Surprising burger haven amidst the Times Square buzz. A casual American eatery with hits and misses, sometimes a fallback for out-of-towners.
This American casual dining spot in Times Square has garnered some unexpected attention, with one visitor noting a surprising line around the corner. While not typically lauded, one patron specifically praised the burgers at this location, calling them some of the best in the city. However, the general sentiment from other diners is more reserved, with some finding certain dishes like wonton tacos to be just 'super mediocre' and questioning the value of items like an appetizer sampler at $35. It's often viewed as a fallback option, especially for those unfamiliar with it from their hometowns, and some believe it's a choice that bypasses more unique local NYC culinary experiences. Overall, it's a place that elicits surprise and mixed feelings, with occasional pleasant surprises on the burger front being overshadowed by general mediocrity for many.
The American cuisine offered here draws mixed reactions. While some patrons have reported surprisingly good burgers, others find dishes like wonton tacos to be mediocre. The appetizer sampler has been noted as potentially overpriced. The general consensus leans towards it being a casual dining option rather than a culinary destination, with some even suggesting it as a last resort.
"The burgers have been specifically praised by one diner as being some of the best in the city."
Customer feedback for this establishment is mixed, with some expressing surprise at its popularity, while others have found specific items like burgers to be surprisingly good. However, there's a general sentiment that it's not a top-tier dining choice and can be overpriced, with some visitors opting for it mainly because it's unavailable in their hometown. Some comments suggest it's a fallback option or mediocre.
Important Note
Some customers feel that choosing this chain restaurant means missing out on more unique local NYC dining experiences. There's also a perception of it being overpriced, particularly for certain items like appetizer samplers.
"The user implies that Applebee's in Times Square would serve better quality food, specifically biscuits and gravy, than Jacob's Pickles, despite Applebee's generally not being considered high-end dining."
Neutral"The user would not pay $35 for an appetizer sampler at Applebee's in Times Square, indicating it's overpriced for the value, unless under the influence."
Neutral"The user believes Applebee's has some good items but specifically rates their wonton tacos as mediocre."
Neutral"The user expresses disappointment in visitors choosing global chain restaurants like Applebee's over unique local NYC options."
Negative"The user thought the original post was referring to tacos from Applebees."
Neutral"The user expresses surprise at seeing Applebee's recommended on r/foodNYC but is glad the original poster enjoyed it."
Neutral"The user acknowledges Applebee's was bad but explains they tried it because it's unavailable in their hometown."
Negative"The user would have preferred to skip Applebee's."
Negative"The commenter unironically praises the Applebees located next to the AMC 25, stating they've had some of the best burgers in the city there."
Positive"The commenter sarcastically refers to Applebees as one of the 'firm favourites of the sub', suggesting it's commonly mentioned but not as a genuine top-tier recommendation."
Negative"stang54 expressed surprise at seeing an Applebee's in Times Square with a line around the corner during a first-time visit to NYC."
Neutral
