Must-try Southern comfort food in Brooklyn: amazing fried chicken, divine pies, & crave-worthy chicken biscuits. Don't miss the fried pickles!
This Brooklyn eatery is a haven for those craving Southern comfort food with a New York twist. It's particularly celebrated for its exceptional fried chicken, often compared to the best in the South, and its decadent pies that have garnered a devoted following. The menu also features standout items like the chicken biscuit sandwich and inventive appetizers such as deep-fried pickle chips, making it a go-to spot for satisfying, hearty meals.
This spot excels in Southern American cuisine, with fried chicken being a major highlight, frequently praised for its quality and flavor. The pies, especially pecan and banana cream, are also a strong draw. However, some feedback suggests the gravy can be too thin. Appetizers like deep-fried pickle chips have also received positive mentions.
"The fried chicken and various pies, particularly the pecan pie, are consistently recommended. The chicken biscuit sandwich and deep-fried pickle chips are also highlighted as must-try items."
Customers generally rave about the authentic Southern flavors, especially the fried chicken and pies, though some find certain dishes like the gravy to be less impressive. The restaurant is considered a strong contender in the NYC fried chicken scene.
Important Note
One commenter noted that the gravy at Pies n Thighs was very thin and almost watery. Another user mentioned that while the restaurant offers comfort food, it might not be comparable to authentic Southern cuisine for some.
"Pies 'n' Thighs on S 4th St in Brooklyn is recommended for their deep-fried pickle chips, served with ranch dipping sauce."
Positive"This user recommends Pies n Thighs as a restaurant in NYC that serves fried chicken with waffles."
Positive"Pies & Thighs in Williamsburg is mentioned as a passable option for traditional Southern food, although it requires travel from Washington Square Park."
Neutral"A user expressed strong positive sentiment about the news related to Pies 'n' Thighs, calling it the best news they've heard all year."
Positive"A user inquired about the opening date of Pies 'n' Thighs, expressing a desire to dine there."
Neutral"The author mentioned trying the Banana Cream Pie at Pies 'n' Thighs."
Neutral"Pies and Thighs is a restaurant that is not too far from the Fort Greene area."
Positive"This commenter, identifying as Southern, stated that Pies n Thighs is not comparable."
Negative"This commenter, identifying as Southern, stated that Pies n Thighs is not comparable."
Negative"This user recommended Pies n Thighs."
Negative"This user recommended Pies n Thighs."
Negative"The commenter states that Thighs and Pies (likely referring to Pies and Thighs) has great fried chicken, though unsure if it's still open."
Positive"Pies and Thighs is listed among several other recommendations for fried chicken."
Positive"This user provided a Yelp link for 'Pies n Thighs' in Chinatown, mentioning it was a go-to breakfast/lunch spot for a while."
Neutral"This user mentioned missing the 'Chinatown pies and thighs' and in a separate comment, noted that the newer Popeyes chicken sandwich isn't as good as its initial launch but is still solid."
Neutral"This user mentioned missing the 'Chinatown pies and thighs' and in a separate comment, noted that the newer Popeyes chicken sandwich isn't as good as its initial launch but is still solid."
Neutral"This user recommended the chicken biscuit sandwich at Pies n Thighs in Williamsburg, expressing a strong craving for it."
Positive"Pies n Thighs is listed as a great casual option."
Positive"Pies n Thighs in Williamsburg is highly praised for its on-the-bone fried chicken, comparing it favorably to Southern fried chicken and even Popeyes."
Positive"The commenter lists Pies N Thighs, noting that they aren't as touristy anymore."
Neutral
