Known for its unique Detroit-style pizzas and iconic burgers with pretzel buns.
Emmy Squared Pizza is a popular spot known for its distinctive Detroit-style pizzas and hearty burgers. Many patrons praise the unique flavors and textures of their pizzas, often highlighting the crispy edges and flavorful toppings. The burgers, such as the 'Le Big Matt,' are also a hit, frequently commended for their substantial patties, pretzel buns, and signature Emmy sauce. Alongside these mainstays, appetizers like the cheesy garlic sticks have also garnered positive attention. While most reviews are favorable, a few comments suggest that quality can vary between locations or has seen a dip with the restaurant's growth. Nonetheless, it remains a go-to destination for those seeking a satisfying and flavorful pizza or burger experience.
This establishment is highly regarded for its Detroit-style pizza, with multiple recommendations and mentions of its unique crust and toppings. The burgers, particularly the 'Le Big Matt,' also receive positive feedback, often noted for their pretzel buns and special sauce. Some users have also enjoyed the cheesy garlic sticks. There are a few dissenting opinions regarding burger quality consistency and overall decline after expansion, but the consensus leans positive, especially for the pizza.
"Detroit-style pizza and the 'Le Big Matt' burger are frequently recommended. Cheesy garlic sticks and the Caesar salad also receive positive mentions."
Customers generally have positive things to say about the Detroit-style pizza and burgers, often recommending them. However, there are some mixed opinions on the burger's consistency across different locations and a few comments suggest a decline in quality with expansion.
Important Note
Some patrons report inconsistent burger quality across locations, and a few believe the overall quality has declined with the restaurant's expansion.
"Appropriate-Tie-6524 states that Emmy Squared is awesome."
Positive"Halfadash6 notes that Emmy Squared fits the bill for sit-down pizza and beer, but clarifies it serves Detroit-style pizza, not the iconic New York slice."
Neutral"Garconavecunreve recommends Emmy Squared for a sit-down pizza experience, highlighting its solid beer selection."
Positive"Sdotmill suggests Emmy Squared in Hell's Kitchen as a good option near Times Square for pizza and beer."
Positive"Killerasp recommends Emmy Squared Pizza in Hell's Kitchen as an option for pizza and beer, suggesting it's a better choice than staying in the Times Square area for good vibes."
Positive"A user finds the Caesar salad at Emmy Squared to be pretty good."
Positive"This user states that Emmy Squared's quality has declined since Matt (presumably a key figure) moved to Nashville, also noting that most NYC Detroit-style pizzas lack brick cheese."
Negative"This user recommends Emmy Squared for Detroit-style pizza."
Positive"This user recommends Emily's (likely Emmy Squared) for Detroit-style pizza."
Positive"This user lists Emmy Squared among several Detroit-style pizza restaurants."
Neutral"This user mentions Emmy Squared as an alternative choice for Detroit-style pizza."
Neutral"The user enjoys Emmy Squared's cheesy garlic sticks, recommending them as a good option for garlic bread."
Positive"The commenter suggests asking Emmy Squared, a Detroit pizza restaurant, if they would sell brick cheese for home use, as they are a Detroit pizza place in NYC."
Neutral"Emmy Squared is a favored restaurant for delivery, with specific mentions of their chopped burger and pizza for leftovers."
Positive"The user simply recommends Emmy Squared."
Positive"The author lists Emmys as a recommended option for burgers in NYC."
Positive"The author Garconavecunreve suggested Emmy Squared as a restaurant in NYC for obtaining gluten-free or wheat-free pizza slices, in reply to a request."
Neutral"Recommended Emmy Squared Pizza."
Positive"The commenter includes Emmy Squared in their list of other spots to consider in NYC, implying a positive recommendation, known for its Detroit-style pizza and burgers."
Positive"The commenter suggested Emmy Squared, noting its co-founding by a husband and wife duo. This made it relevant to the original post seeking female-owned or run pizza establishments."
Neutral"User liked only the burger at Emmy Squared (location unspecified); the pizza was considered not great."
Neutral"Visited Emmy Squared (location unspecified) and had good Detroit style pizza and an okay burger, but wouldn't seek them out again as better options exist in NYC."
Neutral"Claims Emmy Squared expanded too much after the original owners divorced and the quality is now poor ('ass'). Contrasts it with Emily, which is considered 'still solid'."
Negative"Agrees with negative sentiment about Emmy Squared's quality decline and specifically mentions the Hell's Kitchen location with a vomiting emoji, implying a bad experience."
Negative"States the Emmy Squared burger quality is highly variable across its chain locations, ranging from great to terrible. This contrasts with the consistently great Emily Brooklyn burger."
Neutral"Reacting to a comparison, the user suggests Emmy Squared's Detroit style pizza should make the choice easy, implying preference for it."
Positive"Describes the Emmy Squared burger as another double cheese burger, assuming it differs slightly from the one at Emily West Village. User has not been but probably should."
Neutral"Compares Emmy Squared's 'Le Big Matt' double-patty burger and Detroit style pizza to Pizza Loves Emily's offerings. Notes similarities like pretzel buns and Emmy sauce but differences in patty count and pizza style."
Neutral"Notes burgers are similar to Emily WV but quality might be inconsistent due to Emmy Squared being a mini chain. Depends on location."
Neutral"A user simply recommended Emmy Squared as a dining option."
Positive
