TLDR
Detroit-style pizza & iconic burgers w/ pretzel buns. A departure from NY slices, offering a unique, decadent experience.
Reddit Sentiment for EMMY SQUARED PIZZA(based on 23 Reddit opinions)
Details
Known for its unique take on pizza, this establishment offers a delicious Detroit-style crust that's a departure from the traditional New York slice. While pizza is the star, their burgers, particularly 'Le Big Matt,' have also garnered attention, often drawing comparisons to their sister restaurant, Emily. Be prepared for a potentially divisive experience, as opinions on quality and expansion vary among patrons.
Food Overview
The restaurant is primarily known for its Detroit-style pizza, which is a thick, square-cut pizza with a crispy, cheesy crust. Reviewers often recommend the pizza, though some compare it to other establishments and find it varies in quality. The 'Le Big Matt' burger, served on a pretzel bun, is another highlight, frequently mentioned as a strong offering. However, some opinions suggest that the quality of both pizza and burgers can be inconsistent, with a few negative experiences reported.
Caveats
Some patrons have noted a decline in quality since the restaurant's expansion, with opinions on consistency varying significantly by location. It's also important to note that this establishment serves Detroit-style pizza, not traditional New York slices.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About EMMY SQUARED PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For A Truly Great Hells Kitchen Dinner
"The commenter really likes Pizza Loves Emily."
PositiveFrom post: Whats Your Favorite Thick Crust Pizza Slice In Nyc
"This commenter mentioned Emmy Squared as a place that serves thick crust pizza slices."
PositiveFrom post: Whats Your Favorite Thick Crust Pizza Slice In Nyc
"This commenter listed Emmy Squared as a place with a good thick slice, in response to a query about pizza slice styles in NYC."
PositiveFrom post: Whats Your Favorite Thick Crust Pizza Slice In Nyc
"This commenter suggested Emmy Squared in response to a question about thick crust pizza slices in NYC."
PositiveFrom post: I Want To Try 100 New Dishes In 2026 Help Me Make
"While known for pizza, Emmy Squared also has a very good burger and is recommended."
PositiveFrom post: I Want To Try 100 New Dishes In 2026 Help Me Make
"While known for pizza, Emmy Squared also has a very good burger and is recommended."
PositiveFrom post: Best Food In Chelseahells Kitchen
"This user recommended Emmy Squared Pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Pizza Beer
"Appropriate-Tie-6524 states that Emmy Squared is awesome."
PositiveFrom post: Pizza Beer
"Halfadash6 notes that Emmy Squared fits the bill for sit-down pizza and beer, but clarifies it serves Detroit-style pizza, not the iconic New York slice."
NeutralFrom post: Pizza Beer
"Garconavecunreve recommends Emmy Squared for a sit-down pizza experience, highlighting its solid beer selection."
PositiveFrom post: Pizza Beer
"Sdotmill suggests Emmy Squared in Hell's Kitchen as a good option near Times Square for pizza and beer."
PositiveFrom post: Pizza Beer
"Killerasp recommends Emmy Squared Pizza in Hell's Kitchen as an option for pizza and beer, suggesting it's a better choice than staying in the Times Square area for good vibes."
PositiveFrom post: Best Caesar Salad
"A user finds the Caesar salad at Emmy Squared to be pretty good."
PositiveFrom post: Best Detroit Style Pizza In Nyc
"This user states that Emmy Squared's quality has declined since Matt (presumably a key figure) moved to Nashville, also noting that most NYC Detroit-style pizzas lack brick cheese."
NegativeFrom post: Best Detroit Style Pizza In Nyc
"This user recommends Emmy Squared for Detroit-style pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Best Detroit Style Pizza In Nyc
"This user recommends Emily's (likely Emmy Squared) for Detroit-style pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Best Detroit Style Pizza In Nyc
"This user lists Emmy Squared among several Detroit-style pizza restaurants."
NeutralFrom post: Best Detroit Style Pizza In Nyc
"This user mentions Emmy Squared as an alternative choice for Detroit-style pizza."
NeutralFrom post: Garlic Bread
"The user enjoys Emmy Squared's cheesy garlic sticks, recommending them as a good option for garlic bread."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Get Wisconsin Brick Cheese
"The commenter suggests asking Emmy Squared, a Detroit pizza restaurant, if they would sell brick cheese for home use, as they are a Detroit pizza place in NYC."
Neutral