TLDR
A chic cocktail lounge meets authentic, charred-crust Neapolitan pizza in a nostalgic throwback setting.
Sonal Shah praises Super Nice Pizza for its throwback vibes and authentic Neapolitan pies, highlighting its charred crusts and a sauce that leans salty rather than sweet.
Details
Offering a unique blend of a cocktail lounge and a traditional Neapolitan pizzeria, this Upper West Side spot creates a cozy throwback atmosphere with its red brick walls and inviting bar [1]. Guests enjoy classic pies featuring charred crusts and a signature salty sauce, alongside a selection of excellent weekend brunch items [1], [2]. Beyond the pizza, the establishment has garnered acclaim for its diverse menu, ranging from fresh clam pies to indulgent desserts and even pancakes [3], [4].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic Neapolitan pizzas with a signature salty sauce and charred crust, with the housemade sausage pizza and fresh clam pie standing out as guest favorites [1], [3]. Beyond pizza, the kitchen receives high marks for its desserts like the chocolate cake and tiramisu, as well as its weekend brunch service featuring excellent pancakes [1], [3], [4].
Highlights / Recommended
"The housemade sausage pizza and the fresh clam pie are highly recommended, often followed by the fantastic tiramisu or the weekend brunch pancakes [1], [3], [4]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •clam pie(3)
- •sausage pie(2)
- •tiramisu(2)
- •chocolate cake(2)
Customer Sentiment
Patrons consistently express enthusiastic support for the diverse offerings, ranging from their savory clam pies to their standout brunch pancakes [3], [4]. The atmosphere is widely praised, with many viewing it as a top-tier alternative to the crowded dining scenes elsewhere in the city [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About SUPER NICE PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: What Is Your Favorite Steak Frites In Nyc Non
"Surprising recommendation for a pizza spot."
PositiveFrom post: Any Pancake Recommendations On Uws Ues Or Midtown
"This commenter lists Super Nice Pizza on 108th St as a recommendation for weekend brunch."
PositiveFrom post: Any Pancake Recommendations On Uws Ues Or Midtown
"This commenter lists Super Nice Pizza as a place for weekend brunch."
NeutralFrom post: Any Pancake Recommendations On Uws Ues Or Midtown
"The commenter states that Super Nice Pizza has excellent pancakes, comparing them to those at Golden Diner, particularly during weekend brunch."
PositiveFrom post: Bars With A Good Vermouth List Other Than Bar
"This user mentioned Super Nice Pizza in response to a query about bars with good vermouth lists."
NeutralFrom post: Best New Restaurantscoffee Shopsbakeries Opened
"This user lists 'Brunch at super nice pizza' as a new opening."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Pizza Places That Use
"This user recommended Super Nice Pizza, stating it serves great pizza that they would enjoy regardless of current food ingredient concerns like bromated flour."
PositiveFrom post: What Is Your Most Frequented Restaurant
"This user mentions Super Nice Pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Help Me Find A Clam Pizza Slice
"This commenter gave a +1 for the clam pie at Super Nice, calling it outstanding."
PositiveFrom post: Help Me Find A Clam Pizza Slice
"This commenter, who works nearby, expressed intent to visit Super Nice Pizza after seeing the recommendation."
NeutralFrom post: Help Me Find A Clam Pizza Slice
"This commenter had good clam pies (not slices) at Super Nice."
PositiveFrom post: Help Me Find A Clam Pizza Slice
"This commenter agreed that the clam pie at Super Nice was quite nice and very fresh-tasting."
PositiveFrom post: Help Me Find A Clam Pizza Slice
"This commenter enthusiastically recommended Super Nice Pizza on the Upper West Side for its clam pizza, calling it 'fab', and also mentioned their chocolate cake."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle
"This user defends the recommendation for Super Nice Pizza, suggesting it's a great option that might be better than dealing with crowds near Columbus Circle, especially after a marathon."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle
"Super Nice Pizza on 108th and Amsterdam is recommended for its stellar pizza and also offers a large slice of chocolate cake."
PositiveFrom post: Restaurant Recommendation Around Harlemuws
"Super Nice Pizza is recommended as a unique spot that combines a cocktail lounge, wine bar, and pizza."
Positive