TLDR
Elevated deli classics paired with cult-favorite slushies. A go-to for hearty bagel sandwiches, schnitzel clubs, and creative seasonal eats.
Instagram Posts References
Edith's is highlighted for its seasonal BLT sandwich, featuring thick slices of juicy heirloom tomatoes and a unique smoked corn mayo on toasted bread. This sandwich is described as a highly anticipated annual special.
The post shows the user enjoying a hearty bagel sandwich filled with scrambled eggs and avocado, along with an iced coffee, from Edith's Bk, suggesting a delightful and substantial breakfast or brunch.
Details
Renowned for its creative deli-style sandwiches and signature slushies, this spot serves as a neighborhood favorite for hearty, casual meals [1]. Patrons frequently highlight the quality of their wraps and seasonal specials like the popular smoked corn mayo BLT [2], [3]. While the food is consistently lauded, guests should note that the establishment does not provide traditional table service [4].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on elevated American-Jewish deli fare, featuring standouts like the schnitzel club [6] and a variety of well-regarded wraps [7]. The slushie selection, particularly the cold brew-tahini-oat milk flavor, is frequently recommended [1], [5], though seasonal items like the heirloom tomato BLT with smoked corn mayo garner significant acclaim [3].
Customer Sentiment
Overall sentiment remains highly positive, with customers consistently praising the quality of the sandwiches and the refreshing nature of their drink offerings [1], [5]. While most visitors enjoy the experience, some have noted frustrations regarding recent price increases and reduced portion sizes for specific items [1].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About EDITH'S SANDWICH COUNTER
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Recommendations For Sandwich Restaurants That Are
"This commenter listed Edith's Eatery among other places that are good for sandwiches but noted it doesn't have waiters."
PositiveFrom post: What Spot Has The Best Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap
"Edith's is suggested as a good option for wraps."
PositiveFrom post: What Spot Has The Best Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap
"Edith's is recommended, with the user mentioning they've only been to the Williamsburg location but believe there's also one in West Village."
PositiveFrom post: Best Fried Chicken Cutlet
"The user recommended the schnitzel club at Edith's in Bushwick."
PositiveFrom post: Tuna Melt Lower Manhattan
"Edith's was enthusiastically recommended."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Places To Get A Nonbasic Slushy
"This user expressed annoyance that Edith's increased the price and significantly reduced the size of their slushies."
NegativeFrom post: Favorite Places To Get A Nonbasic Slushy
"This user defended Edith's, stating there's no reason to dislike it and that both the slushies and sandwiches are good."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Places To Get A Nonbasic Slushy
"This user found that a slushie from Edith's on a hot day was heavenly."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Places To Get A Nonbasic Slushy
"This commenter recommended the Iced Cafe Slushie at Edith's, calling it very good. They also mentioned that the establishment may have offered a Diet Coke version at one point."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Places To Get A Nonbasic Slushy
"This user mentioned that Edith's slushies are great and not to believe the negative opinions on the subreddit. They specifically called out the cold brew/tahini/oat milk flavor as a classic and noted that seasonal flavors are also available."
Positive