A beloved steakhouse, slaying for 20 years [1] with a sexy, upscale vibe that doesn't take itself too seriously. Known for its steaks, classic sides, and must-try desserts like Baked Alaska [2] and chocolate cake [3].
A long-standing favorite for two decades, this steakhouse is celebrated for its enduring quality and vibrant atmosphere. It's recommended as a top-tier steakhouse option with a lively vibe and a unique charm that sets it apart from more traditional establishments [1]. The establishment is known for its steaks, classic sides, and unique dishes like the Baked Alaska and a multi-layered chocolate cake [2, 3].
This steakhouse is renowned for its expertly prepared steaks, often highlighted for their flavorful crust [1]. Beyond the steaks, classic sides are frequently mentioned as being excellent [1]. For dessert, the Baked Alaska and a multi-layered chocolate cake are popular recommendations, though consistency can vary [2, 3]. While most feedback is positive, one user reported a particularly disappointing ribeye experience [4].
"The Baked Alaska and a multi-layered chocolate cake are highly recommended desserts, with the chocolate cake often suggested to be taken to-go [1, 2]."
Customers have consistently praised this steakhouse for its excellent food, especially the steaks and classic sides, and its fun, lively atmosphere [1]. While some reviews highlight occasional inconsistencies in service or food quality over the years, the overall sentiment remains highly positive, with many considering it a long-time favorite.
Important Note
Some diners have noted a decline in meat quality and inconsistent waiter service over the years, potentially due to ownership changes [1]. One reviewer had a particularly negative experience with a ribeye steak, though they acknowledge it might have been an off night [2].
"Responding to a comment about waiter inconsistency, the original poster admitted they might be picky, but felt that while Strip House's food is excellent, the hospitality at other places is top-notch, whereas at Strip House, waiter quality varies."
Negative"The commenter has been to the 12th street Strip House location over 5 times and is always happy, never having real problems with waiters, although they have been asked to move to the bar with a complimentary drink after finishing their meal."
Negative"The commenter stated that Strip House remains their favorite steakhouse."
Positive"The reviewer has been going to Strip House for a decade and twice in the last year. They describe it as a bawdy, sexy, upscale place that doesn't take itself too seriously. The steak and classic sides were praised as punching above their weight, and the goat cheese salad and other sides were also great. The multi-layered chocolate cake is a favorite, though consistency varies. Pros include fantastic food and sides, and a fun atmosphere, while cons are that it's not 'fancy-schmancy' and waiter quality can be inconsistent."
Negative"Strip House is recommended."
Positive"The commenter notes Strip House's decline in quality since ownership changes, with meat quality no longer matching its initial standards. They previously visited frequently but no longer do."
Negative"Strip House might be preferable for its alcohol selection and cocktails if one is a drinker, though the commenter doesn't drink themselves. Otherwise, Golden Steer is preferred."
Neutral"The commenter enjoys Strip House in the West Village, praising its great vibe and excellent food, particularly the salty peppery crust on the steak."
Positive"The commenter strongly advises against Strip House, stating it has been awful for 20 years and that Golden Steer is a much better choice."
Negative"Strip House is considered one of the best steakhouses in NYC, unlike Old Homestead which has declined significantly in quality. The commenter has had consistently bad experiences at Old Homestead recently."
Positive"Strip House is stated to be the commenter's favorite steakhouse in the city, by a significant margin."
Positive"The commenter had a negative experience at Strip House a few months prior, finding their ribeye to be the worst they'd had in a long time, though they acknowledge it might have been an off day."
Negative"Strip House is the commenter's favorite steakhouse in the city and is recommended."
Positive"While considering both options, the commenter initially leaned towards Golden Steer, indicating Strip House is good but perhaps less memorable compared to Golden Steer's appetizers and steaks like the lobster tail and prime rib."
Neutral"When comparing Strip House and Golden Steer, the commenter suggests looking at interiors and desserts, as meat quality is similar. They specifically recommend getting the chocolate cake to-go from Strip House."
Neutral"Strip House is recommended."
Positive"Strip House is mentioned as an option, alongside 4 Charles and Wolfgang's in Tribeca, for steak."
Neutral"Strip House is recommended."
Positive"This user believes Strip House is superior to Keens."
Positive"Strip House is recommended for its great vibes, making it suitable for a celebratory dinner."
Positive
