TLDR
Florentine sandwich shop serving HUGE, flavorful subs. Must-try: 'La Broadway' w/ pistachio cream. GF options debated.
Reddit Sentiment for ALL'ANTICO VINAIO(based on 10 Reddit opinions)
Details
Known for its generously portioned and flavorful Italian sandwiches, this spot offers a taste of Florence right in NYC. While many rave about the quality and size of their sandwiches, some discussions touch upon the availability and authenticity of gluten-free options. The 'La Broadway' sandwich, featuring a unique combination of pistachio cream, cheese, and vegetables, is a highlighted vegetarian choice.
Food Overview
This establishment specializes in Italian sandwiches, with particular attention on their substantial portions and flavor profiles. The 'La Broadway' sandwich, a vegetarian option with pistachio cream, creamy cheese, dried tomatoes, spicy zucchini, and arugula on focaccia, has been positively mentioned. There is also a recurring conversation thread regarding the availability and quality of gluten-free bread for their sandwiches, with some users reporting positive experiences and others expressing skepticism.
Caveats
There are mixed reviews and ongoing discussions regarding the availability and quality of gluten-free bread options.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About ALL'ANTICO VINAIO
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Casual Bite In Flatiron
"The All'Antico Vinaio location on 25th Street is suggested for its significant seating, though the user hasn't been inside. They also mentioned that Sunday Morning nearby has seating for coffee and pastries."
NeutralFrom post: Vegetarian Breakfast Bagel And General Veggie
"The original poster commented on the high cost of avocados in London compared to their availability in NYC."
NeutralFrom post: Vegetarian Breakfast Bagel And General Veggie
"The commenter suggested adding hot sauce to an egg, cheddar, and avocado combination as a great addition if heat is desired."
PositiveFrom post: Vegetarian Breakfast Bagel And General Veggie
"The original poster found the description of the food at All'antico Vinaio to be very appealing."
PositiveFrom post: Vegetarian Breakfast Bagel And General Veggie
"This establishment, with a less busy location on 25th and Broadway, is praised for its vegetarian sandwich, the 'La Broadway', which features pistachio cream, creamy cheese, dried tomatoes, spicy zucchini, and arugula on focaccia."
PositiveFrom post: Sandwiches With Good Glutenfree Bread
"A user provided evidence from Google Maps reviews for All'Antico Vinaio's W 25th St location, showing recent mentions and a picture of gluten-free bread, and also noted a similar mention for the 8th Ave location."
PositiveFrom post: Sandwiches With Good Glutenfree Bread
"Regarding the gluten-free bread at All'Antico Vinaio, a user mentioned that their mother's bread looked similar to the original, but noted that policies may have changed as it was several months ago."
NeutralFrom post: Sandwiches With Good Glutenfree Bread
"A user expressed skepticism about All'Antico Vinaio offering gluten-free bread that resembles their original bread, suggesting that customers might need to bring their own gluten-free bread for sandwich preparation."
NegativeFrom post: Sandwiches With Good Glutenfree Bread
"A user expressed excitement about the possibility of getting a gluten-free option at All'Antico Vinaio, thanking another user for the information."
PositiveFrom post: Sandwiches With Good Glutenfree Bread
"All'Antico Vinaio reportedly offers gluten-free bread for their sandwiches. This was mentioned as a possibility, with one user's mother having received a gluten-free option there."
Positive