A swanky, exclusive American spot w/ a coveted, hard-to-get reservation. Think classic dishes & vibes.
Step into a world of refined American dining at The Polo Bar, where classic dishes are elevated in an atmosphere that whispers exclusivity and old-world charm. It's a place that promises an experience as curated as a Ralph Lauren runway show, offering a taste of timeless elegance in the heart of New York City. While reservations are notoriously hard to come by, securing a spot is a testament to its enduring allure and the coveted dining experience it provides.
The cuisine is classic American with a focus on upscale comfort food. Standout items mentioned include the corned beef sandwich, popovers, and various desserts like the coffee ice cream and coconut cake. However, some diners have found the food, including burgers and steaks, to be mediocre or not worth the effort of securing a reservation.
"While opinions vary, some diners highly recommend the corned beef sandwich and the coffee ice cream. The popovers and certain appetizers like pigs in a blanket have also received positive mentions."
Customer sentiment is divided, with many praising the restaurant's ambiance and exclusive feel, while others find the food underwhelming and the reservation process overly difficult.
Important Note
Reservations are extremely difficult to obtain, often requiring persistent effort or connections. Some diners find the food to be underwhelming given the difficulty in booking and the restaurant's upscale reputation.
"This user suggests calling Polo Bar right at 4 PM the day before for reservations, as that's when cancellations are often confirmed."
Neutral"Polo Bar was recommended by a user who also suggested other restaurants like Bungalow and Monkey Bar."
Positive"A former employee of the store attached to The Polo Bar mentioned that the food was excessively salty and that drug dealing was occurring in the kitchen."
Negative"The commenter clarified that Martha Stewart mentioned 'Polo Lounge' which is likely The Polo Bar, noting she got the name slightly wrong."
Neutral"This commenter confirmed that the restaurant mentioned is The Polo Bar."
Neutral"This commenter expressed a negative experience at The Polo Bar, citing a very bad steak and the worst espresso martini they've ever had. They feel the restaurant is more for celebrity sightings than for food quality."
Negative"A commenter identified The Polo Bar as the restaurant mentioned in the post."
Neutral"This commenter provided a link to The Polo Bar's website, confirming it as the restaurant being discussed."
Neutral"This user mentioned that The Polo Bar encourages jackets but does not require them."
Neutral"This user recommended the Polo Bar."
Positive"This user recommended Polo Bar and Bathtub Gin."
Positive"This user recommended Polo Bar."
Positive"This user recommended Polo Bar for its cozy vibe."
Positive"This user clarifies that while waiting in line for a table at Polo Bar might not be standard, walking in at the bar could be a possibility."
Neutral"The original poster expressed surprise at the possibility of waiting in line for a spot at Polo Bar."
Neutral"Polo Bar is mentioned as a suggestion, with a note that while reservations might not be possible, walking in at the bar could be an option."
Neutral"The commenter strongly recommends Polo Bar if the user's concierge can secure a reservation there."
Positive"Polo Bar is recommended as an American dining option in Midtown."
Positive"Found Polo Bar's food and drinks to be good but detests the reservation process, arrogant service, and 'waspy' vibe."
Negative
