TLDR
Famous for imaginative custom sugar cookies and massive, thick-dough chocolate chip cookies that are a go-to for NYC dessert lovers.
Reddit Sentiment for FUNNY FACE BAKERY(based on 24 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Funny Face Bakery is celebrated for its chocolate chip cookies, shown broken to reveal a soft, chewy interior with abundant chocolate chips, indicating a highly enjoyable and popular offering in NYC.
Funny Face Bakery is featured for its highly popular cookies, which are a key component of an 'epic collab' with Glace New York. The cookies, available in limited quantities (around 50 per day) at Glace New York's Rockefeller Center spot, are in high demand and contribute significantly to the appeal of the collaborative dessert. The rapid sell-out of these cookies indicates their widespread popularity and desirability.
Funny Face Bakery's chocolate chip cookie is included in this compilation of New York City's finest, demonstrating its standing as a well-regarded option among cookie aficionados. The author features it positively.
Details
Renowned for its creative sugar cookies featuring pop culture icons and custom designs, this bakery also serves substantial, softball-sized chocolate chip cookies that draw frequent comparisons to local favorites [1]. While many praise the quality of their treats, the bakery has sparked mixed discussions regarding the consistency of its recent cookie offerings [2], [3]. It remains a destination for those seeking visually striking baked goods and hearty, thick-dough cookies [1].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American-style bakery staples, highlighted by large, Levain-style chocolate chip cookies packed with generous chunks [1], [6]. Highly recommended items include the S'mores cookie [7] and their artistic royal icing sugar cookies [8], though some diners note that quality can fluctuate depending on timing and temperature [3], [9].
Caveats
Some visitors may find the cookies a bit gimmicky or expensive compared to other neighborhood staples [10]. Additionally, there are reports of inconsistency, with some customers suggesting that the crumbfetti and chocolate chip cookies have recently tasted 'off' or stale [2], [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About FUNNY FACE BAKERY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Don You Have A Favorite Chocolate Chip Cookie
"This commenter agrees that Funny Face Bakery's cookie didn't taste as good on a recent visit as it did previously."
NeutralFrom post: Don You Have A Favorite Chocolate Chip Cookie
"This user rates Funny Face Bakery's cookie at 7.5 out of 10."
PositiveFrom post: Don You Have A Favorite Chocolate Chip Cookie
"This user believes Funny Face Bakery has the best cookie in the city, but questions if the recipe has changed due to a recent visit where it seemed 'off'."
NeutralFrom post: Don You Have A Favorite Chocolate Chip Cookie
"This user recommends Funny Face Bakery as an option if one likes Levain-style cookies."
PositiveFrom post: Don You Have A Favorite Chocolate Chip Cookie
"This user names Funny Face Bakery as the answer for the best cookie, implying it is superior to Levain."
PositiveFrom post: Nyconly Chocolates Worth Taking Home
"Suggests Funny Face Bakery for smaller cookies at $2 each, proposing buying in bulk and dividing them for gifts."
NeutralFrom post: Recs For Custom Cookies
"This user recommended Funny Face Bakery for custom royal icing cookies for an engagement party."
PositiveFrom post: Funny Face Bakery
"Responding to a deleted comment, this user notes a preference against Levain Bakery cookies and suggests that cookie quality from Funny Face Bakery might depend on timing and location."
NeutralFrom post: Funny Face Bakery
"This user is specifying that their negative experience with Funny Face Bakery cookies pertains to the crumbfetti and chocolate chip varieties. They are still questioning if the recipe has changed."
NegativeFrom post: Funny Face Bakery
"This user believes that the crumbfetti cookies from Funny Face Bakery have tasted stale or old recently. They are inquiring about a potential recipe change."
NegativeFrom post: Funny Face Bakery
"This user states that the Funny Face Bakery cookies taste the same to them, and that their experience might depend on whether the cookies are served warm or not."
PositiveFrom post: Funny Face Bakery
"This user is asking for clarification on which specific cookies the original poster was referring to when they mentioned a change in taste at Funny Face Bakery."
NeutralFrom post: Good Bakery In Fidi After Tin Building Closes
"This commenter mentions Funny Face Bakery as having solid cookie options."
PositiveFrom post: Who In Nyc Makes The Best Chantilly Cake And Are
"This user recommended 'KindaCuteNYC' on Instagram for delicious cakes made in the style requested, noting their ability to customize decor and flavors."
PositiveFrom post: Roast My Nyc Food Itinerary
"The commenter finds Funny Face cookies to be fine but suggests there are much better options available in the city for chocolate chip cookies."
NeutralFrom post: Roast My Nyc Food Itinerary
"Similar to Levain Bakery, this opinion suggests that cookies from Funny Face are good for taking home. They can be stored and enjoyed later, making them a good travel option."
NeutralFrom post: Roast My Nyc Food Itinerary
"The user is considering Funny Face for cookies and asks for a comparison with Levain Bakery. This comment notes that while Funny Face cookies are okay, they can be considered a bit gimmicky and expensive."
NeutralFrom post: Who Makes The Best Inside Out Chocolate Chip
"The commenter checked out Funny Face Bakery based on a suggestion and found their cookies looked similar to the ones in the post, planning to try them."
NeutralFrom post: Who Makes The Best Inside Out Chocolate Chip
"This user suggested that the cookies pictured in the post looked very similar to the Cookies and Cream cookie offered by Funny Face Bakery."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For The Best Bakery Cookie
"This user states that the S'mores cookie from Funny Face is great."
Positive