Last Updated: 3 months ago
Phone: (212) 831-9156
Address: 1553-55 LEXINGTON AVENUE 10029
Dense, moist carrot cake w/ tangy cream cheese frosting. Also acclaimed red velvet & a classic NYC sweet spot.
Molly Fitzpatrick reviews Lloyd's Carrot Cake, an East Harlem bakery famous for its dense, moist carrot cake with tangy cream cheese frosting. The article praises their red velvet cake and the bakery's iconic status in NYC.
This East Harlem bakery, a classic NYC establishment since 1986, is famed for its dense and moist carrot cake, complete with a tangy cream cheese frosting. While the signature carrot cake is a must-try, the red velvet cake also receives high praise for its sweet, nutty flavor and soft texture. The small storefront is a testament to its enduring popularity, focusing on takeaway treats that honor a cherished family recipe.
Primarily known for its dense and moist carrot cake featuring a tangy cream cheese frosting, with options to add nuts and raisins. The red velvet cake is also a highly recommended alternative, praised for its sweet, nutty soak and soft crumb. While many find the carrot cake to be a standout, a few opinions suggest it might be overrated, and one reviewer was deterred by a 'B' health rating.
"The dense, moist carrot cake with tangy cream cheese frosting is the signature item, with options to add nuts and raisins. The red velvet cake is also highly praised for its sweet, nutty flavor and soft crumb."
Customers generally praise the bakery's signature carrot cake and red velvet offerings, appreciating the dense, moist texture and tangy frosting. However, some reviews indicate a less favorable experience with the carrot cake, and one mention of a 'B' health rating was noted.
Important Note
One reviewer noted a 'B' health rating for the establishment.
"The author noted that Lloyd's Carrot Cake had a 'B' health rating, which deterred them from trying it."
Negative"The author enjoyed Lloyd's Carrot Cake, considering it a spice cake and appreciating it served warm."
Positive"The author strongly agreed that Lloyd's Carrot Cake is overrated."
Negative"The author was not impressed with Lloyd's Carrot Cake."
Negative"The author mentioned trying the Carrot Cake at Lloyd's Carrot Cake."
Neutral"Lloyd's is listed among several bakeries as a potential place for cake."
Neutral"Lloyds in East Harlem is recommended as significantly better than any carrot cake found in Queens. The commenter advises planning a trip there."
Positive"This commenter listed Lloyds as a downtown option for carrot cake, implying it's a good choice."
Positive"Lloyd's Carrot Cake was recommended, likely for its red velvet offerings."
Positive"Lloyds Carrot Cake is suggested as another nearby option if carrot cake is desired."
Neutral"The commenter also mentions Lloyds Carrot Cake as an option not far from S & S Cheesecake."
Neutral"The commenter mentioned that Lloyd's Carrot Cake (referred to as 'Lloyds') is also a good option for cake."
Positive
