Last Updated: 24 days ago
Phone: (212) 689-1090
Address: 378 PARK AVENUE SOUTH 10010
Renowned for its legendary French dip & upscale casual vibe. A go-to spot for consistent, crowd-pleasing American fare.
This American eatery, a long-standing fixture that was formerly Houston's, offers a consistent and reliable dining experience. It's particularly celebrated for its exceptional French dip sandwich, a dish that has garnered a significant following and is often cited as a must-try. While some perceive it as a more upscale version of a chain restaurant, many appreciate its commitment to quality and its ability to please a wide range of palates.
The cuisine is primarily American, with a strong emphasis on well-executed classics. The French dip sandwich is a standout, frequently recommended by patrons. Other dishes like the spinach artichoke dip and Hawaiian Ribeye also receive praise. While some find the menu basic or a bit pricey, most agree on the consistent quality and satisfying nature of the food.
"The French dip sandwich is overwhelmingly recommended, with many considering it among the best in NYC. The spinach artichoke dip, chicken sandwich, and Hawaiian Ribeye steak are also frequently praised."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards the restaurant, with many praising its consistent quality and specific dishes like the French dip. Some find it to be a reliable choice, while others view it as a more upscale chain.
Important Note
Some reviews suggest that Hillstone can be perceived as a more expensive chain restaurant, and wait times can be significant, especially during peak hours. There are also occasional comments about the service being perceived as having a 'high-and-mighty' attitude, though this is not a widespread complaint.
"This user mentioned Hillstone but stated it does not have a view."
Neutral"This user stated that Hillstone has a great French dip."
Positive"This user commented that Hillstone is 'shockingly reliable'."
Positive"Hillstone was recommended."
Neutral"This user suggested getting a French dip to-go from Hillstone and eating it in Madison Square Park, noting it's not a winter activity."
Neutral"Hillstone was recommended alongside other restaurants."
Neutral"This user agreed with the recommendation for Hillstone."
Positive"This user mentioned Hillstone has a view of 27th and Park."
Neutral"This restaurant is recommended for French dip."
Positive"This user believes Hillstone is a reliable choice and recommended it over Salt Hanks."
Positive"This user agreed with the recommendation for Hillstone."
Positive"This commenter recommended Hillstone as a great option for Valentine's dinner, fitting the user's criteria for a nice American menu, price point, and proximity to the Empire State Building."
Positive"Suggests that many commenters on the sub act like they dine at Michelin-starred restaurants nightly, when in reality, some NYC locals prefer basic food and a nice atmosphere."
Neutral"Comments on the host's varying policies and notes that the bar seating is now limited to solo diners or pairs."
Neutral"Describes a negative experience with a host at Hillstone who claimed the waitlist was closed for the entire night, only for a co-host to later state it would open soon."
Negative"Defends Hillstone as good and dismisses comparisons to Applebees, though agrees it's not worth the reservation hassle."
Neutral"Suggests that showing up on a weekday often results in no wait or a short wait for the bar at Hillstone."
Positive"States that the 'flying chicken platter' is no longer on the menu, deeming it a 'criminal' removal."
Negative"Compares Hillstone unfavorably to Applebees, calling the food horrible and catering to unrefined tastes."
Negative"States that reservations for Hillstone become available online at midnight, one month in advance."
Neutral
