TLDR
Grass-fed smash burgers with an 80s twist, featuring a wide variety of sauces and thick, satisfying shakes.
Reddit Sentiment for HERBIE'S BURGERS(based on 47 Reddit opinions)
Details
This Albany-born burger chain brings a vibrant 80s aesthetic and high-quality fast-casual dining to the Brooklyn neighborhood [1]. The menu features flattened, charred burgers crafted from grass-fed beef and served on sesame seed buns [1]. While some patrons appreciate the diverse sauce selection and fantastic bacon [2], others find the burgers occasionally greasy or inconsistent [3], [4].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American fast-casual staples including burgers, chicken tenders, and fries [1]. The burgers are generally well-regarded for being charred and topped with fresh ingredients [1], though critics argue they can be greasy [3], [4]. Milkshakes are a standout, described as thick and not overly sweet, with vegan options available [1].
Highlights / Recommended
"Highly recommended items include the grass-fed beef burgers, crispy hand-breaded chicken tenders, and the thick, satisfying milkshakes [1]."
Caveats
The chain's quality can be inconsistent, with some visitors reporting overcooked or greasy experiences [4], [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About HERBIE'S BURGERS
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Tried Nycs Most Expensive Burger And Its Not
"This user had a negative experience at Herbie's Burgers, finding their burger thin, overcooked, and inedible."
NegativeFrom post: Tried Nycs Most Expensive Burger And Its Not
"This user expressed a desire to move away from 'burger bougification' and supported places like Herbie's Burgers and smash burgers."
NeutralFrom post: Some Smashburgers Shakes And Fries Worth Getting
"This is a review of a new branch of Herbie's Burgers, an Albany chain, located on Roebling Street. The reviewer noted the restaurant's strong 80s theme and branding, but emphasized that the food lives up to the effort. Burgers are flattened and charred, with fresh toppings, and options like bacon and plant-based patties are available. The chicken tenders are also highlighted as good, as are the fries. Milkshakes are described as thick, tasty, and not overly sweet, with vegan options available. The reviewer concludes that Herbie's is a solid addition to the neighborhood."
PositiveFrom post: Which Nonfast Food Chicken Sandwiches And Tender
"This user tried the chicken sandwich at Herbie's Burgers and thought it was great."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Eat The Best Grass Fed Hamburger In
"This user recommended Herbie's Burgers in Brooklyn as a great option."
PositiveFrom post: Herbies Burgers Williamsburg
"This user stated they liked Herbie's Burgers more than 7th St Burger, appreciating the grass-fed claim, variety of sauces, and finding the bacon fantastic. They also mentioned it reminded them of a former favorite NYC chain, brgr."
PositiveFrom post: Herbies Burgers Williamsburg
"This user asked about sauce preferences at Herbie's Burgers, mentioning they enjoyed the jam sauce and that the grass-fed aspect reminded them of the former NYC chain brgr."
PositiveFrom post: Herbies Burgers Williamsburg
"A native of Albany compared Herbie's Burgers to 7th Street Burger, describing it as okay with slightly small and greasy burgers, but noted they make good milkshakes. They expect the Williamsburg location to have similar quality."
NeutralFrom post: Herbies Burgers Williamsburg
"This user tried 7th St Burger but was not motivated to return, finding Herbie's Burgers more exciting with more options."
PositiveFrom post: Herbies Burgers Williamsburg
"This user shared an article about Herbie's Burgers opening in Williamsburg and asked an Albany native about their experience with the chain there."
NeutralFrom post: Herbies Burgers Williamsburg
"This user continued the 'steamed hams' joke by referencing localization."
NeutralFrom post: Herbies Burgers Williamsburg
"An Albany local commented that Herbie's Burgers locations are common in their area, finding them okay but noting the shops are nicely designed."
NeutralFrom post: Herbies Burgers Williamsburg
"This user enjoyed Herbie's Burgers, particularly the fries, which they compared favorably to McDonald's fries."
PositiveFrom post: Herbies Burgers Williamsburg
"This user, an Albany native, found it strange to see Herbie's Burgers mentioned in a NYC context."
NeutralFrom post: Herbies Burgers Williamsburg
"This user expressed excitement about Herbie's Burgers, calling it 'burger time' and planning to visit."
PositiveFrom post: Herbies Burgers Williamsburg
"This user, from Albany, expressed unfamiliarity with the term 'steamed hams' in their region."
NeutralFrom post: Herbies Burgers Williamsburg
"This user made a jesting comment 'Herpes Burgers' in a reply chain."
NegativeFrom post: Herbies Burgers Williamsburg
"This user made a cryptic comment about tomatoes, referencing the appearance of the burger."
NeutralFrom post: Herbies Burgers Williamsburg
"This user responded to criticism about taste with a general statement that 'Taste is subjective'."
NeutralFrom post: Herbies Burgers Williamsburg
"This user questioned why burgers would be called 'steamed hams' if they are grilled."
Neutral