Next.js logo

FREDDIE & PEPPER'S

Updated

Phone: (212) 799-2378

Address: 303 AMSTERDAM AVENUE 10023

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Underrated UWS slice shop: perfect late-night $2 slice after work. Great local slice places from the past.

Reddit Sentiment for FREDDIE & PEPPER'S(based on 4 Reddit opinions)

75% Positive

Achievements and Accolades

Achievement logo

Tags

italian 4italian-american 3pizza 8View All

Neighborhoods

Upper West Side

Featured Articles

Dedicated reviews and comprehensive features focusing directly on this restaurant.

Freddie & Pepper's
positive

Bryan Kim reviews Freddie & Pepper's, an Upper West Side slice shop praising its classic cheese pizza and decadent bacon chicken ranch slice, advising to stick to the pizza.

Bryan Kim • Mar 26, 2025
Read More →
Infatuation

Details

This Upper West Side gem is a classic slice shop that shines with its no-frills approach to pizza. Praised for its generous cheese pizza and decadent bacon chicken ranch slice, it's a go-to for a substantial and flavorful bite. While they offer other options like Chilean sandwiches, the true stars are the pizzas, embodying a serious takeout operation with an old-school vibe.

Food Overview

This establishment is primarily known for its pizza, with the regular cheese slice and the decadent bacon chicken ranch slice being highly recommended. While they also offer sandwiches, including Chilean options like the chacarero, the consensus is to stick to the pizza for the best experience.

Highlights / Recommended

"The regular cheese pizza and the bacon chicken ranch pizza are highly recommended for their generous toppings and classic flavors."

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally praise this spot for its classic, no-frills pizza, with many recommending specific slices and noting its value.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About FREDDIE & PEPPER'S

NY pizza for one in Manhattan
A Reddit user calls Freddie & Peppers on the Upper West Side 'underrated,' suggesting it's a great spot for a pizza.
Visiting NYC for one night, looking for food & drink
This user enthusiastically recommends the pesto pizza at Freddie & Peppers, finding it exceptionally good and even preferring it over fancier establishments.
best local spots in UWS?
A user recommends the pesto slice from Freddie & Peppers, highlighting it as a notable item on their menu.
Shoutout to the unhyped independent neighborhood joints
A former resident fondly remembers Freddie and Pepper's as a perfect spot for a late-night slice, highlighting its nostalgic value.
Best post-work (7pm) pizza slice option where I can grab and go?
Freddie Peppers is recommended as an underrated slice shop, offering a classic New York slice experience.
Visiting for the first time
This commenter recommended Freddie & Peppers as a 'sleeper' spot for a classic New York slice of pizza.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Visiting For The First Time

"This commenter recommended Freddy and Peppers as a "sleeper" spot for a classic New York slice of pizza, noting its proximity to other mentioned locations."

Positive
Aug 16, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Postwork 7pm Pizza Slice Option Where I Can

"This user recommends Freddy Peppers in the Upper West Side as an underrated slice shop."

Positive
May 20, 2025View Comment →

From post: Visiting Nyc For One Night Looking For Food Drink

"The user strongly recommends Freddy and Peppers, specifically for their pesto pizza, stating it's so good they'd prefer it over a fancier place."

Positive
May 18, 2025View Comment →