Juicy burgers & creative cocktails. Your go-to for post-show bites & casual hangs.
A classic American eatery, this spot is celebrated for its generous portions and consistently good burgers. It's a reliable choice for a satisfying meal, especially appealing for those seeking familiar comfort food done well. The atmosphere makes it a go-to for casual dining and post-show meals.
The restaurant is a popular spot for American cuisine, with a strong emphasis on its burgers, which are frequently recommended. Customers also enjoy the frozen pomegranate margarita. While generally well-regarded, there's some debate about its place among other burger establishments.
"The burgers are a consistent highlight, and the frozen pomegranate margarita is also frequently recommended."
Customers generally have positive experiences, frequently recommending the burgers and appreciating the casual, reliable atmosphere. Some find it a good value, while others debate its standing among burger joints.
Important Note
Some diners have found the medium-rare burgers to be cooked too rare, and there are differing opinions on whether it's a "tourist trap" or a solid, well-priced option.
"Acknowledging the previous comment, this user agreed that Cubbies' fries are great."
Positive"This user stated that Cubbies "sucks" but acknowledged that Lovely's offers a "completely different burger and experience.""
Neutral"This commenter dismissed 5 Napkin Burger as "Propaganda" with "mediocre food" and suggested Lovely and Cubbies as better burger options."
Negative"In response to criticism, this user defended 5 Napkin Burger by stating the food is fine, it's close to theaters, and not prohibitively expensive."
Positive"This user strongly disagreed with the recommendation of 5 Napkin Burger, calling it a "major tourist trap.""
Negative"This user mentioned 5 Napkin Burger as a preferred alternative to Black Iron Burger."
Positive"The commenter finds 5 Napkin Burger to be consistently good, fairly priced, and a solid option, especially when looking for something easy."
Positive"This commenter considers 5 Napkin Burger a go-to spot due to its good taste, reasonable price, convenient location, and excellent bartender."
Positive"5 Napkin is mentioned as a place for burgers."
Positive"5 Napkin Burger is a classic choice for a good, well-priced burger cooked to order, though medium-rare was a bit too rare for the commenter on a previous visit. They also recommend the frozen pomegranate margarita."
Positive"Five Napkin Burger is mentioned as a potential fit for the group's dining needs."
Positive"Suggests 5 Napkin Burger on 45th & 9th if the desired dining time is before 4 pm."
Neutral"5 Napkin Burger was recommended as a dining option when near Broadway, though the commenter cautioned about budget limitations for a group of five at sit-down establishments."
Positive"5 Napkin Burger is listed among several favorite restaurants on 9th Avenue."
Positive"5 Napkin Burger is listed as a restaurant option near Times Square."
Positive"5 Napkin Burger is suggested as good for kids, with the commenter highlighting their favorite veggie burger and noting it accommodates vegetarians well."
Positive"5 Napkin Burger is suggested as a simple and straightforward dining option. The restaurant offers an impossible burger and salads."
Neutral"This user contrasts the Black Label Burger with Five Napkin Burger, suggesting the former is more sophisticated."
Neutral"This user dismisses Five Napkin Burger as a worthwhile comparison."
Negative"This user expresses surprise that Five Napkin Burger is still open."
Neutral
