Updated
Phone: (212) 661-1520
Address: 1065 AVENUE OF THE AMERICAS 10018
Classic Jewish deli w/ bagels & smoked fish [1]. Known for lunch specials & decent coffee [2]. Some find it 'very mid' & disappointing [3].
Zucker's Bagels & Smoked Fish is a popular spot known for its New York-style bagels and Jewish deli offerings. While some praise their lunch specials and the ability to transport bagels home, others have found the quality to be inconsistent, citing issues with saltiness and overall mediocrity. The establishment offers a classic deli experience with options like cream cheese and lox, and even pairs with Irving Farm coffee.
Zucker's specializes in bagels and smoked fish, offering a Jewish deli experience with American influences. Recommended items include their bagels, which some find freeze well [1], and lunch specials that are considered reasonably priced [2]. However, there are notable criticisms regarding the quality of the bagels, with some reviewers finding them 'very mid' and disappointing [3, 4], and one user reporting overly salty fish salad smears [5]. The coffee, specifically Irving Farm, is described as 'decent' [6].
"Zucker's is noted for its bagels, which some recommend for their chewy texture and ability to freeze well [1]. Their lunch specials are also considered a reasonable option [2]."
Customer feedback is divided. While some appreciate the value of lunch specials and the quality of bagels for transport [1], others have expressed strong dissatisfaction with the taste of bagels and fish salad, with some calling it 'very mid' and not worth the effort [2, 3].
Important Note
Customer opinions are sharply divided, with some finding the quality disappointing and not worth the price, while others find the lunch specials to be a good value.
"In response to a comment about Zuckers, the user agreed that the Irving Farm coffee is 'decent' and that the bagels are also 'decent'."
Neutral"The user believes Zuckers might be an exception for combining bagels and coffee, though they described the coffee (Irving Farm) and bagels as 'decent' rather than 'good'."
Neutral"Zucker's is recommended for bagels that freeze well, characterized as chewy."
Positive"The author was disappointed with a bagel sandwich from Zucker's, finding it to be one of the few bagel experiences in the city they regretted paying for."
Negative"This user has experience transporting bagels from Zuckers to other locations and finds freezing them upon arrival to be the easiest method."
Positive"This commenter advised getting rid of Zucker's Bagels from the list, calling it 'very mid' and not worth the effort."
Negative"This commenter advised getting rid of Zucker's Bagels from the list, calling it 'very mid' and not worth the effort."
Negative"This commenter had one of their worst bagel experiences at Zucker's before the pandemic, finding it infuriatingly disappointing."
Negative"This commenter had one of their worst bagel experiences at Zucker's before the pandemic, finding it infuriatingly disappointing."
Negative"The commenter suggests getting a New York bagel at Zucker's, mentioning cream cheese and lox as a topping."
Positive"This user has had negative experiences at Zucker's, finding their bagels not good, fish salad smears too salty, and also takes issue with being charged for water."
Negative"Zucker's Bagels on 6th Ave and 40th St is suggested as a place to get bagels, to be eaten in Bryant Park."
Neutral"Zucker's Bagels offers lunch specials with sandwiches that are not too expensive, considering all factors."
Positive
