Details
A beloved Brooklyn spot, The Commodore is frequently recommended for its exceptional fried chicken, often described as having maximum crunch and even hailed as the best in the city [20], [24]. Beyond their standout chicken, patrons also rave about the Cadillac nachos and the potent, vacation-inducing Piña Colada [17], [4], [26]. This casual American eatery also offers late-night dining options and is known for its good value, with mentions of potentially $4 beers [10], [29].
Food Overview
The Commodore is renowned for its fried chicken, consistently lauded for its maximum crunch and often called the best in the city [1], [2], [17], [20], [24], [34]. Other highly recommended dishes include the Cadillac nachos, noted for their generous portions, and the French dip, described as amazing [17], [27], [38]. The Piña Colada, especially with an amaretto float, is a popular drink that evokes a vacation feel [4], [26]. The menu also features items like hot fish, tuna melts, and fries, all contributing to its reputation as a great casual American dining spot [29], [30], [32].
Highlights / Recommended
"The hot fried chicken sandwich is frequently cited as a must-try, with some calling it the best in the city. Nachos, particularly the Cadillac nachos, are also highly recommended for their generous portions."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •chicken fried(3)
Customer Sentiment
Customers overwhelmingly praise The Commodore, with frequent mentions of its outstanding fried chicken and enjoyable atmosphere. While most feedback is positive, one user expressed a slight preference for another bar's ambiance despite liking the food [23].
Caveats
While generally highly praised, one Reddit user mentioned preferring another bar's atmosphere over The Commodore's, despite enjoying the fried chicken [23].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE COMMODORE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Need An Amazing Steak Sandwich Under 30 Doesnt
"The brisket dip sandwich at The Commodore in Brooklyn is described as life-changing."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Nyc Food After A Night Of
"Chicken fried from The Commodore is mentioned as a late-night food option."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Nyc Food After A Night Of
"Chicken fried from The Commodore is mentioned as a late-night food option."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Nyc Food After A Night Of
"Chicken fried from The Commodore is mentioned as a late-night food option."
PositiveFrom post: 2026 Nyc Food Trip Review How Did I Do Overall
"The user suggested that the plate of nachos is the primary reason to visit The Commodore."
NeutralFrom post: 2026 Nyc Food Trip Review How Did I Do Overall
"The user specifically mentioned the 'medium breast' at The Commodore as being legendary."
PositiveFrom post: 2026 Nyc Food Trip Review How Did I Do Overall
"The user reminisced about getting the Piña Colada from The Commodore to go during peak COVID and enjoying it while walking around the neighborhood at sunset."
PositiveFrom post: 2026 Nyc Food Trip Review How Did I Do Overall
"The user mentioned that the fried chicken at The Commodore is under the radar and, when paired with their Piña Colada, constitutes a top 10 NYC bite."
PositiveFrom post: 2026 Nyc Food Trip Review How Did I Do Overall
"The user enjoyed the chicken sandwich at The Commodore, appreciating the seeded bun and slaw. The fried chicken plate was also considered solid."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Lose Beef Virginity
"The original poster is considering various options for their first beef experience, including burgers and sandwiches, while deliberately excluding steak."
NeutralFrom post: Hot Dogs And Nachos
"The Commodore is recommended for nachos."
PositiveFrom post: Hot Dogs And Nachos
"This user suggested The Commodore for nachos."
PositiveFrom post: Hot Dogs And Nachos
"The Commodore is mentioned as a place with pretty good and large portions of nachos."
PositiveFrom post: Rowdy Rooster In The East Village Has Closed For
"In response to a request for spicy fried chicken sandwich recommendations, the commenter suggests Commodore as a decent option."
NeutralFrom post: Where Can I Get A Mudslide Andor Bushwacker
"The commenter suggested that The Commodore in Williamsburg might have the Mudslide that the original poster was looking for."
NeutralFrom post: Which Nonfast Food Chicken Sandwiches And Tender
"This user recommended The Commodore and Commodore II for their delicious chicken sandwiches."
PositiveFrom post: Your Favorite Go To Restaurant That Doesnt Break
"Recommends The Commodore for good, affordable food."
PositiveFrom post: Iso The Cheapest Pint And Glass Of Wine In The
"The Commodore in Williamsburg is mentioned as possibly still having $4 beers, based on a positive remark from another customer."
PositiveFrom post: Visiting Nyc Tomorrow Best Spicy Fried Chicken
"The Commodore's spicy chicken sandwich is recommended as a good option."
PositiveFrom post: Since Its Lent Where Is The Best Fish Sandwich
"The commenter suggests trying the hot fish or tuna melt at The Commodore."
Positive