Amazing tavern & deep dish pizza in a lively West Village spot.
This West Village gem is a top spot for pizza, offering both authentic Chicago-style deep dish and delicious tavern pies. Reviewers rave about the amazing flavors and the impressive cheesiness of the deep dish, with some even calling it the best in NYC. Beyond the stellar pizza, patrons also enjoy other Italian-American classics and a lively atmosphere, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers.
The restaurant is highly praised for its pizza, with specific mentions of both Chicago-style deep dish and tavern pies. The deep dish is noted for being very cheesy, and the tavern pies are described as amazing. Beyond pizza, other dishes like eggplant parmesan, ribs, and pan-seared broccoli have also received positive mentions. A notable dessert is the key lime pie, lauded for its perfect sweet and tart balance.
"Highly recommended are the tavern pies and the Chicago-style deep dish pizza. Other standouts include the eggplant parmesan, ribs, and the key lime pie."
Customers overwhelmingly recommend this restaurant, particularly praising its pizza and overall vibe. Some diners found the deep dish pizza to be exceptionally cheesy, while others highlighted the tavern-style pies as a delicious alternative. The atmosphere is frequently described as lively and a great spot for a night out.
Important Note
The restaurant can get loud.
"In response to a question about tavern pies, this commenter clarifies that while both locations have tavern pies, only the MacDougal location serves deep dish."
Positive"This commenter indicates that Emmett's on Grove offers a trendier, "scene-y" atmosphere and specializes in tavern pies, but does not serve deep dish pizza."
Positive"The commenter asks if Emmett's on Grove serves Chicago tavern style pizza, as they may be confusing it with another restaurant. They are later informed that this location does have tavern pies."
Neutral"This commenter strongly prefers Emmett's on Grove over the original Emmett's."
Positive"This commenter suggests that Emmett's on Grove has a more extensive menu and a more upscale atmosphere compared to the original Emmett's. They also note that the "hot papi bar pie" is available here."
Positive"This user inquired if the French fries at Emmett's on Grove are comparable to those at the Roxy hotel bar."
Neutral"The user expressed excitement about Emmett's opening a new location on the Upper East Side, noting that the pizza at the restaurant is excellent."
Positive"Halfadash6 mentions Emmets on Grove serves Chicago tavern-style pizza, suggesting it as an alternative to Detroit-style or iconic New York slices."
Neutral"PretzelsThirst recommends Emmets on Grove for good tavern-style pizza, noting that other good food options are nearby."
Positive"Emmet's on Grove is seconded for its quality, specifically being praised for having some of the best pizza in NYC."
Positive"Emmet's on Grove boasts a '10/10 vibe' and is consistently busy, offering great food in a desirable neighborhood."
Positive"Emmett's on Grove is known for great pizza but also offers incredible other main dishes like eggplant parmesan and ribs, although it can get loud."
Neutral"Emmett's is described as fantastic, particularly appealing to New Yorkers who may not frequently encounter Chicago or Detroit-style pizza."
Positive"Emmett's on Grove is suggested as an alternative option for sit-down pizza."
Neutral"A friend visiting tried Emmet's deep dish pizza, initially thinking it lacked cheese because it's hidden under the sauce, but the extreme cheesiness eventually caused digestive issues for them."
Neutral"The user agrees that Emmet's is a good recommendation for cheesy pizza, having visited the restaurant multiple times and also enjoying its sister location on Grove."
Positive"Emmet's is recommended for its very cheesy deep dish pizza."
Positive"User highly recommends Emmets for its "amazing" tavern pies, suggesting it as a different but excellent style of pizza."
Positive"Recommends Emmets on Grove."
Positive"User recommends Emmett's on Grove in the West Village."
Positive
