Last Updated: 8 days ago
Phone: (347) 460-5507
Address: 495 LORIMER STREET 11211
Mind-blowing sandwiches and a fire slushie.
Edith's Sandwich Counter is a Brooklyn-based spot that has quickly gained a reputation for its creative and delicious sandwiches, blending American and Jewish deli traditions. Their standout items include a highly praised pastrami on rye and a smoked turkey hoagie featuring house-made pickles. Don't miss their unique tahini ice coffee slushy, described as an addictive treat, or their decadent chocolate babka for dessert.
Edith's Sandwich Counter is celebrated for its inventive and high-quality sandwiches, with particular acclaim for their pastrami on rye and smoked turkey hoagie. The tahini ice coffee slushy has also garnered significant attention for its unique flavor and addictive quality. While most reviews are overwhelmingly positive, one customer found the bagels to be subpar.
"Highly recommended are the pastrami on rye and the smoked turkey hoagie. The tahini ice coffee slushy is also a must-try unique beverage."
Customers generally have a very positive experience at Edith's Sandwich Counter, frequently praising the unique and high-quality offerings, especially their inventive sandwiches and slushies. While some find the prices slightly high, the overall consensus is that the food is worth the cost.
Important Note
One reviewer found the bagels to be of poor quality.
"This user considers the smoked turkey 'gero' from Edith's their 'GOAT' (Greatest Of All Time) sandwich."
Positive"Edith's is listed as a great casual option."
Positive"The commenter experiences wallet regret at Edith's but finds their items, like the slushie, to be very good."
Positive"Edith's coffee tahini slushie, priced at $9, is no longer seen as exceptionally crazy given current coffee prices in the city."
Neutral"The user recommended Edith's."
Neutral"The user notes that Edith's prices for sandwiches are not as high as Salt Hanks, implying Salt Hanks is overpriced."
Neutral"Edith's was simply mentioned as a suggestion for a good BLT."
Neutral"The commenter believes Edith's bagels are awful because they fall apart when eaten."
Negative"Edith's is considered a pretty good choice for bagels in Williamsburg."
Positive"Edith's smoked turkey hoagie is a favorite turkey sandwich in the city, praised for its homemade pickled ingredients and smoked turkey, which justify its slightly higher price."
Positive"Edith's in Brooklyn is recommended for its pastrami on rye."
Positive"The user just had Edith's Sandwich Counter and found it mind-blowing, also praising their iced coffee slushy as 'fire'."
Positive"The user declares Edith's Sandwich Counter 'pretty fire'."
Positive"Listed Edith's as a recommended sandwich shop."
Neutral
