TLDR
An iconic Times Square fixture known for its polarizing charm, reliable Italian-American classics, and lively, oft-debated atmosphere.
Details
Located in the heart of Times Square, this establishment serves as a polarizing fixture in the local dining scene, frequently sparking spirited debates among food enthusiasts [2]. While some patrons appreciate its consistent Italian-American offerings, accommodating atmosphere for large groups, and phenomenal table service [2], [3], others dismiss it as an overpriced, generic chain [2]. The location is also uniquely noted for its premium holiday experiences, including ball drop views, and its role as a persistent, meme-worthy recommendation within the city's food community [1], [2].
Highlights / Recommended
"The steak and shrimp bucatini has been specifically noted as a dish of interest by patrons [1]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •drinks(4)
- •pasta primavera(2)
Customer Sentiment
Sentiment towards this location is deeply split, ranging from sincere praise for its service and suitability for large groups to widespread, sarcastic commentary dismissing it as an overpriced chain [2].
Caveats
Many recommendations for this restaurant are made sarcastically or ironically, and the location is widely considered a meme within the local community [2].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About OLIVE GARDEN
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Cute Vibe Birthday Dinner Spots In Nyc
"The user suggested Giardino di Ulivi in Times Square as a potential restaurant."
NeutralFrom post: Which Restaurants In Manhattan Are Wellregarded
"This commenter suggested Olive Garden in Times Square."
NeutralFrom post: Best Spot For A 15 Party Birthday
"This user jokingly or sarcastically recommended Olive Garden in Times Square for the party."
NeutralFrom post: Restaurants In Nyc That Have Impressed You With
"The user sarcastically suggests The Olive Garden in Times Square has been 'knocking it out of the park', implying it's surprisingly good or they are joking."
NeutralFrom post: Times Square Food Suggestions
"Giardino degli ulivi is mentioned as a hidden gem in the Times Square area."
PositiveFrom post: Times Square Food Suggestions
"Olive Garden is suggested as a dining option."
NeutralFrom post: Times Square Recs Food Services Etc
"This user humorously commented that they specifically look for the Olive Garden mention when Times Square is discussed, implying it's a predictable or notable mention."
NeutralFrom post: Times Square Recs Food Services Etc
"Olive Garden was mentioned as a dining option."
NeutralFrom post: Places Similar To Carmines
"The commenter ironically suggested Olive Garden in Times Square, likely due to its large chain portions, though the sentiment is sarcastic."
NeutralFrom post: качественная шаверма
"A commenter suggested Olive Garden in Times Square in response to a question about quality shawarma."
NeutralFrom post: Best Iconic Times Squaretouristycant Miss
"Olive Garden Times Square is listed as a restaurant option."
NeutralFrom post: Best Iconic Times Squaretouristycant Miss
"Responding to the Olive Garden suggestion, the original poster acknowledges that taste-wise, it would be a hit, referencing a desire for a 'Michael Scott at the Sbarro' type of experience."
PositiveFrom post: Best Iconic Times Squaretouristycant Miss
"Olive Garden is suggested, with the commenter noting that taste-wise, people would love it, comparing the desired energy to 'Michael Scott at the Sbarro'."
PositiveFrom post: Does Olive Garden At Time Square Still Sell
"In response to a question about Olive Garden in Times Square, this comment advises against going, stating 'I'm gonna say no just to save you a bad decision.'"
NegativeFrom post: Does Olive Garden At Time Square Still Sell
"This comment expresses a very negative opinion about Olive Garden in Times Square, describing the food as 'horrible'. However, it also notes the people-watching is 'unmatchable' and uses it as an example to appreciate NYC."
NegativeFrom post: Does Olive Garden At Time Square Still Sell
"The poster asked about the 'endless pasta & salad' promotion at Olive Garden in Times Square. The comment states this promotion ended a few weeks ago."
NeutralFrom post: Nye In Nyc
"Suggests Olive Garden in Times Square for NYE dinner, noting the view of the ball drop."
PositiveFrom post: Best Italian For A Large Party
"The commenter suggested Olive Garden in Times Square."
NegativeFrom post: Places That Will Have Dinner For 10 On Xmas Day W
"This user recommended the Olive Garden in Times Square as a possible Christmas dinner venue."
NeutralFrom post: Business Lunch Near 44th 6th
"Olive Garden Times Square is suggested as a dining option, with a subsequent reaction of amusement from another user."
Neutral