TLDR
Iconic Southern-style comfort food and fried chicken, paired with signature frozen Piña Coladas in a laid-back, late-night setting.
Details
Renowned for its legendary fried chicken and decadent comfort food, this neighborhood staple is a favorite for casual, high-quality dining [1]. Diners consistently rave about standout items like the brisket dip sandwich [2] and their signature Piña Colada, which is often considered a top NYC culinary pairing [3]. Whether for a late-night bite or a relaxed meal, the restaurant maintains a stellar reputation for delivering flavorful, affordable dishes that keep patrons coming back [4].
Food Overview
Specializing in American and Southern bar food, the menu is defined by its highly praised fried chicken, often cited as the best in the city [6]. Highly recommended dishes include the hot fried chicken sandwich [7], the brisket dip sandwich [2], and generously portioned nachos [8]. Patrons also enjoy the hot fish, tuna melt [4], and frozen cocktails [9].
Caveats
Some patrons inquire about the availability of specific legacy menu items like the adult grilled cheese to confirm if they remain as good as previously remembered [10].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE COMMODORE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Manhattan Trip Specific Requests For 2026 Best
"Suggested in a general list of fried chicken recommendations."
PositiveFrom post: Any Fried Green Tomato Sandwich Recommendations A
"The user suggests that the fried green tomato dish here is quite good."
PositiveFrom post: Best Grilled Cheese In Nyc Grilled Cheese Lover
"The user is inquiring if their 'adult grilled cheese' is still on the menu and if it remains good."
NeutralFrom post: Fried Chicken Sandwich In The City Any
"Confirmed they make a very good spicy chicken sandwich."
PositiveFrom post: Fried Chicken Sandwich In The City Any
"People seem to like this spot for fried chicken sandwiches."
Positive