Caveats
The restaurant does not take reservations, so arriving early is recommended, especially on holidays.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About FRED'S
This post suggests Fred's as a brunch option on the Upper West Side and also discusses the walk-in vibe as the restaurant does not take reservations.
A user mentions Fred's on the Upper West Side as their personal favorite for Thanksgiving dinner.
This post highlights that Fred's has a private room that can accommodate groups of around 10-12 people, offering a good experience.
Fred's is mentioned in this discussion about restaurants people frequently return to.
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Quiet Back Room On The West Side
"Fred's on Amsterdam has a private room that has been used successfully for groups of about 10-12 people, offering a good experience."
PositiveDec 21, 2025View Comment →
From post: Thanksgiving Restaurants Nyc
"This user considers Fred's on the Upper West Side their personal favorite for Thanksgiving."
PositiveAug 30, 2025View Comment →
From post: Uws Brunch With Parents
"Advises arriving early at Fred's or any other restaurant on Mother's Day."
NeutralMay 4, 2025View Comment →
From post: Uws Brunch With Parents
"Suggests Fred's as a brunch option."
PositiveMay 3, 2025View Comment →
From post: Uws Brunch With Parents
"Asks about the walk-in vibe at Fred's, as it doesn't take reservations."
NeutralMay 3, 2025View Comment →