Next.js logo

CLUB A STEAKHOUSE

Last Updated: ~1 month ago

Phone: (212) 688-4190

Address: 240 EAST 58 STREET 10022

TLDR

Top NYC steakhouse w/ dry-aged porterhouses & thick-cut bacon. A sophisticated choice.

Sentiment Overview(Based on 5 Reddit comments)

80% Positive20% Neutral

Achievements and Accolades

Next.js logo

Tags

steakhouse 3american 3steak 3View All

Neighborhoods

Midtown

Instagram Posts References

Summary

Details

This esteemed New York City steakhouse is a premier destination for meat enthusiasts and those seeking a classic, upscale dining experience. Praised for its exceptional quality, it's often recommended over other well-known establishments. The menu boasts a robust selection of expertly prepared steaks, including highly-rated Dry Aged Porterhouses and Ribeyes, alongside thick-cut Steakhouse Bacon and a standout Dry Aged Burger. The raw bar, featuring impressive Shrimp Cocktails, adds to the allure. Traditional steakhouse sides such as creamy Mashed Potatoes, Mac n’ Cheese, and Creamed Spinach are perfectly executed to complement the main courses. The establishment also features an impressive wine list, making it a complete package for a memorable meal.

Food Overview

This steakhouse is highly regarded for its classic American steakhouse fare, with a particular emphasis on high-quality, dry-aged cuts. Standout dishes include thick-cut Steakhouse Bacon, Dry Aged Porterhouses, Ribeyes, and an exceptional Dry Aged Burger. The raw bar offerings, such as massive Shrimp Cocktail, are also a hit. Complementing the meat-centric menu are classic savory sides like Mashed Potatoes, Mac n’ Cheese, and Creamed Spinach. A sophisticated wine list is also a notable feature, enhancing the overall dining experience.

Highlights / Recommended

"Highly recommended dishes include the thick-cut Steakhouse Bacon, Dry Aged Porterhouses, Ribeyes, and the Dry Aged Burger, all praised for their quality and flavor."

Customer Sentiment

Customers have a very positive view of this steakhouse, with many recommending it as a top-tier option in NYC. It's frequently suggested as a superior alternative to other well-known steakhouses. The food, particularly the steaks and classic sides, receives high praise, with specific mentions of thick-cut bacon, dry-aged porterhouses, burgers, and a well-curated wine list. The overall dining experience is described as very pleasant.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

This user believes Club A Steakhouse is a superior choice compared to other popular steakhouses like Gallagher's, Delmonico's, and Wolfgang's, making it a strong contender for a special occasion.
Another recommendation highlights Club A Steakhouse as a great alternative to Gallagher's and Strip House, suggesting it offers a comparable or better experience.
This post briefly suggests Club A Steakhouse as a viable option for someone looking for a great steak in the city.
Club A Steakhouse is mentioned as a suitable dining choice for a pre-event meal, indicating its convenience and appeal for a nice night out.

Recent Mentions

From post: Which Steakhouse For My Bfs Birthday Dinner

"Recommends Club A Steakhouse as a good alternative to Gallagher's and Strip House."

Positive
Jul 17, 2025View Comment →

From post: Which Steakhouse For My Bfs Birthday Dinner

"Believes Club A Steakhouse is superior to Gallagher's, Delmonico's, and Wolfgang's."

Positive
Jul 16, 2025View Comment →

From post: Dinner Before Date Night At The Met

"Club A Steakhouse is suggested as a dining option."

Positive
May 13, 2025View Comment →

From post: Need A Good Steak

"Briefly suggests Club A Steakhouse as an option for the original poster's steak request."

Neutral
May 8, 2025View Comment →