Last Updated: 8 days ago
Phone: (212) 689-1090
Address: 378 PARK AVENUE SOUTH 10010
NYC's go-to for consistently great American classics. Faves include the French dip & spinach artichoke dip. A polished, reliable choice.
Hillstone Manhattan, a well-regarded American establishment, offers a consistent dining experience that has been a favorite for years. While some may liken it to a more upscale version of a chain restaurant, its enduring popularity stems from reliable execution of classic dishes. It's a go-to spot for many, especially for those seeking comfort food in a polished setting.
Hillstone is celebrated for its consistently well-prepared American cuisine, with the French dip and spinach artichoke dip being frequently recommended dishes. While some find the menu familiar, most agree on the quality and execution, making it a reliable choice for classic comfort food.
"The French dip is overwhelmingly recommended and frequently cited as one of the best in the city. Other popular choices include the spinach artichoke dip and the chicken sandwich."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards Hillstone, praising its consistency and well-executed American classics, though some find it comparable to a more upscale chain.
Important Note
Some users compare Hillstone to a more upscale version of a chain restaurant like TGI Friday's, and wait times can be considerable. Reservations can also be difficult to secure, with some advice suggesting calling directly as online platforms may appear fully booked.
"This user agrees that Houston's (Hillstone's sister restaurant) French dip is their favorite and praises its bread."
Positive"This user states that Hillstone's French dip is their all-time favorite dish and found Salt Hank's to be not as good."
Negative"This commenter lists Hillstone's French dip as one of the benchmarks for pricing, stating it costs $34 and is in line with the pricing of other high-end French dips in the city."
Neutral"This user agrees that Hillstone's French dip is incredibly good and reliable."
Positive"This commenter states that the French dip at 4 Charles is potentially the best item on their menu, implicitly comparing it to other establishments."
Positive"This user considers Hillstone's French dip their all-time favorite and asks for a comparison to Salt Hank's."
Positive"This user considers Hillstone's French dip to be in the same league as Salt Hank's, but suggests Hillstone might be better overall, although Salt Hank's beef quality is superior."
Neutral"This user suggests that high-end restaurant groups often offer the best consistency, pitching Hillstone as an example."
Positive"Hillstone was recommended as a dining option."
Positive"This restaurant is listed as a repeat spot."
Positive"This restaurant is recommended."
Positive"This commenter suggests Hillstone as an 'upscale casual' option for the original poster's birthday celebration in NYC."
Positive"This user lauded Hillstone's French dip as their personal favorite, specifically highlighting the ample au jus provided."
Positive"Provided a price comparison for French dip sandwiches, listing Hillstone's at $34 with fries included, placing it as a more expensive option than Salt Hanks."
Positive"This commenter mentioned Hillstone as a benchmark for the price and quality of a French dip sandwich, indicating it's a comparable option to Salt Hanks."
Positive"Hillstone is recommended as a lunch spot."
Positive"Hillstone is suggested as an American dining option for the lunch gathering. It is mentioned alongside Isla & co and The Smith."
Neutral"Hillstone is suggested as a close match for the type of people and food the original poster is looking to entertain, implying it fits the specific 'vibe' requirement."
Neutral"The user provides the cost breakdown for French Dip + Fries at Hillstone ($34, fries included), noting it looks good compared to Salt Hanks."
Neutral"The user mentions Hillstone as a restaurant with a French dip that Salt Hanks' is considered better and cheaper than."
Neutral
