TLDR
Iconic Detroit-style thick-crust pizza and a cult-favorite burger. A go-to spot for crispy edges and hearty American comfort food.
Reddit Sentiment for EMMY SQUARED PIZZA(based on 12 Reddit opinions)
Details
Renowned for its signature Detroit-style pizza, this spot has established itself as a premier destination for those seeking a thick, crispy crust in New York City [5], [9]. Beyond its famous pies, the menu is celebrated for featuring a standout burger that diners frequently praise [2]. While it has long been a go-to for many, some recent feedback suggests concerns regarding a potential decline in quality following a transition to corporate ownership [10].
Food Overview
The restaurant specializes in American comfort food, anchored by its highly regarded Detroit-style pizza characterized by a signature thick, crispy crust [5], [9]. Patrons also consistently praise the quality of the burgers, which are frequently highlighted as a must-try item alongside the pizza [2].
The Detroit-style pizza is the primary recommendation, frequently cited as a high-quality, top-tier option [9], [12]. The burger is also consistently suggested as an excellent alternative to the pizza menu [2].
While the establishment is widely hailed as a top-tier destination for Detroit-style pizza, some diners have recently expressed concerns regarding a decline in quality following its acquisition by a larger corporation [9], [10].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01burger5 mentions
- 02detroit style pizza4 mentions
- 03pizza3 mentions
Caveats
Some recent feedback indicates a potential drop in quality, which patrons attribute to the restaurant's recent acquisition by a corporation [10].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About EMMY SQUARED PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where Will Los Tacos No1 Open Next Theyre At 10
"Mentioned as a brand that received private equity investment."
NeutralFrom post: Manhattan Trip Specific Requests For 2026 Best
"Recommended as a place to get pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Different Pizza Styles Chicago
"The user argues that the quality has declined significantly since the business was sold to a corporation."
NegativeFrom post: Looking For Different Pizza Styles Chicago
"Ranked as a high-tier option for Detroit-style pizza in NYC."
PositiveFrom post: Searching For A Specific Pizza Place Around East
"Mentioned as an alternative possibility in a comment listing potential restaurants."
Neutral