TLDR
Classic, well-priced burgers and comfort food favorites. A convenient, no-fuss go-to near the heart of the Broadway theater district.
Reddit Sentiment for FIVE NAPKIN BURGER(based on 31 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
This post highlights the 5N Patty Melt from 5 Napkin Burger, describing it as a perfect fusion of a burger and a grilled cheese. The sandwich is meticulously prepared with high-quality ingredients including imported Gruyère and white American cheeses, caramelized onions, and a rosemary garlic aioli, all nestled between two slices of toasted Texas bread. The visual appeal is emphasized, showcasing the melted cheese and hearty patty.
5 Napkin Burger is presented as an ideal destination for Father's Day celebrations, offering a menu centered around burgers. The post specifically mentions their stacked burgers, crispy sides, wings, milkshakes, and a selection of cold drinks. They also offer gift cards, suggesting a way to treat fathers to a meal at their convenience. The restaurant is noted for being in the Upper West Side and Hell's Kitchen areas of NYC.
Details
Known for stacked burgers and an unpretentious American menu, this spot is a frequent recommendation for those looking for a reliable, fairly-priced meal near Times Square and Broadway [1], [2]. While some patrons appreciate its consistent quality and welcoming atmosphere [3], others caution that it may lean toward being a tourist-focused establishment with mediocre options [4]. The menu features a variety of satisfying classics, including their notable 5N Patty Melt, wings, and milkshakes [5], [6].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American staples, highlighted by their signature stacked burgers and the 5N Patty Melt, which features Gruyère, caramelized onions, and rosemary aioli on Texas toast [5], [6]. Customers also enjoy the wings, salads, and frozen margaritas, with the restaurant successfully accommodating vegetarians through Impossible and veggie burger options [3], [5].
Caveats
Some visitors may find the restaurant crowded, and critics have suggested that diners looking for more artisanal or sophisticated burger experiences might prefer other neighborhood alternatives [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About FIVE NAPKIN BURGER
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Wheres The Good Food In Midtown Thats Not 50 And
"Listed as one of the user's favorites in Hell’s Kitchen."
PositiveFrom post: What Burgers Should I Eat During A Week Off From
"Listed 5 Napkin Burger as a casual burger spot."
PositiveFrom post: Something Easy Lunch Or Dinner For 2 Demoralized
"Five Napkin Burger is recommended as a place that can satisfy hunger and emotional needs."
PositiveFrom post: Tried Nycs Most Expensive Burger And Its Not
"This user suggested going to 5 Napkin instead."
NeutralFrom post: Best Onion Rings
"This user mentioned 5 Napkin Burger in the context of onion rings."
NeutralFrom post: Your Favorite Go To Restaurant That Doesnt Break
"Recommends Five Napkin Burger."
PositiveFrom post: Brunch This Sunday Before Bway Show
"This user inquired about Five Napkin Burger as a potential brunch spot for a group with potentially picky eaters near Times Square."
NeutralFrom post: Black Iron Burger Taste Was A Pleasant Surprise
"Acknowledging the previous comment, this user agreed that Cubbies' fries are great."
PositiveFrom post: Black Iron Burger Taste Was A Pleasant Surprise
"This user stated that Cubbies "sucks" but acknowledged that Lovely's offers a "completely different burger and experience.""
NeutralFrom post: Black Iron Burger Taste Was A Pleasant Surprise
"This commenter dismissed 5 Napkin Burger as "Propaganda" with "mediocre food" and suggested Lovely and Cubbies as better burger options."
NegativeFrom post: Black Iron Burger Taste Was A Pleasant Surprise
"In response to criticism, this user defended 5 Napkin Burger by stating the food is fine, it's close to theaters, and not prohibitively expensive."
PositiveFrom post: Black Iron Burger Taste Was A Pleasant Surprise
"This user strongly disagreed with the recommendation of 5 Napkin Burger, calling it a "major tourist trap.""
NegativeFrom post: Black Iron Burger Taste Was A Pleasant Surprise
"This user mentioned 5 Napkin Burger as a preferred alternative to Black Iron Burger."
PositiveFrom post: Burgers Cooked To Order In Midtown
"The commenter finds 5 Napkin Burger to be consistently good, fairly priced, and a solid option, especially when looking for something easy."
PositiveFrom post: Burgers Cooked To Order In Midtown
"This commenter considers 5 Napkin Burger a go-to spot due to its good taste, reasonable price, convenient location, and excellent bartender."
PositiveFrom post: Burgers Cooked To Order In Midtown
"5 Napkin is mentioned as a place for burgers."
PositiveFrom post: Burgers Cooked To Order In Midtown
"5 Napkin Burger is a classic choice for a good, well-priced burger cooked to order, though medium-rare was a bit too rare for the commenter on a previous visit. They also recommend the frozen pomegranate margarita."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Daughters 13th Birthday Dinner
"Five Napkin Burger is mentioned as a potential fit for the group's dining needs."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Food Drink Spots For A Jfk Arrival
"Suggests 5 Napkin Burger on 45th & 9th if the desired dining time is before 4 pm."
NeutralFrom post: Good Moderately Priced Food Places For Kids
"5 Napkin Burger was recommended as a dining option when near Broadway, though the commenter cautioned about budget limitations for a group of five at sit-down establishments."
Positive