An enduring NYC institution known for its classic American fare and consistently praised burgers, with notable lobster rolls and Rhode Island-style calamari.
PJ Clarke's stands as a beloved institution in the New York City dining scene, consistently praised for its classic American fare and inviting atmosphere. It's a go-to spot for many, especially for its highly-regarded burgers, which have earned it a reputation as a reliable purveyor of this quintessential American dish. Beyond burgers, the lobster rolls have also garnered positive mentions, adding another layer to its appealing menu. The restaurant offers a unique Rhode Island-style calamari, setting it apart from typical seafood offerings. While many long-time patrons and new visitors alike appreciate its consistent quality and status as a dependable establishment, a few voices suggest that while still good, the food might not reach the same heights it once did for some. Nevertheless, PJ Clarke's remains a solid choice for a satisfying meal, whether you're seeking a classic burger, a taste of their well-loved lobster rolls, or a generally pleasant dining experience.
PJ Clarke's is celebrated for its classic American cuisine, with a particular emphasis on its burgers, which are consistently recommended. Customers also enjoy the lobster rolls. The restaurant offers a Rhode Island-style calamari. While many consider it an institution with enduring quality, one opinion suggests that the burgers, while still good, are now considered average compared to their past reputation. Overall, the food is viewed as reliable and satisfying.
"The burgers are highly recommended and considered a signature dish. The lobster rolls are also noted as a great option."
Customers generally have a positive view of PJ Clarke's, often referring to it as an institution and a reliable choice for classic American fare. The burgers are frequently highlighted as a must-try, with some patrons even recommending the lobster rolls. While most feedback is favorable, a few opinions suggest that while still good, the quality might be considered average by some compared to its past reputation.
Important Note
One opinion suggests that while still good, the burgers at PJ Clarke's may now be considered average compared to their past reputation.
"The commenter includes P.J. Clarke's in their list of other spots to consider in NYC, implying a positive recommendation, likely for its classic American fare and burgers."
Positive"The author recommends PJ Clarke for a burger and Bloody Mary, stating it "can't miss"."
Positive"Explains that PJ Clarke's used to have great burgers but is now average."
Neutral"Recommends PJ Clarke's in Midtown for a classic NY 'beers and burgers' experience."
Positive"Likes PJ Clarke's burgers despite the rising prices."
Positive"Expresses continued love for PJ Clarke's despite it being trendy to hate."
Positive"Suggests sitting at the bar at PJ Clarke's, located right across the street from Lincoln Center, for a potentially quick meal."
Positive"The commenter lists PJ Clarke’s as a recommendation."
Neutral"A commenter suggested PJ Clarke's as a basic restaurant option suitable for someone with a simple palate."
Positive"I like PJ Clarkes"
Positive"David Burke and PJ Clarkes"
Neutral"Love PJ Clarkes"
Positive"The lobster rolls are great too!"
Positive"PJ Clarkes is fine."
Neutral"An institution and still serves out some great burgers."
Positive"PJ Clarkes does a Rhode Island Style calamari!"
Positive
