TLDR
A psychedelic supper club tucked inside a historic theater, perfect for a high-quality burger, decadent desserts, and a classic martini.
Instagram Posts References
A24 has launched its first New York City restaurant, Wild Cherry, situated within the historic Cherry Lane Theatre in the West Village. This establishment offers an upscale dining experience, described as a supper club, with a menu featuring American and French-inspired dishes. The restaurant's ambiance is designed to be movie-themed, reflecting A24's cinematic background. The opening is part of A24's broader initiative to restore the nearly century-old theater, aiming to integrate film, food, and culture.
The post features Wild Cherry, a restaurant located in the West Village of New York City. It showcases a variety of dishes, including a pasta dish, a cheeseburger with fries and lettuce, and a dessert that appears to be a rich chocolate confection topped with whipped cream and berries. Several cocktails are also visible, suggesting a lively bar scene. The ambiance seems to be cozy and inviting, with dimly lit interiors and a prominent bar area. The menu visible in one of the images indicates a diverse range of offerings from oysters and seafood cocktails to hors d'oeuvres and main courses.
Wild Cherry is recognized for its delicious burger and expertly made martinis, contributing to the quintessential New York City experience of enjoying both.
Bryan Kim reviews Wild Cherry, a West Village spot that blends psychedelic diner aesthetics with Hollywood supper club vibes, offering a hit-or-miss menu anchored by an exceptional burger.
Details
Tucked away inside the historic Cherry Lane Theatre, this West Village establishment blends a psychedelic diner aesthetic with the upscale vibe of a Hollywood supper club [3]. While the menu features some inconsistent dishes, the high-quality, marrow-infused burger and excellent desserts consistently win over patrons [4]. Its trendy, movie-industry-adjacent atmosphere makes it a popular "hotspot" for special celebrations [6], [10], though prospective diners should expect competitive reservations [4], [8].
Food Overview
The restaurant offers an eclectic mix of French and American cuisine, ranging from frog legs Kiev to tableside fettuccine alfredo [3]. While some appetizers and entrees can be hit-or-miss—with the garlic bread and chicken specifically receiving criticism—the menu is redeemed by its celebrated marrow-infused cheeseburger and delightful desserts like the Black Forest custard and pineapple cream cake [4].
The standout is the marrow-infused cheeseburger [4], [5], complemented by decadent desserts such as the Black Forest custard and pineapple cream cake [4].
Overall sentiment leans positive, with guests frequently praising the unique atmosphere, celebratory vibe, and standout menu items like the burger [4], [10]. While the experience is highly sought after, some visitors note that securing a reservation requires advance planning or a willingness to wait for a bar seat [4], [8].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01burger2 mentions
- 02cheeseburger2 mentions
Caveats
The menu can be inconsistent, with reports of disappointing appetizers and rubbery chicken [4]. Additionally, reservations are highly competitive, making walk-ins for the bar the primary alternative for those without a booking [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About WILD CHERRY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Eloping In The Les Where Should Two Foodies
"Suggested as a good celebratory space."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Find Pastis To Drink In The City
"A user noted that Wild Cherry is a place where they have had pastis before, and that one should ask for it if it's not on the menu."
PositiveFrom post: Restaurant Ideas For A Long Weekend Trip Next Week
"Wild Cherry is mentioned as a good spot in Greenwich/West Village, and the commenter advises making reservations or being prepared for a wait, suggesting it might be a place that requires planning."
PositiveFrom post: Which Would You Choose The Corner Store Or 4
"This user listed Wild Cherry as a current 'hotspot' that could be considered."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Find A Good Scorpion Bowl In The City
"The commenter had a scorpion bowl at Wild Cherry recently which included a bouquet of flowers."
Positive