TLDR
Smashed grass-fed beef with a signature 'lacey' crunch, nostalgic fries, and 2am availability. A fresh, 80s-themed fast-casual spot perfect for late-night cravings.
Reddit Sentiment for HERBIE'S BURGERS(based on 47 Reddit opinions)
Will Hartman reviews Herbie's, a Williamsburg burger joint that brings crispy, thin smashed patties to the neighborhood with a fun, late-night atmosphere.
Details
This Albany-based fast-food arrival in Williamsburg specializes in smashed grass-fed beef burgers featuring a distinctively crispy, lacey edge [1]. The menu leans into a nostalgic 80s aesthetic, offering reliable late-night bites including hand-breaded chicken tenders, seasoned fries, and satisfying milkshakes [1], [2]. While it has become a neighborhood favorite for its consistent quality and approachable vibe, the chain has sparked spirited debate among locals regarding its value and culinary impact [2].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on smashed, charred grass-fed beef burgers served on sesame seed buns with a variety of signature sauces [1], [2]. Customers frequently recommend the fries, which are compared favorably to classic fast-food styles, and the hand-breaded chicken tenders [1], [2]. However, some diners have found the patties to be thin, greasy, or lacking in beefy depth [2].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About HERBIE'S BURGERS
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Tried Nycs Most Expensive Burger And Its Not
"This user had a negative experience at Herbie's Burgers, finding their burger thin, overcooked, and inedible."
NegativeFrom post: Tried Nycs Most Expensive Burger And Its Not
"This user expressed a desire to move away from 'burger bougification' and supported places like Herbie's Burgers and smash burgers."
NeutralFrom post: Some Smashburgers Shakes And Fries Worth Getting
"This is a review of a new branch of Herbie's Burgers, an Albany chain, located on Roebling Street. The reviewer noted the restaurant's strong 80s theme and branding, but emphasized that the food lives up to the effort. Burgers are flattened and charred, with fresh toppings, and options like bacon and plant-based patties are available. The chicken tenders are also highlighted as good, as are the fries. Milkshakes are described as thick, tasty, and not overly sweet, with vegan options available. The reviewer concludes that Herbie's is a solid addition to the neighborhood."
PositiveFrom post: Which Nonfast Food Chicken Sandwiches And Tender
"This user tried the chicken sandwich at Herbie's Burgers and thought it was great."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Eat The Best Grass Fed Hamburger In
"This user recommended Herbie's Burgers in Brooklyn as a great option."
Positive