Singing servers serenade you with Broadway hits over classic diner fare. A unique, high-energy Times Square experience!
Bryan Kim reviews Ellen's Stardust Diner, a touristy but entertaining NYC spot where singing servers perform Broadway hits, offering a unique experience that's perfect for out-of-towners or those craving a dose of theatrical kitsch.
Experience the magic of Broadway without leaving your seat at this iconic Times Square diner. Known for its singing waitstaff who are aspiring performers, Ellen's Stardust Diner offers a unique blend of American comfort food and live musical theater. While the food itself may be secondary to the dazzling performances, the energetic atmosphere and theatrical flair make it a must-visit for families and theater enthusiasts.
The food at Ellen's Stardust Diner is consistently described as average diner fare, with some finding it overpriced and mediocre. While dishes like the "Stardust Nachos" and "Yankee Doodle Burger" are mentioned, the culinary aspect is clearly secondary to the entertainment. Some reviewers even suggest not ordering much food and focusing on the experience.
"While specific dishes aren't highly praised, the overall experience of American diner food is available. The focus should be on the singing entertainment rather than a specific dish."
Customers generally agree that the food is mediocre, but the singing waitstaff and lively atmosphere provide a memorable and entertaining experience, especially for families and tourists.
Important Note
The food quality is generally considered mediocre and overpriced, with many visitors prioritizing the singing entertainment over the culinary experience. Long lines can also be a deterrent.
"Ellen's Stardust Diner is mentioned as a classic option for dining."
Positive"Ellen's Stardust Diner was mentioned by the author, Bryan Kim, as a reviewed establishment. He is the editorial lead for Infatuation in NYC."
Neutral"The commenter suggests embracing Ellen's Stardust Diner for its unique feature of singing servers, a novelty not found elsewhere."
Neutral"The commenter realized from another post that Ellen's Stardust Diner is recommended to visitors on other platforms, expressing surprise and dismay."
Negative"The commenter found Ellen's Stardust Diner to be 'pretty awesome' but advised against ordering much food as it 'sucks'."
Negative"Responding to a comparison, the commenter preferred Ellen's Stardust Diner for its 'in your face' performances, emphasizing that visitors should not expect good food."
Neutral"The commenter expressed unfamiliarity with Ellen's Stardust Diner and its location, indicating it's a place they haven't experienced despite living in NYC."
Neutral"The commenter mentions that a Facebook group called 'What to do in NY' features tourists discussing how great Ellen's Stardust Diner is."
Neutral"The commenter preferred Gayle's Broadway Rose over Ellen's Stardust Diner for its better food and vibes, suggesting it as a compromise for Times Square singing waitstaff."
Positive"This commenter agrees with skipping Ellen's, citing long lines, overpriced food, and poor quality, suggesting that the singing waiters are the main draw but can be experienced better elsewhere."
Negative"The commenter advises skipping Ellen's, suggesting that the experience with singing waiters is not worth the long lines and poor food quality, recommending a concert or Broadway show instead for singing."
Negative"This commenter advises skipping Ellen's, stating that the food is not good by New York standards, unless visiting for tourist reasons, primarily for the singing waiters."
Negative"The commenter describes Ellen's Stardust Diner as a "special place" due to its unique experience, even though its food quality is generally acknowledged to be poor, suggesting that overall dining experience can outweigh culinary merit."
Neutral"Ellen's Stardust is considered popular for a reason and highly recommended if the kids enjoy Broadway or pop singing due to its unique entertainment."
Positive"Ellen's Stardust Diner offers a unique experience where staff aspiring to Broadway perform while you dine."
Neutral"Ellen's Stardust is considered a great option, especially if the wait line is small, suggesting it's worth visiting."
Positive"Ellen's Stardust Diner is suggested as a place for the previous commenter, implying it has pancakes and syrup, along with entertainment."
Neutral"This diner is recommended for its unique entertainment where the waitstaff, who are aspiring Broadway singers, perform for patrons."
Positive"Ok_Way_9634 loved Ellen’s Stardust Diner, clarifying that one doesn't go for the food."
Positive"grimly59 states that Ellen's Stardust Diner is not about the food but about having fun, and they love going before shows."
Positive
