TLDR
Classic NYC steakhouse charm with a legendary personal touch, offering great value for premium cuts.
Reddit Sentiment for CLUB A STEAKHOUSE(based on 15 Reddit opinions)
Details
Known for its warm, personal hospitality and vibrant interior, this establishment has built a loyal following among steak enthusiasts [1]. Diners frequently highlight the high quality of the meat and the value offered, particularly during special promotional menus [10]. While many guests praise the attentive service and unique owner engagement [1], [8], some have noted mixed experiences regarding consistency in food quality and presentation [11], [15].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic American steakhouse fare, with the filet mignon and thick-cut bacon receiving specific praise for their preparation and quality [10]. The mac and cheese is frequently cited as a standout side dish [10], though some diners have noted the lack of traditional options like french fries [6]. Some negative feedback has been directed at the quality of the steak and dessert presentation during certain visits [11], [15].
Customer Sentiment
Overall sentiment is largely positive, with many guests praising the impeccable service and the owner's warm, personal engagement [8]. However, there is a divide in opinion, as some visitors have reported inconsistent experiences with food quality and presentation compared to other city staples [11], [15].
Caveats
Some diners have expressed concerns regarding inconsistent food quality and dated presentation of certain menu items [11], [15]. Others have noted that while the restaurant offers great value, it may not reach the same level as historical landmarks like Peter Luger or Keens [6], [14].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About CLUB A STEAKHOUSE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Delmonicos Worth It Or Try Another Steakhouse
"The user likes them a lot."
PositiveFrom post: Club A Steakhouse 58th Street And 2nd Ave Great
"The user visited years ago for a birthday and found the experience disappointing compared to other steakhouses."
NegativeFrom post: Club A Steakhouse 58th Street And 2nd Ave Great
"The user found the restaurant to be dreadful during their visit and notes there are many better steak options in NYC."
NegativeFrom post: Club A Steakhouse 58th Street And 2nd Ave Great
"The user had a negative experience last year with poor quality steak and tiramisu, and finds the restaurant untempting as a local resident."
NegativeFrom post: Club A Steakhouse 58th Street And 2nd Ave Great
"The user criticized the presentation of the chocolate sauce drizzle on the dessert."
NeutralFrom post: Club A Steakhouse 58th Street And 2nd Ave Great
"The user commented on the high price of wine, though later clarified they hadn't considered the Restaurant Week pricing at the time."
NeutralFrom post: Club A Steakhouse 58th Street And 2nd Ave Great
"The author enjoyed their Restaurant Week experience, noting the excellent value of the four-course menu which includes standard menu items like the filet mignon and mac and cheese."
PositiveFrom post: Where Did The Ny Strips Go Where Are They Best
"The commenter shares a very positive experience involving impeccable service and complimentary food, noting the owner's personal engagement."
PositiveFrom post: The Steakoff Best Value
"This commenter asked if Club A is significantly better than Keens or Peter Luger, or if it belongs to a different category."
NeutralFrom post: The Steakoff Best Value
"This commenter made a humorous remark about Club A being a person's pool, but confirmed it offers good value for steak, though without french fries."
PositiveFrom post: The Steakoff Best Value
"This commenter suggested Club A as a good steak option."
PositiveFrom post: Restaurants In Nyc That Have Impressed You With
"Club A was mentioned as a restaurant recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: Mightiest Steakhouses In Nyc Keens Next
"The commenter suggests trying Club A Steakhouse, stating it definitely has a great steak."
PositiveFrom post: Mightiest Steakhouses In Nyc Keens Next
"Club A Steakhouse is listed among the user's favorite steakhouses."
PositiveFrom post: Bowery Meat Co Vs Strip House Vs Wolfgang
"The user had a great experience at Club A, highlighting its fun interior and a nice owner who provided a graduation card and a group polaroid."
Positive