Next.js logo

TUSCANY STEAKHOUSE

Updated

Phone: (718) 918-2684

Address: 117 WEST 58 STREET 10019

View on Google Maps

TLDR

A closing Manhattan steakhouse, once a go-to for reliable American fare and steak, now a memory for many.

Reddit Sentiment for TUSCANY STEAKHOUSE(based on 10 Reddit opinions)

60% Neutral30% Negative

Tags

steakhouse 2steakhouse 2View All

Neighborhoods

Midtown

Details

This classic steakhouse, a staple on West 58th Street, offered a traditional American dining experience. Known for its steaks and ambiance, it was a place many locals frequented for special occasions or a reliable steak fix. Despite its long tenure, it has recently closed its doors.

Food Overview

This steakhouse primarily served American cuisine with a focus on steaks. While some patrons considered it a reliable option, one Reddit comment categorized it as a 'meh' steakhouse, indicating a potentially average or uninspiring food experience for some.

Customer Sentiment

Customer sentiment is mixed, with some expressing sadness at its closure and fond memories, while others noted a lack of noticeable activity, suggesting it might have been a 'meh' experience for some.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About TUSCANY STEAKHOUSE

Tuscany Steakhouse on W58th is closing after 10 years.
This post announces the closure of Tuscany Steakhouse. Multiple commenters express sadness and nostalgia, with one noting it was their go-to place.
A laid-back Brooklyn steakhouse and more NYC.
One user mentions Tuscany Steakhouse in passing, noting they walk by it daily and didn't realize it had closed, suggesting it may not have been very visible. Another user speculates that the scaffolding at its location might have contributed to its struggles.
Mightiest steakhouses in NYC (Keens, next?)
In a discussion about steakhouses, Tuscany Steakhouse is mentioned as a 'meh' option. This suggests it may not have stood out as a top-tier steakhouse for this particular commenter.
Tuscany Steakhouse on W58th is closing after 10 years.
A commenter mentions that Tuscany Steakhouse has a sister restaurant, Il Monello, in Midtown East and expresses interest in trying both establishments.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: A Laidback Brooklyn Steakhouse And More Nyc

"This commenter expressed sadness about Tuscany Steakhouse closing, noting that its location, which was under scaffolding, might have contributed to its struggles. They visited two days before it closed."

Negative
Jan 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: A Laidback Brooklyn Steakhouse And More Nyc

"The commenter mentioned they walk past Tuscany Steakhouse daily and did not realize it had closed, indicating it might not have been very noticeable."

Negative
Jan 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Tuscany Steakhouse On W58th Is Closing After 10

"This commenter expressed sympathy regarding the closure of Tuscany Steakhouse."

Neutral
Dec 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Tuscany Steakhouse On W58th Is Closing After 10

"This commenter mentioned that Tuscany Steakhouse has a sister restaurant called Il Monello in Midtown East and expressed inclination to try both."

Neutral
Dec 29, 2025View Comment →

From post: Tuscany Steakhouse On W58th Is Closing After 10

"This commenter asked if Tuscany Steakhouse was good and expressed intent to visit it that evening."

Neutral
Dec 29, 2025View Comment →

More in Midtown

See all

More Steakhouse in NYC

See all