Renowned for its top-ranked cookies & pastries, this spot is a go-to for sweet cravings. Don't miss their viral Papaya Matcha Lemonade!
This charming eatery is a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth, especially for their highly-acclaimed cookies that have garnered top rankings across the city. Customers rave about the perfect balance of chew and caramelized bottom in their chocolate chip cookies, with some even calling them "divine." Beyond cookies, they also offer a delightful selection of pastries and unique beverages like the Papaya Matcha Lemonade, making it a versatile spot for various cravings. While a few find it a bit too sweet or chain-like, the overwhelming consensus is that this spot delivers a consistently delicious experience.
The restaurant is particularly renowned for its cookies, with many users ranking them among the best in NYC. Specific mentions include the Nutty Chocolate Chip Cookie and a homemade 'oreo'. While many rave about the quality and taste, a few find them too sweet or comparable to other chain offerings. Pastries, such as croissants, also receive mixed reviews, with some finding them exceptional and others disappointing. The Papaya Matcha Lemonade is also a standout item, with one user calling it a
"The Nutty Chocolate Chip Cookie is consistently praised as one of the best in NYC. The Papaya Matcha Lemonade is also a highly recommended and unique beverage option."
Overall, customers have a very positive sentiment towards the restaurant, frequently praising its cookies and pastries. There are a few dissenting opinions, with some finding the establishment to be a mid-tier chain or their pastries disappointing, but the majority view is highly favorable.
Important Note
One commenter criticized a croissant as "trash," and another found the restaurant to be a mid-tier chain. There's also a debate about whether recent changes to their pancakes have improved or detracted from the dish.
"This commenter visited recently and found the pancakes to be just okay, not living up to the hype, and tasting like regular pancakes with a hint of lemon zest."
Negative"This commenter had the pancakes about a month ago and found them to be consistent, though perhaps slightly less tall and crisp. They still considered them very good."
Positive"This commenter visited recently and did not understand the hype surrounding the restaurant."
Negative"This commenter noticed that the individual pancakes are wider and flatter now, with less butter, which they consider an improvement. They suspect the change in texture might be due to the lower height."
Neutral"The commenter is on the fence about trying the Papaya Matcha Lemonade from Maman but is being convinced by the positive feedback."
Positive"The commenter's wife is addicted to the Papaya Matcha Lemonade from Maman."
Positive"The user impulsively ordered the Papaya Matcha Lemonade from Maman and was very glad they did. They found the papaya coconut whip to be a game-changer that tasted amazing despite sounding unusual."
Positive"This user suggested Maman as a brunch spot near the Center for Jewish History."
Neutral"This commenter found Maman's cookies to be too sweet and preferred others with better flavor."
Negative"In response to a comment about Maman's cookies, this commenter admitted they only go there for a latte if needed."
Neutral"This commenter stated that Maman's only good product might be their chocolate chip cookie."
Positive"This commenter felt Maman should have been ranked higher and considered their chocolate chip cookie to be good, although they personally prefer cookies not as thick as Levain's."
Positive"This user recommended Maman as a breakfast option in the Gramercy/Flatiron area."
Neutral"The commenter lists various Maman locations as recommended spots for a quick meal."
Positive"The user recommended Maman for cookies."
Neutral"Maman is listed as a recommendation for oatmeal raisin cookies."
Neutral"Maman is recommended for its cookies."
Positive"Maman is recommended for its cookies."
Positive"Maman is a favorite of the commenter, who states they have never had a bad pastry from there."
Positive"The commenter believes Maman offers an insane cookie, similar to Daily Provisions."
Positive
