Timeless West Village gem with a celeb-favored vibe, cozy fireplaces, and classic American fare. Perfect for date nights or a taste of old New York.
Molly Fitzpatrick reviews The Waverly Inn, a timeless West Village restaurant with a classic NYC atmosphere, solid food, and an unbeatable vibe. Explore dishes like their famous biscuits and a juicy cheeseburger.
The Waverly Inn offers a timeless and trendy West Village experience with a classic NYC atmosphere, complemented by solid food and an unbeatable vibe. While known for its celebrity clientele and discreet no-photographs policy, the restaurant impresses with its intimate, fireplace-lit setting, making it ideal for date nights. The complimentary biscuits with whipped honey butter are a standout, alongside other well-executed dishes like the juicy cheeseburger and comforting chicken pot pie.
The American cuisine at Waverly Inn is generally well-regarded, with standout items including the complimentary biscuits, the juicy cheeseburger with excellent fries, and the comforting chicken pot pie. However, the truffle mac & cheese is noted as a pricey dish to skip due to an off-putting truffle oil flavor. The onion rings are also a recommended item.
"The complimentary biscuits with whipped honey butter are a must-try, as are the juicy cheeseburger with its excellent fries, and the large, puffy onion rings served with spicy aioli."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards the restaurant, highlighting its excellent atmosphere and romantic setting, though some find the food to be merely edible.
Important Note
One reviewer found the truffle mac & cheese to be overpriced and not worth ordering due to its truffle oil flavor.
"This user mentions going to Waverly Inn for their 30th birthday and fondly recalling the memories, noting that Anna Wintour was present during their visit."
Positive"This comment suggests Waverly inn."
Positive"Waverly Inn is suggested as an additional restaurant option."
Neutral"The user expresses a preference for Waverly Inn, noting its shared revival history with Monkey Bar under Greydon Carter."
Positive"The user visits Waverly Inn more frequently than Monkey Bar because it is easier to access and closer to their home, though they prefer Monkey Bar overall."
Neutral"The user enthusiastically describes Waverly Inn as fantastic."
Positive"The original poster compares Waverly Inn to Monkey Bar, asking if Monkey Bar is a more polished, slightly more expensive version of it."
Neutral"This user recommends Waverly Inn, highlighting its fireplace and open patio, suggesting it offers a romantic atmosphere perfect for a proposal night, especially when followed by a walk in the West Village."
Positive"The Waverley Inn is another potential option, partly because Taylor Swift has reportedly dined there, which is a positive for the birthday boy."
Neutral"Recommends Waverly Inn."
Positive"The author praised Waverly Inn's good atmosphere but found the food edible at best across approximately three visits."
Negative"Recommends Waverly Inn as a potential spot for the user's cozy birthday dinner."
Positive"Recommendation for Waverly Inn."
Neutral
