TLDR
Vibrant and trendy Italian-American spot at Columbus Circle perfect for groups and creative cocktails. A high-energy destination often buzzing with social media hype.
Instagram Posts References
This post highlights Bad Roman for its outstanding sweet treats, specifically mentioning the Tiramisu Ice Cream Cake. The dessert is presented as an ideal choice for the weather and is described as a delightful indulgence.
Bad Roman is ranked as one of the premier places in NYC for Cacio e Pepe, implying a distinctively good and popular version of the dish.
Details
Located in the Time Warner Center, this vibrant Italian-American destination is frequently cited as a popular choice for group celebrations and trendy outings [1][2][8]. While many patrons enjoy the atmosphere and creative menu offerings [10][16], others have characterized the experience as heavily Americanized or potentially driven by influencer hype [6][15]. Despite polarizing reviews regarding its overall quality, it remains a high-demand spot that can be difficult to book on short notice [11].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on creative Italian-American fare, with notable highlights including Cacio e Pepe [17], Brussels sprouts [2], and indulgent desserts like Tiramisu Ice Cream Cake [18]. While specific items like the garlic babka and pepperoni are well-received, some diners feel the cuisine leans too heavily into an Americanized style [6][16].
Highlights / Recommended
"Highly recommended items include the Cacio e Pepe [17], the Tiramisu Ice Cream Cake [18], and creative appetizers such as the garlic babka and pepperoni [16]."
Customer Sentiment
Customer feedback is notably divided, ranging from praise for its lively atmosphere and suitability for group events to critiques labeling it as gaudy or artificial [6][7][10][15]. Some diners prefer the food quality here over similar local eateries, while others strongly advise skipping the experience altogether [13][14].
Caveats
Reservations can be challenging to secure on short notice due to the restaurant's popularity [11], and some visitors find the aesthetic gaudy or overly commercialized [7][15].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BAD ROMAN
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: 96th And Broadway To Columbus Circle A Walk With
"Suggested as a fancy spot to end the walk with cocktails and creative appetizers like garlic babka or pepperoni."
PositiveFrom post: Why Do People Think Its A Flex To Hate On Hyped
"Used as an example of a restaurant that may be artificially hyped due to influencer marketing rather than food quality."
NegativeFrom post: Place To Eat Lunch With Family Near The Lincoln
"The commenter advises to skip this restaurant, stating it is not good."
NegativeFrom post: Place To Eat Lunch With Family Near The Lincoln
"The commenter feels the food is better at Bad Roman compared to The Smith."
PositiveFrom post: Place To Eat Lunch With Family Near The Lincoln
"The commenter notes they have not personally visited Bad Roman."
Neutral