TLDR
LA-born donut icon now in the heart of Manhattan. Serving up classic raised donuts and highly-regarded apple fritters.
Instagram Posts References
This restaurant is listed in The Chicago Food Index.
Randy's Donuts, a well-known donut chain originating from the West Coast, is expanding to Manhattan with its second location set to open on Second Avenue. The brand is recognized for its iconic giant donut rooftop sign. This expansion marks a significant step for the chain in establishing a presence in New York City.
Details
Originating from the West Coast, this iconic donut shop has brought its classic American treats to Manhattan [1]. Visitors can enjoy a variety of raised donut flavors, ranging from classic glazed to M&M and Nutella topped varieties [1]. While some enjoy the offerings, opinions on the overall quality remain mixed among locals [2], [3].
Food Overview
This spot serves a variety of American-style raised donuts, including options like Oreo, S'mores, and chocolate-frosted varieties [1]. The apple fritter is frequently cited as a standout menu item worth ordering [4], [5], though some diners note that the standard donut offerings may not match the perfection of traditional West Coast Cambodian-style shops [6].
The apple fritter is widely considered a great choice at this location [4], [5]. Additionally, regulars often gravitate toward the maple bars and chocolate iced buttermilk donuts [4].
Customer reception is polarizing, with some regulars enjoying the maple bars and apple fritters [4], [5], while others find the overall quality underwhelming or not quite hitting the mark compared to West Coast counterparts [2], [3], [6].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01apple fritter2 mentions
Caveats
Some visitors have noted that the quality can be inconsistent or underwhelming compared to expectations [2], [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About RANDY'S DONUTS
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Apple Fritter Where Can I One Like The One From
"The shop on Bleecker is recommended as a good option for apple fritters."
PositiveFrom post: Apple Fritter Where Can I One Like The One From
"A brief mention that this location in the West Village offers an apple fritter."
NeutralFrom post: Expats And Transplants Of Nyc What Is Your
"This donut shop is considered close to the style sought after, but not quite perfect."
NeutralFrom post: Where To Find The Best Coffee Roll In Nyc Not
"Stated that the quality is not good at all."
NegativeFrom post: Where To Find The Best Coffee Roll In Nyc Not
"Noted as a place with a great apple fritter."
Positive