Kaitlyn Rosati reviews Emmett's, a Soho restaurant serving authentic Chicago-style pizza, noting its cozy atmosphere and delicious deep-dish and tavern-style pies.
Details
Located in Soho, this spot brings authentic Chicago-style pizza to Manhattan, featuring both iconic deep-dish pies and crispy thin-crust tavern styles [1]. The atmosphere is moody and intimate, offering a quintessential neighborhood feel with both indoor and outdoor seating options [1]. While pizza remains the main draw, the menu also rounds out with various Chicago-inspired classics like Italian beef sandwiches and bleu cheese-stuffed burgers [1].
Food Overview
Specializing in Chicago-style cuisine, the menu centers on deep-dish pies that are generously topped and require a knife and fork, alongside thin, crispy tavern-style pizzas [1]. Other offerings include a Chicago-style hot dog, Italian beef sandwiches, and a bleu cheese-stuffed burger [1]. While some enjoy the pizza options, others have found the quality to be mediocre [2].
The deep-dish pie is a standout, and the thin Chicago-style tavern pie is equally regarded as a must-try [1].
Feedback is generally positive regarding the casual, inviting atmosphere and efficient service [1], though experiences with the pizza quality can be mixed among diners [2].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01fries2 mentions
- 02pizza2 mentions
Caveats
The deep-dish pie requires a 30-40 minute wait for preparation [1]. Additionally, happy hour specials are restricted to the bar area only [1].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About EMMETT'S
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Cuisinesdishes In Nyc That I Cant Find In Toronto
"Chicago tavern style pizza, different from standard Toronto options."
PositiveFrom post: Expats And Transplants Of Nyc What Is Your
"Rated as 'meh' for their pizza, contrary to some other expectations."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For Restaurants Recommendations Near
"Emmett's was suggested as a good sitdown pizza place nearby, described as not fancy but nicer than a typical slice joint, suitable for lunch or early dinner."
Positive