TLDR
Thin-crust slices featuring inventive toppings like hot honey, burrata, and vodka sauce. A standout slice shop on the Lower East Side.
Instagram Posts References
The author considers Johnny's Pizza one of their favorite spots in New York City, particularly for their 'Johnny's Way' slice, which features burrata, hot honey, and parmesan. They note that the slices are served exceptionally hot, but this does not detract from the overall phenomenal quality of the pizza. The post also includes relevant hashtags for New York pizza and food enthusiasts.
The reviewer found Jonny's Pizza to be a complete letdown, even when ordering 'Jonny's Way'. They described the slice as tiny, dry, and overpriced, costing $13.69.
Johnny's Pizza is featured for its classic New York-style pizza, with a close-up shot of a delicious-looking slice. The pizza appears to have a thin crust, savory tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and perhaps some pepperoni or similar topping, finished with grated cheese.
Jonny's Pizza is highlighted as having the 'best new pizza slice in NYC' and is the reviewer's new favorite spot. The establishment is praised for its thin crust pizza that offers a slight crunch while remaining soft on top. Specific mention is made of their unique topping combinations, such as burrata, hot honey, and shaved Parmesan on their cheese slice, and a pesto drizzle on their pepperoni vodka slice. The overall experience was highly positive, with the slices described as bright and impactful, leaving the reviewer eager to return.
Details
Located on Orchard Street, this spot is celebrated for its fresh, thin-crust pizza that many claim offers a superior alternative to other downtown establishments [10]. Diners frequently highlight the unique, flavor-forward topping combinations that elevate the standard slice experience [2]. While the overwhelming majority of feedback is glowing, a small minority of patrons have found certain specialty slices to be overpriced [3].
Food Overview
This pizzeria serves high-quality, thin-crust New York-style pizza with a slight crunch [2], [11]. Standout items include the 'Johnny's Way' cheese slice, which features burrata, hot honey, and shaved Parmesan, and the pepperoni vodka slice often enhanced with hot honey [11], [12], [13]. Customers also enjoy the turkey pesto sandwich [6]. While most feedback is enthusiastic, one reviewer found a premium slice to be small, dry, and poor value [13].
Caveats
Some customers have noted that the pizza is served extremely hot, which can lead to mouth burns if not handled carefully [12]. Additionally, the price of the lunch special has seen a slight increase over time, and some premium slices are criticized for being overpriced [5], [13].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About JONNY'S PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For Pizza Recs For Queens Brooklyn And
"Recommended pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Reigning Pizza Slice Downtown Manhattan Lindustrie
"Highlights the vodka pepperoni slice with hot honey as an unmatched item."
PositiveFrom post: Reigning Pizza Slice Downtown Manhattan Lindustrie
"Praise for serving slices that taste like fresh-made pie, described as the antithesis of Scarr's."
PositiveFrom post: Johnnys Pizza Lunch Special Is Slept On Les
"This user, who frequents Mr. Take, plans to try Johnny's Pizza after learning about their offerings."
NeutralFrom post: Johnnys Pizza Lunch Special Is Slept On Les
"This user usually goes to Ovens Slice for a quick slice but intends to try Johnny's Pizza next time based on the discussion."
Neutral