TLDR
Indulgent froyo with double-layered toppings and a nostalgic candy shop vibe. A popular West Village spot for customizable, Instagrammable treats.
Instagram Posts References
On Friday, Birdies presents a creative ice cream concoction loaded with cookie dough chunks and drizzled with chocolate, appealing to cookie and ice cream lovers alike.
Birdies is a highly anticipated candy shop duo that epitomizes current trends in a way that appeals to millennials, featuring nostalgic favorites.
Birdies is highlighted as an honorable mention for its cookie dough desserts. The post specifically showcases a soft-serve ice cream cup generously topped with cookie dough pieces and colorful sprinkles, indicating a creative and appealing dessert presentation.
Birdie's is featured for its Peach Frozen Yogurt, topped with fresh raspberries, suggesting a refreshing and fruity dessert.
Birdie's NYC offers a variety of frozen yogurt flavors and classic American toppings. The post highlights a rich chocolate and vanilla swirl froyo topped with generous portions of chocolate crunch and cookie dough, alongside a classic vanilla froyo adorned with colorful sprinkles and fresh strawberries, catering to diverse preferences.
Birdies NYC is a sweet shop that offers a pick-and-mix candy station. The sign indicates that the price for the candy is $4.50 per 1/4 lb. They also have a menu that lists various toppings such as strawberries, chocolate chips, and premium toppings like cookie dough and brownies. The establishment is noted for its tart and chocolate options.
The post includes a frozen yogurt from Birdie's, noting that 'Trying new froyos is always a great idea,' implying a positive and enjoyable experience.
A caramelized banana cinnamon bun from Birdie Bakery was featured, described as 'unsurprisingly incredible'. The bun is shown with a generous topping of cream cheese frosting and a slice of caramelized banana, indicating a rich and indulgent treat.
Willa Moore reviews Birdie's, a West Village shop that blends frozen yogurt and a candy bar, offering a treat experience that leans closer to ice cream than traditional yogurt.
Details
Located in the West Village, this trendy dessert shop combines a customizable frozen yogurt bar with an extensive pick-and-mix candy station [1]. While many guests flock here for the social media-worthy experience and generous, double-layered toppings, opinions on the frozen yogurt itself remain divided [2], [3]. Some patrons find the creamy, ice-cream-like texture to be a delightful indulgence [1], though others argue the quality is mediocre and fails to live up to nostalgic expectations [2], [4].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on customizable frozen yogurt and soft serve that lean toward a creamy, ice-cream-like profile rather than the traditional tart style [1], [2]. Customers highlight the high-quality toppings, specifically the made-from-scratch chocolate chip cookie dough [1], though some warn that individual topping costs can drive up the total price quickly [1]. While standard froyo receives mixed reviews [2], [4], the vegan chocolate soft serve has been noted for its resemblance to a classic fudgsicle [5].
Feedback is deeply split; while many diners praise the creative topping variety, others feel the experience is driven more by social media hype than actual quality [2], [3]. Frequent complaints cite high prices and long lines that often fail to deliver a superior product compared to local competitors [2], [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BIRDIE'S
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Dairy Free Soft Serve In Midtown Area Healthyish
"Birdies offers a vegan chocolate soft serve that is compared to a fudgsicle."
PositiveFrom post: Visiting For A 3 Night Stay Would You Help With
"The commenter states the frozen yogurt is not very good and suggests alternative nearby shops."
NegativeFrom post: Anyone Tried Birdies In The West Village Is It
"The double-layered toppings are a highlight, but the overall quality is mediocre and not worth the slow-moving line."
NegativeFrom post: Anyone Tried Birdies In The West Village Is It
"The reviewer finds the texture too much like ice cream and lacks the desired tart quality of traditional frozen yogurt."
NegativeFrom post: Anyone Tried Birdies In The West Village Is It
"The restaurant is described as fine, but it suffers from being located directly across from a competitor with longer lines."
Neutral