Last Updated: 4 days ago
Phone: (212) 255-8649
Address: 17 BARROW STREET 10014
Quintessential NY romantic dining, perfect for proposals w/ a historic, charming ambiance. Food is good but can be forgettable.
Molly Fitzpatrick reviews One If By Land, Two If By Sea, a historic West Village spot praised for its incredibly romantic atmosphere and suitability for special occasions, though the food is described as good but forgettable.
Step into a historic West Village gem, once Aaron Burr's carriage house, now celebrated for its unparalleled romantic ambiance, making it a prime spot for proposals and special anniversaries. While the brick walls, high ceilings, and chandeliers create a magical setting, the food, though artfully plated, tends to be good but unremarkable, with some dishes like the duck ragu pappardelle standing out. It's an experience where the atmosphere undeniably takes center stage.
The cuisine is primarily American, with a focus on classic dishes. While the duck ragu pappardelle and beef Wellington have received positive mentions for their execution, other items like the Roasted Cornish Game Hen were noted as dry. The Chocolate Soufflé is described as having a strong chocolate flavor but a runnier center than expected.
"The Duck Ragu Pappardelle is noted for its tender duck and silky noodles, and the Beef Wellington is praised for its flavor and crisp pastry."
Customers generally view the restaurant as a top choice for romantic occasions, with many highlighting its intimate ambiance and suitability for proposals. However, some feedback suggests the food may be dated and less impressive compared to the atmosphere.
Important Note
Some diners feel the food has become dated and forgettable, and the restaurant may now function more as an event venue than a purely culinary destination.
"This commenter recommended One if by Land, Two if by Sea as a very intimate and romantic spot where many proposals happen."
Positive"One if by Land, Two if by Sea is an old favorite for romantic dining."
Positive"This user criticizes the initial suggestions, including One if by Land Two if by Sea, implying they are outdated and no longer good recommendations."
Negative"This user gives a strongly negative, one-word opinion on One if by Land, Two if by Sea, calling it "Gross.""
Negative"This user strongly disapproves of One if by Land, Two if by Sea, implying its quality or relevance is outdated and no longer suitable."
Negative"This user suggests One if by Land, Two if by Sea as a recommendation."
Neutral"This user suggests One if by Land Two if by Sea as a recommendation for the original poster's proposal night."
Neutral"This user lists One if by Land Two if by Sea as one of their recommendations for the original poster's proposal night."
Neutral"Suggests "One if by land, two if by sea" as a possibility. Notes it might be more of an event venue now."
Neutral"Recommends One if by Land, Two if by Sea as a possibility for upscale, quintessential NY dining."
Positive
