A premier NYC steakhouse w/ a fun interior & a great owner. Top-tier dry-aged steaks, bacon, burgers, & an extensive wine list.
This classic Manhattan steakhouse offers a delightful dining experience with a strong emphasis on high-quality meats and a sophisticated atmosphere. Patrons rave about the excellent steaks, including dry-aged porterhouses and ribeyes, as well as other popular items like the thick-cut steakhouse bacon and a highly-rated dry-aged burger. The extensive wine list and classic sides further enhance the meal, making it a top choice for steak lovers.
The steakhouse excels in its meat offerings, with dry-aged porterhouses, ribeyes, and a notable dry-aged burger being fan favorites. Thick-cut steakhouse bacon and a massive shrimp cocktail are also highly recommended starters. Classic sides like mashed potatoes, mac n' cheese, and creamed spinach complement the rich flavors of the main courses, all supported by a sophisticated wine list.
"Standout dishes include the thick-cut steakhouse bacon, dry-aged porterhouses, ribeyes, and the highly-praised dry-aged burger. The massive shrimp cocktail is also a recommended starter."
Customers generally have a very positive experience, highlighting the fun interior, a welcoming owner, and excellent steak options. The food is consistently praised, with specific recommendations for various cuts and appetizers.
Important Note
One user humorously noted that while Club A offers good value for steak, it does not come with french fries.
"This commenter asked if Club A is significantly better than Keens or Peter Luger, or if it belongs to a different category."
Neutral"This commenter made a humorous remark about Club A being a person's pool, but confirmed it offers good value for steak, though without french fries."
Positive"This commenter suggested Club A as a good steak option."
Positive"Club A was mentioned as a restaurant recommendation."
Positive"The commenter suggests trying Club A Steakhouse, stating it definitely has a great steak."
Positive"Club A Steakhouse is listed among the user's favorite steakhouses."
Positive"The user had a great experience at Club A, highlighting its fun interior and a nice owner who provided a graduation card and a group polaroid."
Positive"Recommends Club A Steakhouse as a good alternative to Gallagher's and Strip House."
Positive"Believes Club A Steakhouse is superior to Gallagher's, Delmonico's, and Wolfgang's."
Positive"Club A Steakhouse is suggested as a dining option."
Positive"Briefly suggests Club A Steakhouse as an option for the original poster's steak request."
Neutral
