cream cheese and fresh squeezed orange juice from Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company in midtown."
Positive"The user's go-to is Brooklyn Bagel, stating they have the best chew and are closest to a traditional NY bagel."
Positive"This comment suggests Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company as a good option for bagels."
Positive"Despite being a chain, Brooklyn Bagel was considered a solid option for bagels by a reviewer, with a location conveniently close to their hotel."
Neutral"Brooklyn Bagels and Coffee Company is listed as a recommendation for bagels and coffee, noting that it has multiple locations."
Positive"A user speculates that Brooklyn Bagel Company might have both chocolate chip bagels and strawberry cream cheese."
Neutral"Brooklyn Bagel Co was suggested as a place to buy single flagels."
Positive"Recommends Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company in Hell’s Kitchen for bagels, responding to OP's request for bagel recommendations."
Positive
