TLDR
Classic American burgers served in comfortable booths, now featuring fresh hand rolls at their uptown location.
Reddit Sentiment for 5 NAPKIN BURGER(based on 11 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The post announces that 5 Napkin Burger is offering hand rolls at their Upper West Side location. The image displays a selection of these hand rolls, which appear to be made with fresh ingredients. The caption suggests that the hand rolls are very appealing and may lead to repeat orders.
Details
Known for a reliable American burger experience, this Manhattan staple offers a comfortable dining environment with spacious booths [2]. While some patrons find the quality inconsistent for the price point, others consider it a satisfying local option [1], [3]. Beyond the signature burgers, the Upper West Side location has recently expanded its menu to include fresh hand rolls [10].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American-style burgers, including popular truffle and classic variations [1]. Feedback on the food is varied, with some customers preferring alternative halal options [5], [8], though many still find the offerings to be a solid choice for a casual meal [2], [6]. Recently, the restaurant has introduced hand rolls to its UWS menu, which are highlighted as a fresh and highly recommended addition [10].
Caveats
Some visitors may find the quality does not always justify the price point [3], and some long-time fans have questioned if the experience remains as high-quality as it was in previous years [10].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About 5 NAPKIN BURGER
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Best Fastcasual Burger With Lettuce Tomato And
"Clarifies that the preference for kofta-like burgers over 5 Napkin Burger is a matter of personal taste."
NeutralFrom post: Best Fastcasual Burger With Lettuce Tomato And
"The commenter lists Zurna, Zaad, and Shah's as halal places with better burgers than Five Napkin and Bareburger."
PositiveFrom post: Best Fastcasual Burger With Lettuce Tomato And
"In response to a negative comparison, this commenter defends 5 Napkin Burger, stating it clears the bar set by halal restaurants and is fine for the price, though acknowledges personal taste can differ."
NeutralFrom post: Best Fastcasual Burger With Lettuce Tomato And
"The commenter used to love 5 Napkin Burger but is unsure if it's still as good as it was 10 years ago."
NeutralFrom post: Best Fastcasual Burger With Lettuce Tomato And
"The commenter expresses a preference for burgers from halal restaurants over 5 Napkin Burger, finding them superior."
NegativeFrom post: Best Fastcasual Burger With Lettuce Tomato And
"A second recommendation for 5 Napkin Burger."
PositiveFrom post: Best Fastcasual Burger With Lettuce Tomato And
"5 Napkin Burger is suggested as an option, slightly above the $20 price point."
NeutralFrom post: Not The Best Restaurant
"The user had a disappointing experience at Five Napkin Burger (UWS) for their birthday, finding both their and their girlfriend's meals to be poor quality for the price, but would be open to trying again."
NegativeFrom post: Not The Best Restaurant
"This user agrees with the previous comment, stating that a burger doesn't need to be life-changing and that Five Napkin Burger offers a satisfying experience with comfortable booths."
PositiveFrom post: Not The Best Restaurant
"The user admits Five Napkin Burger's burgers aren't top-ranked but are delicious, recommending the classic or truffle burger. They disclose a personal bias due to a friend being the GM."
Positive