TLDR
Massive, indulgent Southern comfort food served in portions that easily double as multiple meals. Famous for fried chicken, biscuit sandwiches, and a lively, high-energy atmosphere.
Reddit Sentiment for JACOB'S PICKLES(based on 27 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
This post details the NYC Restaurant Week menu for Jacob's Pickles, featuring a $45 dinner prix fixe. The menu includes a 'Pick Four' starter option with items like bread & butter, kosher cuks, and fried pickles. Entree choices range from Southern Biscuit Sandwich to BBQ Ribs, Roasted Lemon Chicken, and Chicken and Waffles. Desserts offered are Oreo Pie Jar and Banana Pudding Jar, with a 'Dine-In Only' note.
Jacob's Pickles, an iconic New York City spot known for its specialty pickles, has partnered with Murray's Cheese to create the 'Big Pickle Melt' for National Grilled Cheese Day. This unique grilled cheese incorporates their signature Hot Sour Pickle & honey mustard relish, contributing to a flavorful experience. The collaboration sandwich will be available at Jacob's Pickles from April 12-17.
Details
Known for its massive Southern-style comfort food, this Upper West Side staple is a destination for those seeking generous portions that often require a takeout box [8], [9], [10]. The menu features indulgent classics including fried chicken, biscuit sandwiches, and a signature butter bread pudding [11], [15], [21]. While the restaurant is a popular choice for groups and pre-bar crawl dining, it has faced criticism regarding the consistency of its namesake pickles and past health department concerns [16], [17], [21].
Food Overview
The restaurant specializes in Southern-American comfort food, with highlights like buttermilk fried chicken, biscuit sandwiches, and grits [15], [21], [22]. The fried pickles are frequently recommended, though some diners feel the standard pickle selection is underwhelming or overly intense [16], [17], [20]. The butter bread pudding and oversized soft pretzels are also noted as standout, satisfying dessert and snack options [11], [26].
Highlights / Recommended
"Highly recommended items include the fried chicken, biscuit sandwiches, and the butter bread pudding served with ice cream [11], [15], [21]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •biscuits(2)
- •mac and cheese(2)
Customer Sentiment
Diners are consistently impressed by the exceptionally large portion sizes and value for money, frequently praising the heavy comfort food [8], [10], [11]. Some negative sentiment persists among long-time critics regarding the quality of the signature pickles and occasional concerns tied to historical health department issues [16], [17], [2].
Caveats
Entree portions are extremely large, which some diners find overwhelming [13]. Additionally, some patrons have expressed disappointment with the signature pickle offerings, suggesting they do not always meet expectations given the restaurant's name [16], [17].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About JACOB'S PICKLES
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Seeking Economical Dinner Places 4560 Pp In
"Suggested for dinner on the Upper West Side."
NeutralFrom post: Anywhere To Find A Stuffed Pretzel Sweet Or Savory
"They serve a very large pretzel that is intended to feed many people."
PositiveFrom post: Brunch At Bubbys In Tribeca I Give It An 810 It
"Recommended for good grits."
PositiveFrom post: Traditional Thanksgiving Dinner In New York City
"A Southern-style comfort food restaurant that offers a solid traditional Thanksgiving takeout menu and dine-in options; pre-ordering is necessary."
PositiveFrom post: Where Would You Say Has The Best Fried Pickle
"The commenter suggests that the fried pickles at this restaurant are quite good."
Positive