Innovative NY-style slices & sandwiches w/ fresh toppings [1, 3]. Close to L'Industrie quality but w/ shorter lines [2].
This West Village pizzeria, Slicehaus, has quickly become a go-to spot for pizza lovers, offering a high-quality take on traditional New York slices [1]. Praised for its fresh ingredients and innovative toppings, it's considered a strong contender in the city's competitive pizza scene, often compared favorably to more established names like L'Industrie [2]. The restaurant also offers a unique selection of sandwiches, adding another dimension to its culinary appeal [3].
Slicehaus is celebrated for its high-quality New York-style and Sicilian pizza slices, with standout options including the soppresata with hot honey and the shishito pepper and sausage pizza [1, 2]. The 'marinara slice' has also been specifically praised for its rich, umami sauce [3]. While most reviews are positive, one customer found the NY-style slice to be visually appealing but lacking in flavor, with a crispy crust but underwhelming sauce and cheese [4]. The restaurant also offers creative sandwiches that are noted as a unique and exciting part of their menu [5].
"The soppresata with hot honey pizza and the shishito and sausage pie are highly recommended, with the marinara slice also receiving praise for its rich sauce [1, 2]."
Customers generally have a positive view of Slicehaus, with many recommending it for its quality pizza and innovative toppings [1, 2]. While most reviews are favorable, one diner found the NY-style slice mediocre, noting the crust was crispy but the sauce and cheese lacked depth [4].
Important Note
One reviewer found the NY-style slice from Slicehaus to be mediocre, citing a lack of depth in the sauce and cheese despite a crispy crust [1]. There is also some debate among commenters regarding the classification of their pizza as strictly 'NY-style' [2].
"This user finds Slicehaus to be great and believes Fermento might be slightly better, but it's a close call, requiring another try of both."
Positive"User likes Slicehaus on Carmine Street and mentions they introduce a new topping every week."
Positive"Commenter identified Slicehaus as one of their new favorite pizza spots with mind-blowingly good offerings."
Positive"This user commented that the pizza slices in the provided photo for Slicehaus also looked dry."
Neutral"This user found the slices at Slicehaus to be somewhat dry and almost stale during their visits."
Negative"This commenter expressed satisfaction with the savory sauce description for Slicehaus and plans to visit."
Positive"In response to a question about the sauce, this commenter praised the tomato sauce at Slicehaus, describing it as not sweet and very rich in umami."
Positive"The original poster confirmed Slicehaus was opened by an L'Industrie alum and feels it's close in quality, especially the crust, but slightly inferior in toppings. They also mentioned Cello's, another L'Industrie alum shop, which they prefer and also has no lines."
Positive"This user noted that Slicehaus was opened by a former employee of L'Industrie."
Neutral"This commenter asked about the sauce on the different slices at Slicehaus, inquiring about its sweetness or blandness compared to other places."
Neutral"This user confirmed the location of Slicehaus as being in the West Village."
Neutral"This commenter believes Slicehaus is slightly better than Lucia but both are great pizza options."
Positive"This commenter mentioned that even the Brooklyn L'Industrie location can have long lines, especially on weekends."
Neutral"This user stated they found Ceres to be mediocre and disappointing, but appreciated the perspective on Slicehaus and intends to try it."
Neutral"This user commented about the strong preference some people have for L'Industrie."
Neutral"This commenter criticized another user for leaving a rude and unhelpful comment without offering an alternative suggestion."
Neutral"This commenter offered a lower rating for Slicehaus compared to L'Industrie, suggesting 75% as a fair assessment."
Neutral"This commenter considers Slicehaus among the best recent pizza slices they've had, comparing it favorably to Lucia of Ave X and Stretch, and intends to bookmark it."
Positive"This user suggested going to the Brooklyn L'Industrie location, noting the line is usually short and it's the original."
Neutral"This user responded 'Yes. No.' to a question about Slicehaus's ownership relation to Numero 28 Pizza, implying no direct connection."
Neutral
