Next.js logo

SAGAPONACK

Updated

Phone: (212) 229-2226

Address: 4 WEST 22 STREET 10010

TLDR

Seafood haven w/ cozy vibes. $1 oyster happy hr & delish 'nduja mussels.

Reddit Sentiment for SAGAPONACK(based on 11 Reddit opinions)

45% Positive45% Neutral9% Negative

Achievements and Accolades

Next.js logo

Tags

seafood 2oysters 5seafood 2View All

Neighborhoods

Flatiron District

Details

This Manhattan seafood spot is a versatile choice, praised for its cozy atmosphere and accommodating nature for both intimate dinners and larger celebrations. Guests can enjoy a delightful happy hour featuring $1 oysters, though some note they are on the smaller side. The menu also boasts highly recommended dishes like the 'nduja mussels and classic fish and chips.

Food Overview

Primarily a seafood restaurant, with standout recommendations for their fish and chips and 'nduja mussels. The happy hour offers $1 oysters, which are a popular draw, though some find them to be quite small. Spicy margaritas are also mentioned positively.

Highlights / Recommended

"Highly recommended dishes include the fish and chips and the 'nduja mussels. The $1 oyster happy hour is also a significant draw, though portion size might be a consideration."

Mentioned Dishes:

  • oysters(3)

Customer Sentiment

Overall positive, with frequent praise for its atmosphere, happy hour deals on oysters, and specific dishes like the 'nduja mussels and fish and chips. Some find the happy hour oysters to be small.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About SAGAPONACK

This post recommends Sagaponack for its fish and chips, indicating it's a strong contender for one of the best in the city.
This thread discusses Sagaponack's $1 oyster happy hour. While one user praises the deal, another notes the oysters are 'tiny' and a third mentions a limit of one dozen per person.
A user specifically recommends the 'nduja mussels dish at Sagaponack, highlighting it as a must-try.
Sagaponack is recommended as a go-to spot known for great oysters and spicy margaritas, offering a relaxed atmosphere.
Sagaponack is suggested as a venue for a birthday party, with comments noting its cozy atmosphere, high ceilings, and good accessibility.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Casual Bite In Flatiron

"Sagaponack is recommended as a perfect spot for lingering with a book during the day, noting it's quiet and has great happy hour prices. A user recalled a mediocre date there previously."

Positive
Apr 20, 2026View Comment →

From post: Restaurants That Havent Been Impacted By

"This user adds a detail to the discussion about sagaponack's $1 oyster happy hour, stating there's a limit of one dozen oysters per person."

Neutral
Sep 25, 2025View Comment →

From post: Restaurants That Havent Been Impacted By

"Replying to a comment about sagaponack's $1 oyster happy hour, this user notes that the oysters are 'tiny'."

Negative
Sep 23, 2025View Comment →

From post: Restaurants That Havent Been Impacted By

"A short, possibly sarcastic, comment suggesting that information about sagaponack's $1 oyster happy hour should be kept quiet."

Neutral
Sep 23, 2025View Comment →

From post: Restaurants That Havent Been Impacted By

"This commenter mentions that sagaponack offers $1 oyster happy hours."

Positive
Sep 23, 2025View Comment →

From post: Restaurant For Birthday

"This restaurant was able to accommodate a party of 12 people."

Neutral
Sep 16, 2025View Comment →

From post: Birthday Dinner In The City Any Private Room

"Sagaponack was recommended and linked for services and events, suggesting it can accommodate the user's needs."

Positive
Sep 4, 2025View Comment →

From post: Private Room For Party Review

"Sagoppnack was considered as a venue for a private party. The minimum menu pricing was $45 per person."

Neutral
Aug 28, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Casual Dinner And Cocktails With Great

"This restaurant was suggested as one of many options near the user's location. It's considered a good choice depending on the user's food preferences."

Neutral
Aug 25, 2025View Comment →

From post: Sunday Night Dinner Solo Diner Bar Seating

"Sagaponack is described as a go-to spot with great oysters and spicy margs, offering chill vibes."

Positive
Jul 1, 2025View Comment →

From post: Nduja

"Garconavecunreve recommends the 'nduja mussels dish available at Sagaponack."

Positive
May 17, 2025View Comment →