A unique spot blending cocktail lounge & pizza [4]. Known for its Neapolitan pies with charred crusts and a salty sauce [1]. Don't miss the incredible potato pizza or the standout chocolate cake [1, 3].
Sonal Shah praises Super Nice Pizza for its throwback vibes and authentic Neapolitan pies, highlighting its charred crusts and a sauce that leans salty rather than sweet.
Super Nice Pizza offers a unique blend of a cocktail lounge, wine bar, and pizzeria, creating a throwback atmosphere with red brick walls and inviting bar seating. Reviewers praise their classic Neapolitan pizzas, noting the charred crusts and a sauce that leans salty rather than sweet. Standout dishes include the pizza with housemade sausage and a fantastic tiramisu [1].
This Neapolitan pizzeria offers classic pizzas with charred crusts and a sauce that is noted for being salty rather than sweet [1]. Standout pizzas include the potato pizza with smoked mozzarella and a highly-praised clam pizza [3, 7, 10]. For dessert, the chocolate cake is frequently recommended for its excellent quality and large portion size [1, 7].
"Highly recommended dishes include the pizza with housemade sausage and the tiramisu [1]. Patrons also rave about the potato pizza with smoked mozzarella and the clam pizza [3, 7]."
Customers are highly positive, with many recommending the restaurant for its unique offerings and delicious food. Specific praise is given to the pizza, including a highly-rated potato and clam pizza, and a surprisingly excellent chocolate cake dessert [1, 3, 7, 10].
"This user recommended Super Nice Pizza, stating it serves great pizza that they would enjoy regardless of current food ingredient concerns like bromated flour."
Positive"This user mentions Super Nice Pizza."
Positive"This commenter gave a +1 for the clam pie at Super Nice, calling it outstanding."
Positive"This commenter, who works nearby, expressed intent to visit Super Nice Pizza after seeing the recommendation."
Neutral"This commenter had good clam pies (not slices) at Super Nice."
Positive"This commenter agreed that the clam pie at Super Nice was quite nice and very fresh-tasting."
Positive"This commenter enthusiastically recommended Super Nice Pizza on the Upper West Side for its clam pizza, calling it 'fab', and also mentioned their chocolate cake."
Positive"This user defends the recommendation for Super Nice Pizza, suggesting it's a great option that might be better than dealing with crowds near Columbus Circle, especially after a marathon."
Positive"Super Nice Pizza on 108th and Amsterdam is recommended for its stellar pizza and also offers a large slice of chocolate cake."
Positive"Super Nice Pizza is recommended as a unique spot that combines a cocktail lounge, wine bar, and pizza."
Positive"Super Nice Pizza is noted for having an incredible potato pizza that includes smoked mozzarella."
Positive"Super Nice Pizza surprisingly served what a user considered the best fried calamari they’d ever had."
Positive"The user highly recommended the chocolate cake at Super Nice Pizza on the Upper West Side, noting its excellent quality and large portion size."
Positive
