Throwback vibes, charred crust Neapolitan pies w/ salty sauce, standout sausage pizza & tiramisu. Great cocktails too.
Sonal Shah praises Super Nice Pizza for its throwback vibes and authentic Neapolitan pies, highlighting its charred crusts and a sauce that leans salty rather than sweet.
This Neapolitan pizzeria on the Upper West Side offers a throwback vibe with classic pies. The pizzas boast charred crusts and a sauce that leans salty, with the housemade sausage pizza being a particular highlight. Beyond the pizza, the tiramisu is a must-try dessert, capping off a dining experience that combines a casual atmosphere with a great wine and cocktail selection.
The pizzeria specializes in Neapolitan-style pizza, with a crust described as good and airy, and a sauce that is salty rather than sweet. Standout dishes include the sausage pie, white zucchini pie, and a highly recommended tiramisu. Other notable mentions include a great and huge chocolate cake slice, outstanding clam pizza, and even surprisingly excellent fried calamari.
"Highly recommended dishes include the sausage pie, white zucchini pie, tiramisu, chocolate cake slice, clam pizza, and potato pizza with smoked mozzarella."
Overall, customers have a very positive sentiment, praising the quality of the pizza dough and ingredients, with specific mentions of the sausage pie and tiramisu being excellent. The ambiance is also noted as pleasant, though some found the seating uncomfortable.
Important Note
One customer mentioned that their chair was a very low stool, leading to uncomfortable seating and back pain.
"This user mentions Super Nice Pizza."
Positive"This commenter gave a +1 for the clam pie at Super Nice, calling it outstanding."
Positive"This commenter, who works nearby, expressed intent to visit Super Nice Pizza after seeing the recommendation."
Neutral"This commenter had good clam pies (not slices) at Super Nice."
Positive"This commenter agreed that the clam pie at Super Nice was quite nice and very fresh-tasting."
Positive"This commenter enthusiastically recommended Super Nice Pizza on the Upper West Side for its clam pizza, calling it 'fab', and also mentioned their chocolate cake."
Positive"This user defends the recommendation for Super Nice Pizza, suggesting it's a great option that might be better than dealing with crowds near Columbus Circle, especially after a marathon."
Positive"Super Nice Pizza on 108th and Amsterdam is recommended for its stellar pizza and also offers a large slice of chocolate cake."
Positive"Super Nice Pizza is recommended as a unique spot that combines a cocktail lounge, wine bar, and pizza."
Positive"Super Nice Pizza is noted for having an incredible potato pizza that includes smoked mozzarella."
Positive"Super Nice Pizza surprisingly served what a user considered the best fried calamari they’d ever had."
Positive"The user highly recommended the chocolate cake at Super Nice Pizza on the Upper West Side, noting its excellent quality and large portion size."
Positive
