Quintessential NY slice spot with killer marinara and vodka slices [1]. Often praised as a top-tier pizza contender, sometimes noted for being a better alternative to other popular pizzerias without the long waits [1, 2].
Lucia Pizza, a notable Italian pizzeria with roots in Brooklyn, is celebrated for its exceptional pizza slices, including standout options like the Caramelle Picantti and a classic Papa Leone vodka slice [1]. Reviewers praise their excellent sauce and the unique combination of ingredients in their specialty slices [1]. The restaurant, also with locations in Soho and on the Upper East Side, is recommended for its quality and often suggested as a great alternative to other popular pizzerias, sometimes even with shorter wait times [1, 2].
Lucia Pizza is a well-regarded Italian pizzeria known for its excellent pizza slices. Standout offerings include the Caramelle Picantti, a combination of hot cherry peppers, pepperoni, and Mike’s Hot Honey, and the Papa Leone vodka slice, which features a classic sauce recipe [1]. Reviewers often highlight the quality of the sauce and the balanced flavors of cheese and sauce [1]. While many consider it a top-tier option, some patrons have found it to be only average or have had less impressive experiences with specific slices like the vodka slice, describing it as bland [1, 3].
"Lucia Pizza is highly recommended for its classic NY-style slices, with particular praise for its marinara and vodka slices [1, 2]. The Caramelle Picantti, a mix of hot cherry peppers, pepperoni, and hot honey, and the Papa Leone vodka slice are also highlighted as must-tries [1]."
Customers generally have a positive view of Lucia Pizza, with many recommending it as a great option for pizza and praising its classic slices, such as the pepperoni and vodka slices [1, 2]. However, a few have expressed disappointment, finding it to be just 'good at best' or underwhelming compared to the hype [1, 3].
Important Note
One user expressed surprise and disappointment with Lucia's inclusion in a top restaurant list, calling it 'such a joke' and rating it 'good at best' [1]. Another commenter, after two visits to different locations, was underwhelmed and questioned the hype, while also finding a recent vodka slice to be thin, bland, and insubstantial [1, 2].
"Mentioned that one of the 20 best, and possibly 10 best, pizza slices in the city is available a block away."
Positive"Stated that Lucia's is absolutely top tier."
Positive"Recommended Lucia for pizza."
Positive"Recommended Lucia Pizza of Soho for having some of the best pizza they've had in the city."
Positive"This user considers Lucia of Soho to be a preferred option since Scarr's Pizza has already been discussed."
Positive"Lucia, located on Canal Street, is mentioned as a better pizza option compared to others nearby."
Positive"Commenter mentioned that Ceres, L'Industrie, Prince St, and Lucia are all within a 10-minute walk in SoHo."
Neutral"This user had liked Lucia previously but found their last vodka slice to be too thin with minimal toppings, bland, and insubstantial."
Negative"The commenter questioned the hype around Lucia, as they were underwhelmed during two separate visits to different locations."
Negative"This commenter recommended Lucia as a place to get a thick crust pizza slice in NYC."
Positive"This user suggested Lucia's might be a good option for a doughy pizza."
Positive"Lucia is recommended as a place to get a pizza slice, mentioned as a preferred option alongside Village Square. This is in response to a request for pizza recommendations."
Positive"The user is considering Lucia of Soho as an alternative pizza option in Manhattan."
Neutral"Lucia Pizza of Soho was rated 8.8/10 for its plain cheese slice, described as a good New York slice."
Positive"This commenter enthusiastically recommended Lucia for its killer marinara slice."
Positive"This user recommended Lucia of SOHO, noting it's a new outpost of an old-school Brooklyn pizza shop. They suggested it's worth visiting for a slice."
Positive"Suggests Lucia offers a quality similar to L'Industrie with no wait, located in the same vicinity."
Positive"Mentions Lucia Pizza in Soho as a possible option."
Neutral"This user mentioned Lucia in the context of restaurants in FiDi."
Neutral"The commenter, who lives near Lucia's, believes it has surpassed Joe's Pizza in quality due to freshness and appreciated touches like fresh basil and olive oil, finding Joe's current price of $4 a slice to be outrageous."
Positive
