Last Updated: 14 days ago
Phone: (212) 600-8635
Address: 1410 BROADWAY 10018
Iconic artichoke slices, a polarizing but beloved late-night bite. Rich, decadent flavors with a divisive reputation.
This pizzeria offers a distinct culinary experience with its signature artichoke slice, a polarizing item that some find exceptionally delicious, especially during late-night cravings. While the Margherita and vodka slices also receive praise for their rich and decadent profiles, the restaurant's overall reputation on Reddit is mixed. Some long-time patrons feel it has become too much like a chain, and a few critics find it overrated and overpriced, though many still appreciate the unique flavors it offers.
This pizza spot is known for its unique artichoke slice, which garners both strong recommendations and criticisms, with some describing it as tasting like creamy soup on dough. Other offerings like the Margherita and vodka slices also receive praise for their rich flavors. However, some customers feel the quality has declined over time or that the price for a single slice is too high compared to other options.
"The artichoke slice and the vodka slice are frequently recommended for their unique and rich flavors. The Margherita pizza is also praised."
Customers have mixed feelings about this pizza place. While some enjoy specific slices like the artichoke or vodka, others find it overrated or too rich. There's a notable contrast between those who love it, especially late at night, and those who are critical of its taste and price.
Important Note
The artichoke slice is described by some as tasting like cream of broccoli soup on pizza dough and is considered by some to be best consumed late at night. The price of a single slice is noted as being high.
"The vodka square slice at Artichoke Pizza is considered very good and decadent, featuring a rich vodka sauce and a combination of fresh and whole milk mozzarella. It's enjoyed but not recommended for frequent consumption."
Positive"Artichoke Pizza's Margherita pizza is praised for converting a thin crust hater into a thin crust lover. Their artichoke pizza is also considered phenomenal, though very rich."
Positive"Artichoke Basil is highlighted as a pizza place offering good value with their reasonably priced slices."
Positive"The commenter hasn't had Artichoke's pizza in a long time and would grab a slice as their final meal, anticipating it would make them sleep for the flight."
Positive"Artichoke Basille's Pizza is described as great, particularly mentioning its location in the garment district."
Positive"The price of a single slice of pizza from Artichoke Basille's Pizza is noted to be equivalent to half a pizza obtained through the Too Good To Go app, suggesting it is expensive."
Negative"While Artichoke Basille's Pizza is known to be a divisive topic on Reddit, the commenter personally enjoys their vodka slice."
Positive"The commenter asserts that Artichoke Basille's is one of the most overrated pizza spots in NYC, along with Bleecker St Pizza."
Negative"The author recalls liking Artichoke Pizza 10 years ago but notes it seems more like a chain now."
Neutral"Suggests Artichoke Basille's Pizza."
Positive"While acknowledging it's not exactly what was asked for (a dip), a commenter suggests trying the spinach artichoke pizza slice at Artichoke Pizza."
Neutral"The artichoke slice tastes like Campbell's cream of broccoli soup on pizza dough."
Negative"The artichoke slice is only good when faded at 2am."
Negative"Recommended to get an artichoke slice from multiple Artichoke Basille's locations."
Neutral
