TLDR
The ultimate destination for authentic Chicago-style and crispy tavern-style pies in a vibrant, group-friendly setting.
Reddit Sentiment for EMMETT'S ON GROVE(based on 13 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
This restaurant is highlighted for its 'martini mondays' special, offering $9 martinis at the bar from 5-6:30 pm. It's shown as a place where a group of friends can gather and enjoy drinks.
The 'Hot Girl Pizza' from Emmetts on Grove is described as delicious, featuring Mike's hot honey, pepperoni, and jalapeños on a thin crust. The author expresses a strong desire to return to try their chocolate cake.
Bryan Kim reviews Emmett's on Grove, a West Village spot channeling Midwestern nostalgia with tavern-style pizzas and comforting Italian-American classics that aim to please.
Details
Emmett's on Grove is a crowd-pleasing neighborhood spot that focuses on satisfying, nostalgic Midwestern and Italian-American comfort food [1]. With its inviting wood-paneled bar and skylit dining room, the restaurant serves as a reliable destination for groups and those looking for drinks [1], [2]. While it is celebrated as the definitive spot in NYC for Chicago-style pizza, it also earns high praise for its thin, crispy tavern-style pies [3], [4].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on hearty comfort food, with tavern-style pizza—featuring a thin, flexible, crackery crust—serving as a standout offering [1], [3]. Beyond pizza, highly recommended items include crunchy, batter-coated cheese curds, a satisfying thick-patty burger, and classic chicken parm served over spaghetti [1]. For dessert, the dense, brick-like slice of chocolate cake is a crowd favorite [1]. While generally lauded, some diners remind visitors that the offerings differ from traditional New York-style pies [3].
The tavern-style pizza, specifically the 'Hot Girl Pizza' topped with Mike's hot honey, pepperoni, and jalapeños, comes highly recommended [1], [4]. Other frequently praised items include the crunchy cheese curds and the rich, dense chocolate cake [1].
Patrons consistently rank the restaurant as a top-tier choice for Midwestern-inspired comfort food, particularly praising the quality of the pizza and the buzzing, versatile atmosphere [1], [3]. It is widely considered an excellent, reliable pick for group events and social gatherings [2], [3].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01tavern style pizza3 mentions
- 02tavern pies2 mentions
- 03pizza2 mentions
- 04chicken parm2 mentions
Caveats
While the restaurant is highly regarded for its specific regional styles, diners should note that it serves tavern-style and Chicago-style pizza rather than traditional New York-style slices [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About EMMETT'S ON GROVE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For Different Pizza Styles Chicago
"Confirms the original location serves tavern-style pies."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Different Pizza Styles Chicago
"Recommended for Tavern-style pizza, noting it differs from their Chicago-style offerings."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Different Pizza Styles Chicago
"Recommended for Chicago-style pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Different Pizza Styles Chicago
"Described as the definitive spot for Chicago-style pizza in NYC."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Different Pizza Styles Chicago
"Ranked as a high-tier option for Chicago-style pizza."
Positive