TLDR
Massive, dense NYC-style bagels paired with creative cream cheese flavors. An underrated, top-tier favorite for bagel enthusiasts.
Details
Renowned for their massive, dense bagels and creative cream cheese spreads, this spot is consistently ranked among the top bagel destinations in New York City [1], [2]. Many locals consider it an underrated gem that offers superior quality and consistency compared to its competitors [3], [4]. Whether enjoyed on-site or taken home, the bagels are frequently praised for their exceptional chew and generous portions [5].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on authentic New York-style bagels that are notably dense and massive [2], [5]. Diners highly recommend the creative cream cheese flavors, and seasonal offerings like pumpkin bagels and pumpkin cream cheese are well-regarded [1], [6]. While the HEC (Ham, Egg, and Cheese) is noted as being on the pricier side, customers appreciate the generous portions and quality of the sandwich [7].
The massive, dense bagels are the primary recommendation, particularly when paired with creative cream cheese flavors [2], [5]. During the autumn season, the pumpkin bagels and matching pumpkin cream cheese are standout choices [6].
Customers express overwhelming affection for the shop, frequently citing it as their go-to spot for high-quality bagels [4]. Feedback is consistently positive, highlighting the shop's reliability and superior taste over other popular chains [3], [5].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01tofu cream cheese2 mentions
- 02pumpkin bagels2 mentions
Caveats
The HEC sandwich is noted to be on the pricier side by some patrons [7].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BROOKLYN BAGEL & COFFEE COMPANY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: If Your Bagel Sandwich Is At Least 8 Itd Better
"The user likes their HEC for the massive bagels and generous portions."
PositiveFrom post: Bagel Shop That Sells Pumpkin Bagels The Bagel
"The user reacts with excitement to the mention of pumpkin seeds on the bagels at this location."
PositiveFrom post: Bagel Shop That Sells Pumpkin Bagels The Bagel
"This shop is recommended for offering both pumpkin bagels and pumpkin cream cheese during the autumn season."
PositiveFrom post: Where Would You Take Someone If They Could Only
"Massive and dense bagels with creative cream cheese flavors."
PositiveFrom post: Where Would You Take Someone If They Could Only
"A top choice, noted for being underrated."
Positive