Award-winning bakery w/ top-tier cinnamon buns & chocolate chip cookies [1]. Also known for unique rotating buns & pastries [1].
Willa Moore reviews Red Gate Bakery, an East Village spot known for its outstanding cinnamon buns and chocolate chip cookies, calling them some of the city's best.
Red Gate Bakery is a highly-regarded East Village bakery celebrated for its exceptional American pastries [1]. They are particularly known for their outstanding cinnamon buns, described as having loose, squishy layers, and their flawless, buttery chocolate chip cookies [1]. The bakery also offers a rotating selection of unique buns on Fridays and Saturdays, such as pavlova or chocolate caramel pretzel varieties [1].
This bakery specializes in classic American pastries, with a strong emphasis on their highly-rated cinnamon buns and chocolate chip cookies [1]. They offer unique, rotating bun flavors on Fridays and Saturdays, alongside a variety of cakes and loaves. Some customers have noted that while the classic cinnamon rolls are a hit, specialty flavors can sometimes be inconsistent [3].
"Highly recommended are the 'OG cinnamon roll' [1], praised for its divine cinnamon and caramel flavors, and the toffee-spiked chocolate chip cookie [1, 2]. The pickled PB&J bar and the cranberry orange muffin have also received specific mentions of praise."
Customers overwhelmingly praise Red Gate Bakery for its exceptional baked goods, with many highlighting the cinnamon buns and chocolate chip cookies as among the city's best [1, 2].
Important Note
One user mentioned that Red Gate Bakery is not open on Sundays [4]. Another commenter noted that while their favorite cinnamon roll from Red Gate used to be consistent, their last experience was disappointing due to an overbaked bun [5]. Some users have also expressed that their cakes can be too sweet or lack flavor [6].
"This user suggests trying Red Gate Bakery for their cookies, calling them the best."
Positive"This user praises Red Gate Bakery's toffee chocolate chip cookie, calling it amazing."
Positive"Red Gate Bakery is listed as a bakery to consider for future cookie rankings."
Neutral"This user highly recommends Red Gate Bakery's 'Everything cookie', stating it's excellent, although they are unsure if they make a plain chocolate chip cookie."
Positive"Red Gate is listed as one of many good bakery options in the East Village."
Positive"The user suggests Red Gate Bakery has a 'cardamoodle' cookie, noting that standard snickerdoodles can be seasonal at better bakeries."
Positive"Red Gate was suggested as an option for sandwiches, pastries, and baked goods, and is located along the proposed route."
Positive"This commenter expects Red Gate Bakery to offer a rhubarb bun or cake slice soon, as they did last year."
Neutral"Red Gate Bakery is suggested as a place to get chocolate chip cookies."
Positive"This user lists Red Gate Bakery's chocolate toffee cookie as among their favorites."
Positive"This user states that Red Gate Bakery's chocolate chip cookie is their absolute favorite after over 15 years of searching."
Positive"This user wants to try Red Gate Bakery but has not yet tasted their chocolate chip cookies."
Neutral"This user recommends Red Gate Bakery and Janie's Life Changing Baked Goods."
Positive"Suggests Red Gate Bakery, stating it's a bit of a walk but worth it."
Positive"The user tried the banana bread from Red Gate and found it to be a bit cakier and more chocolatey than expected, but they still liked it."
Positive"This user listed 'Red gates midnight banana bread' as a recommendation."
Positive"This user simply recommended 'Red Gate'."
Positive"This user found both Claud chocolate cake and Salty Lunch Lady's Luncheonette to be epic, and has heard good things about Red Gate Bakery but not yet visited."
Neutral"In contrast to another opinion, this user found Red Gate Bakery's cake to be dry and flavorless."
Negative"This user enjoys Red Gate Bakery's cookies but found their birthday cake disappointing due to a lack of flavor and sweetness."
Negative
