Iconic bakery w/ made-to-order jelly donuts, incredible babka & rugelach, and top-tier black & white cookies.
Orwasher's is a beloved New York institution, celebrated for its traditional Jewish baked goods and desserts. Reviewers consistently praise their wide array of offerings, from iconic black and white cookies and jelly donuts filled to order, to exceptional babka and rugelach. While most items receive high marks, some mention that the sourdough bread can be on the drier side.
This bakery specializes in traditional Jewish baked goods and desserts, with particular acclaim for their rugelach, babka, and black and white cookies. Jelly donuts are also a standout, noted for being filled to order. While most items are highly recommended, some customers find the sourdough bread to be dry.
"Highly recommended items include their black and white cookies, jelly donuts (filled to order), rugelach, and babka. Their apple honey cake is also a noteworthy dessert option."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the bakery's traditional Jewish baked goods, frequently recommending specific items like babka, rugelach, and black and white cookies. While the overall sentiment is very positive, a minor note mentions that the sourdough can be dry.
Important Note
Some customers have noted that the sourdough bread can be dry.
"Orwashers has an incredible apple honey cake."
Positive"Agrees that Orwashers has great babka."
Positive"Recommends Orwashers for babka, noting locations on the UES, UWS, and Roslyn (Long Island)."
Positive"Mentioned Orwashers for black and white cookies as an alternative to rainbow cookies from Ferrara."
Positive"This user recommends Orwashers on the UWS, stating it gives William Greenberg a run for their money."
Positive"In response to a question about locations, this user clarifies that Orwasher's has locations on both the UES and UWS, and also has a great black and white cookie."
Positive"This user agrees with recommendations for William Greenberg and Orwashers, and mentions their local deli's cookies were a favorite."
Positive"This user simply comments 'Orwashers' as a recommendation."
Positive"This user recommends Orwashers, along with William Greenberg Desserts, Zaro's (if fresh), and Caputo's in Brooklyn for black and white cookies."
Positive"This user lists Orwashers among several recommendations for black and white cookies."
Neutral"This comment expresses nostalgia for Orwasher's and their babka, referencing a now-closed establishment called Lichtman's."
Neutral"Responding to a comment about disliking black and white cookies, this user, who identifies as Jewish, states they love black and white cookies."
Positive"The user expresses a dislike for black and white cookies, noting that someone is downvoting positive comments about Orwasher's."
Negative"Orwasher's on the Upper West Side is recommended for rugelach and black and white cookies, with their babka also being highlighted as incredible."
Positive"Recommends Orwasher's, especially for cookies, doughnuts, rugelach, bagels, and flatbreads, calling it one of NY's best bakeries. Notes some bread is amazing but sourdough can be dry."
Positive"Recommends Orwasher's for numerous things, including jelly donuts filled to order."
Positive"Recommended Orwasher’s specifically for their black & white cookies."
Positive
