TLDR
Massive portions of Southern comfort food served in a lively UWS setting. Famous for fried chicken, biscuits, and shareable snacks.
Reddit Sentiment for JACOB'S PICKLES(based on 32 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Jacob's Pickles is recommended for Southern comfort food as part of a guide to dining on the Upper West Side.
This post details the NYC Restaurant Week menu for Jacob's Pickles, featuring a $45 dinner prix fixe. The menu includes a 'Pick Four' starter option with items like bread & butter, kosher cuks, and fried pickles. Entree choices range from Southern Biscuit Sandwich to BBQ Ribs, Roasted Lemon Chicken, and Chicken and Waffles. Desserts offered are Oreo Pie Jar and Banana Pudding Jar, with a 'Dine-In Only' note.
Jacob's Pickles, an iconic New York City spot known for its specialty pickles, has partnered with Murray's Cheese to create the 'Big Pickle Melt' for National Grilled Cheese Day. This unique grilled cheese incorporates their signature Hot Sour Pickle & honey mustard relish, contributing to a flavorful experience. The collaboration sandwich will be available at Jacob's Pickles from April 12-17.
Details
Famous for its generous portions of Southern-style comfort food, this Upper West Side institution has become a go-to for hearty meals that often require a takeout box [7], [8], [9]. While many diners praise staples like fried chicken and biscuits [14], [20], others have expressed disappointment with the signature pickles, finding them overpowering or average [15], [16]. Despite a history marked by some negative feedback regarding wait times and past health issues [1], [2], [28], the restaurant remains a popular, lively destination for brunch and group dining [14], [26], [27].
Food Overview
The menu features Southern-inspired comfort food with a focus on oversized portions [7], [8]. Highly praised dishes include the fried chicken [20], biscuit sandwiches [14], fried green tomatoes [12], and creamy grits [21]. While the restaurant is named for its pickles, some guests find the current offering of new and half-sour varieties to be too intense for casual snacking [16]. Other popular, shareable items include the massive soft pretzels [24] and the decadent butter bread pudding served with ice cream [10].
Customer feedback is largely focused on the immense portion sizes, with many finding the food to be great value for the quantity provided [6], [7]. However, long-time patrons have noted inconsistencies over the years, and some express strong negative sentiments regarding past service and cleanliness experiences [1], [3], [28].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About JACOB'S PICKLES
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Eyesrollintothebackofyourheadgood Dinner Tonight
"Recommended as a comfort food spot, with the user noting it could arguably be considered a 'reasonable' dinner."
PositiveFrom post: Birthday Brunch With Husband And Teenslooking For
"A suggested restaurant for a brunch outing."
PositiveFrom post: Which Restaurant Whether Fancy Wellknown Or Not
"A neighborhood institution that is always good and offers a great happy hour."
PositiveFrom post: Whats The Longest Nyc Line Youve Waited In For
"Waited 2 hours years ago and it was glorious, though user notes it sucks now."
NegativeFrom post: Seeking Economical Dinner Places 4560 Pp In
"Suggested for dinner on the Upper West Side."
Neutral