TLDR
East Village destination for iconic toffee-spiked cookies and squishy, butter-drenched cinnamon buns. Known for artisanal small-batch quality and fast-selling rotating weekend specials.
Reddit Sentiment for RED GATE BAKERY(based on 81 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The Strawberry Rhubarb Shortcake is featured, a beautifully layered cake with what appears to be strawberry and rhubarb filling, and frosting. This dessert looks fresh, fruity, and appealing.
A bakery that provided a 'straw-tachio' cake for a birthday celebration. The cake featured a thick French buttercream.
Redgate Bakery's Choco-Toffee cookie has earned a distinguished spot, being ranked by the author as a definite "Top 3" favorite in New York City. This high praise indicates an exceptional taste and quality that sets it apart.
Willa Moore reviews Red Gate Bakery, an East Village spot known for its outstanding cinnamon buns and chocolate chip cookies, calling them some of the city's best.
Details
Located in the East Village, this bakery is celebrated for its warm, industrious atmosphere and consistently excellent American-style treats [1]. The menu features standout items like squishy, cinnamon-packed buns and buttery, toffee-spiked chocolate chip cookies [1], [2]. While they offer creative, rotating specialty flavors on weekends, the bakery is known for selling out quickly [1], [3].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American baked goods including high-quality cookies, cinnamon buns, and cakes [1]. The toffee-spiked chocolate chip cookie is a widely lauded city favorite [2], [6], while the cinnamon buns—often featuring creative flavors like pavlova or chocolate caramel pretzel—are praised for their soft, layered texture [1], [2]. Although most items receive acclaim, a few customers have criticized certain cakes for lacking flavor or sweetness [5], [7].
Highlights / Recommended
"The toffee-spiked chocolate chip cookie and the classic cinnamon buns are consistently recommended as standout items [1], [2]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •chocolate chip cookie(4)
- •midnight banana bread(3)
- •chocolate chip cookies(2)
- •cinnamon buns(2)
Customer Sentiment
Overall feedback is overwhelmingly positive, with many patrons calling their cookies and cakes some of the best in the city [1], [4]. While the products are highly sought after, some visitors have reported inconsistency in bun quality or disappointment when specific popular items sell out [3], [5].
Caveats
The bakery is closed on Sundays and is known for selling out of popular items early in the day [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About RED GATE BAKERY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For Sour Cream Fudge Chocolate Cake Since
"The bakery serves a chocolate sour cream frosting, though it is paired with yellow cake rather than chocolate cake."
NeutralFrom post: Best Custom Cake In Nyc Both For Design And
"Red Gate Bakery is recommended for custom cakes, noting they offer unique flavors and a tasting experience that was previously around $55 for half a cake."
PositiveFrom post: Best Custom Cake In Nyc Both For Design And
"This bakery was mentioned as a recommendation for custom cakes."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Unique Dessert Spots In Nyc With
"Red Gate Bakery in the East Village is mentioned for offering special cakes on a weekly basis."
NeutralFrom post: Where Can I Find The Best Cinnamon Roll Of All
"This user stated that Red Gate Bakery is the best option."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Find The Best Cinnamon Roll Of All
"This commenter recommended Red Gate Bakery."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Find The Best Cinnamon Roll Of All
"In response to difficulty getting specific flavors, this user noted that Red Gate Bakery's cinnamon roll availability might be why it's slightly below Hani's."
NeutralFrom post: Where Can I Find The Best Cinnamon Roll Of All
"Red Gate was mentioned as a good second choice for cinnamon rolls, after Sunday Morning."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Find The Best Cinnamon Roll Of All
"This user noted that they often have difficulty trying the rotating flavors at Red Gate Bakery."
NeutralFrom post: Where Can I Find The Best Cinnamon Roll Of All
"Red Gate Bakery was listed as a recommended spot for cinnamon rolls by this user."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Find The Best Cinnamon Roll Of All
"Red Gate Bakery is mentioned as a close second to Hani's, known for rotating interesting cinnamon roll flavors."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Find The Best Cinnamon Roll Of All
"This commenter recommended Red Gate Bakery for cinnamon rolls."
PositiveFrom post: Nyc Cookies Ranking 12 Spots From Lower Manhattan
"This user suggests trying Red Gate Bakery for their cookies, calling them the best."
PositiveFrom post: Nyc Cookies Ranking 12 Spots From Lower Manhattan
"This user praises Red Gate Bakery's toffee chocolate chip cookie, calling it amazing."
PositiveFrom post: Nyc Cookies Ranking 12 Spots From Lower Manhattan
"Red Gate Bakery is listed as a bakery to consider for future cookie rankings."
NeutralFrom post: Nyc Cookies Ranking 12 Spots From Lower Manhattan
"This user highly recommends Red Gate Bakery's 'Everything cookie', stating it's excellent, although they are unsure if they make a plain chocolate chip cookie."
PositiveFrom post: Best Bakery Near Grand Central Station These Days
"Red Gate is listed as one of many good bakery options in the East Village."
PositiveFrom post: Seeking Snickerdoodle Cookie Anywhere In 5
"The user suggests Red Gate Bakery has a 'cardamoodle' cookie, noting that standard snickerdoodles can be seasonal at better bakeries."
PositiveFrom post: Local Ny Birthday Food Crawl East Village And
"Red Gate was suggested as an option for sandwiches, pastries, and baked goods, and is located along the proposed route."
PositiveFrom post: Rhubarb Season 2026
"This commenter expects Red Gate Bakery to offer a rhubarb bun or cake slice soon, as they did last year."
Neutral