Urban bakery w/ divine cinnamon buns & lauded choco chip cookies. Unique rotating flavors daily!
Willa Moore reviews Red Gate Bakery, an East Village spot known for its outstanding cinnamon buns and chocolate chip cookies, calling them some of the city's best.
This East Village gem is a must-visit for pastry enthusiasts, consistently praised for its exceptional baked goods. From their signature cinnamon buns with their perfectly balanced cinnamon-sugar filling and generous frosting, to their flawless chocolate chip cookies with a delightful buttery flavor, Red Gate Bakery offers a taste of classic American baking at its finest. They also offer creative rotating bun flavors and beautiful cakes, making it a perfect stop for any sweet craving.
Red Gate Bakery is celebrated for its classic American pastries, with a particular emphasis on cinnamon buns and cookies. The cinnamon buns are frequently highlighted for their loose, squishy layers and generous frosting, while their chocolate chip cookies are described as buttery and top-tier. They also offer a variety of other baked goods, including cakes, loaves, and unique rotating bun flavors. While most reviews are highly positive, a few customers have expressed dissatisfaction with specific items.
"The cinnamon buns and chocolate chip cookies are consistently highly recommended. Other popular items include their rotating specialty buns, brownies, and various cakes like the strawberry pistachio cake."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the bakery's exceptional baked goods, particularly their cinnamon buns and cookies, often citing them as some of the best in the city. While most feedback is positive, a few recent comments suggest some inconsistency or disappointment with specific items like cake or buns.
Important Note
Some users have noted that certain items, like cookies, can sell out early in the day. There have also been a few comments suggesting inconsistency in quality for some items, such as cake or buns, and one user mentioned a previous disappointment after being a long-time fan.
"The user tried the banana bread from Red Gate and found it to be a bit cakier and more chocolatey than expected, but they still liked it."
Positive"This user listed 'Red gates midnight banana bread' as a recommendation."
Positive"This user simply recommended 'Red Gate'."
Positive"This user found both Claud chocolate cake and Salty Lunch Lady's Luncheonette to be epic, and has heard good things about Red Gate Bakery but not yet visited."
Neutral"In contrast to another opinion, this user found Red Gate Bakery's cake to be dry and flavorless."
Negative"This user enjoys Red Gate Bakery's cookies but found their birthday cake disappointing due to a lack of flavor and sweetness."
Negative"The Triple Corn cake from Red Gate Bakery is mentioned as a summer special."
Positive"This user recently discovered Red Gate Bakery and enjoys trying their various items, noting the pleasant aroma of the surrounding block."
Positive"Red Gate Bakery offers delicious cakes with daily changing flavors."
Positive"This user found many popular cookies to be too bitter and salty. They had a great experience with the choco-toffee cookie from red gate bakery."
Positive"This user agreed that their last experience with Redgate was disappointing, finding the buns overcooked and dry."
Negative"This user contrasts Loser's soft roll with Redgate's buns, describing the latter as hard and dry."
Negative"Red Gate is mentioned as another option for cinnamon rolls, though not considered Loser's equal by this user."
Neutral"The user considers Redgate Bakery their current favorite cake spot in the city, specifically praising their strawberry pistachio cake with French buttercream."
Positive"This user lists Red Gate Bakery among several other recommendations for cake."
Positive"This user finds Sunday Morning inconsistent and strongly prefers Red Gate Bakery."
Positive"Red Gate Bakery is recommended as an alternative to Sunday Morning."
Positive"Red Gate Bakery's classic cinnamon rolls are available on Wednesdays and Thursdays, with rotating specialty flavors on Fridays and Saturdays. The pastry itself is consistently good, though specialty flavors can be hit or miss."
Positive"Red Gate Bakery offers a specialty cinnamon roll on weekends and their classic roll on Wednesdays and Thursdays."
Positive"Recommends Hani's Bakery and Red Gate Bakery for cinnamon rolls."
Positive
