Historic NYC cafe serving legendary burgers, steak frites & chili since 1847. Oldest cafe w/ a timeless vibe.
Step into a piece of New York history at Fanelli Cafe, an establishment that has been serving the city since 1847. This legendary spot offers a classic American cafe experience, perfect for soaking in the vibrant atmosphere of the city. While it's known for its historic charm, patrons also rave about its delicious burgers, standout steak frites, and comforting chili, making it a go-to for both a taste of the past and satisfying comfort food.
Fanelli Cafe is celebrated for its classic American fare, with a particular standout being their steak frites, described by some as the best in the city, especially when ordered with fried onions. Burgers and chili also receive high marks, suggesting a solid menu of comforting dishes. One mention of a 'heavenly' ham and cheese croissant from the past hints at potential hidden gems, though its current availability is uncertain.
"Fanelli Cafe is highly recommended for its steak frites, burgers, and chili. The steak frites, in particular, are noted as a city favorite, with suggestions to enhance the dish with fried onions."
Customers consistently praise Fanelli Cafe for its historic ambiance and classic American comfort food, with specific mentions of excellent burgers, steak frites, and chili. It's regarded as a beloved, enduring spot with a lively atmosphere.
Important Note
The availability of some previously popular items, like the ham and cheese croissant, may be uncertain.
"Fanelli Cafe at Prince and Mercer used to serve the best steak frites in the city, especially with fried onions on top."
Positive"This user also recommended Fanellis, mentioning it alongside other establishments."
Positive"This user co-signed the recommendation for Fanellis."
Positive"This user recommended Fanellis for chili."
Positive"This commenter suggested Fanellis, along with Kenn's, as places that give them the vibe of old New York, noting they are more divey."
Neutral"Fanelli Cafe was suggested as an option, with a specific mention of their great fries."
Positive"This user suggests Fanelli's as a classic spot for people-watching outside in the afternoon or evening."
Positive"Fanellis, located next door to Sartiano's, was described as a more laid-back option."
Positive"Fanelli Cafe is noted for having the commenter's favorite steak frites in the city, suggesting to ask for fried onions and Tabasco with it."
Positive"Fanelli Cafe was recommended by a commenter who stated it is "always fun," suggesting a lively and enjoyable casual dining experience."
Positive"User 'shiftyasluck' recalls that Fanelli Cafe used to offer a 'heavenly' ham and cheese croissant which had to be specifically requested. The past tense implies uncertainty about current availability."
Neutral"Henrygrins recommends Fanelli Cafe for its history and atmosphere."
Positive"Recommends Fanelli’s (Fanelli Cafe) for burgers."
Positive
