Last Updated: ~2 months ago
Phone: (347) 460-5507
Address: 495 LORIMER STREET 11211
Mind-blowing sandwiches & addictive coffee slushies. Jewish deli classics w/ a modern twist.
This Brooklyn sandwich counter offers a taste of Jewish deli classics with a modern twist. Customers rave about their creative and delicious sandwiches, particularly the pastrami on rye and the smoked turkey hoagie. Don't miss their unique iced coffee slushies, which are a surprising hit.
Edith's Sandwich Counter is highly regarded for its inventive sandwiches, with the pastrami on rye and the smoked turkey hoagie frequently highlighted as must-tries. The establishment also receives significant praise for its unique coffee slushies, especially the tahini flavor. While most feedback is overwhelmingly positive, a few comments suggest that prices may be on the higher side, and there's a dissenting opinion on the quality of their bagels.
"Standout dishes include the pastrami on rye, the smoked turkey hoagie, and the unique coffee slushies, particularly the tahini flavor. The schnitzel club is also recommended."
Customers consistently praise the unique and delicious sandwiches, with many calling them 'mind-blowing.' The coffee slushies are also a standout, though some note the prices can be a bit high.
Important Note
Some customers find the prices to be on the higher side, and there is a dissenting opinion regarding the quality of their bagels.
"Edith's is suggested as a good option for wraps."
Positive"Edith's is recommended, with the user mentioning they've only been to the Williamsburg location but believe there's also one in West Village."
Positive"The user recommended the schnitzel club at Edith's in Bushwick."
Positive"Edith's was enthusiastically recommended."
Positive"This user expressed annoyance that Edith's increased the price and significantly reduced the size of their slushies."
Negative"This user defended Edith's, stating there's no reason to dislike it and that both the slushies and sandwiches are good."
Positive"This user found that a slushie from Edith's on a hot day was heavenly."
Positive"This commenter recommended the Iced Cafe Slushie at Edith's, calling it very good. They also mentioned that the establishment may have offered a Diet Coke version at one point."
Positive"This user mentioned that Edith's slushies are great and not to believe the negative opinions on the subreddit. They specifically called out the cold brew/tahini/oat milk flavor as a classic and noted that seasonal flavors are also available."
Positive"This user considers the smoked turkey 'gero' from Edith's their 'GOAT' (Greatest Of All Time) sandwich."
Positive"Edith's is listed as a great casual option."
Positive"The commenter experiences wallet regret at Edith's but finds their items, like the slushie, to be very good."
Positive"Edith's coffee tahini slushie, priced at $9, is no longer seen as exceptionally crazy given current coffee prices in the city."
Neutral"The user recommended Edith's."
Neutral"The user notes that Edith's prices for sandwiches are not as high as Salt Hanks, implying Salt Hanks is overpriced."
Neutral"Edith's was simply mentioned as a suggestion for a good BLT."
Neutral"The commenter believes Edith's bagels are awful because they fall apart when eaten."
Negative"Edith's is considered a pretty good choice for bagels in Williamsburg."
Positive"Edith's smoked turkey hoagie is a favorite turkey sandwich in the city, praised for its homemade pickled ingredients and smoked turkey, which justify its slightly higher price."
Positive"Edith's in Brooklyn is recommended for its pastrami on rye."
Positive
