TLDR
Theatrical bagel service, elevated brunch staples, and upscale Jewish appetizing in the heart of Soho. Perfect for a celebratory splurge.
Instagram Posts References
The post showcases two salads from Sadelle's Soho, presenting them as visually appealing and diverse options. The focus then shifts to the Edere app, which is promoted as a tool that provides allergen information and suggests modifications for dishes, thereby enhancing the dining experience and reducing anxiety for individuals with food sensitivities. The author encourages readers to sign up for the Edere waitlist.
Sadelle's is a top recommendation for brunch, particularly for its incredible in-house made gluten-free bagels and the recommendation to order a full tower for the experience.
Details
This upscale, Major Food Group-operated destination in Soho reimagines the classic Jewish appetizing experience with dramatic flair [4]. Known for its theatrically served bagels and extensive brunch menu, the spot is widely celebrated as a quintessential New York experience for special occasions [4], [13]. While consistently praised for its vibrant atmosphere and quality dishes, diners frequently note that the pricing is on the higher side [9], [13].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on elevated American-Jewish fare, highlighted by house-made bagels served hot on dowels [1], [3] and an impressive array of smoked fish spreads like salmon, sable, and whitefish [4]. Standout dishes frequently recommended include the tuna melt [8], scrambled eggs [23], the Grapefruit Brûlée [17], and the egg-and-cheese roti [3]. Some diners also enjoy the unique bagel tower experience for groups [19].
Highlights / Recommended
"The tuna melt is highly regarded as a standout item [8], along with the house-made bagels [1], scrambled eggs [23], Grapefruit Brûlée [17], and the egg-and-cheese roti [3]."
Customer Sentiment
Overall, the sentiment is strongly positive, with many diners considering it a go-to spot for birthday brunches and special meals [9], [13]. While the food and atmosphere receive consistent acclaim, some patrons note that portions can be small and the price point reflects a premium 'splurge' experience [8], [13].
Caveats
The restaurant is widely considered to be on the expensive side, and some guests find the portion sizes, such as the tuna melt, to be small [8], [13]. Additionally, one user advised against using gift cards there, suggesting other locations under the same ownership group might be better suited for that purpose [16].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About SADELLE'S
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where Are The Best Bagels To Pair With A Spread
"This user suggests going to Sadelle's on West Broadway and Houston."
PositiveFrom post: Rent Out Bagel Spot For Brunch Nyc
"Sadelle's was suggested for private events, with a note that it is likely to be expensive. A link to their private events page was provided."
NeutralFrom post: Rent Out Bagel Spot For Brunch Nyc
"This user recommended renting a room at Dirty French on the Lower East Side and having it catered by Sadelle's, which is its sister establishment."
NeutralFrom post: Rent Out Bagel Spot For Brunch Nyc
"Sadelle's was mentioned as a potential option for private events, though it's noted as being more of a restaurant than a dedicated bagel shop."
NeutralFrom post: Rent Out Bagel Spot For Brunch Nyc
"This user suggested Sadelle's as a possibility for a buyout, acknowledging it's more of a restaurant than a bagel shop but does offer private events and a bagel tower."
NeutralFrom post: Soft Scrambeled Eggs Rec
"Commenter recommends Sadelle's for scrambled eggs."
PositiveFrom post: Seeking Your Favorite Grapefruit Drinksdishes
"The user recommended the Grapefruit Brûlée at Sadelles, which the original poster found to be a great suggestion."
PositiveFrom post: French Toast Date Ideas
"This user simply stated that Sadelle's is great."
PositiveFrom post: Major Food Group Opinions
"This commenter advises against using a gift card at Sadelle's, suggesting any other Major Food Group restaurant in the city would be a better choice."
NegativeFrom post: Classic Chicken Noodle Soup
"Sadelle's was suggested as a place to get chicken noodle soup."
PositiveFrom post: Itinerary Review For 4day Birthday Visit
"The user decides to consider Sadelle's for breakfast after discussing it with another commenter."
NeutralFrom post: Itinerary Review For 4day Birthday Visit
"This commenter recommends Sadelle's for the birthday breakfast, highlighting its great vibes and delicious food, describing it as 'very New Yorky'. They acknowledge it's a bit pricey but suitable for a birthday."
PositiveFrom post: Itinerary Review For 4day Birthday Visit
"The user is considering Sadelle's for their fianc ext{é}e's birthday breakfast, noting it might be expensive but looks good. They are comparing it with The Temple Court at The Beekman."
NeutralFrom post: Tuna Melt Lower Manhattan
"Clarifying Sadelle's location in SoHo, the commenter assured it was worth the walk from Chinatown."
PositiveFrom post: Tuna Melt Lower Manhattan
"Sadelle's was mentioned as a potential dining option."
PositiveFrom post: Birthday Brunch Recommendations
"This restaurant is recommended for a birthday brunch, with the commenter suggesting it offers a nicer atmosphere and generally good food."
PositiveFrom post: Two Questions 1 Where Is The Best Tuna Melt And 2
"Sadelle's is praised for having the best tuna melt the user has ever had, though it's noted as small and expensive."
PositiveFrom post: Restaurants Near Angelika Houston Street
"This user recommended Sadelle's as a place for a casual nice lunch."
NeutralFrom post: Whats Everyones Favorite Brunch Spot In Manhattan
"A user responds negatively to the mention of Sadelle's."
NegativeFrom post: Whats Everyones Favorite Brunch Spot In Manhattan
"This user reluctantly admits that Sadelle's is a good option."
Positive