Exclusive NYC hotspot w/ tough-to-get res.; classic American fare & clubby vibes. A scene for those in the know.
A classic American restaurant with a sophisticated, club-like ambiance. Reservations are notoriously difficult to secure, often requiring advance planning or connections. While the atmosphere and service are frequently praised, opinions on the food are more divided, with some finding it to be excellent and others describing it as average or overhyped.
The cuisine is classic American, with dishes like burgers, corned beef sandwiches, and various appetizers. While some find the food excellent, particularly certain desserts and appetizers, others describe it as average or 'golf course' tier. Reservations are consistently cited as a major hurdle.
"While opinions are mixed, some stand-out dishes mentioned include the corned beef sandwich, the cauliflower appetizer, and the coffee ice cream. The chocolate cake and hot fudge sundae have also received positive mentions, as have various appetizers like pigs in a blanket and caviar with potatoes."
Overall customer sentiment leans positive, with many highlighting the excellent ambiance and service. However, there's a notable divide regarding the food, with some finding it exceptional and others deeming it overrated or mediocre.
Important Note
Reservations are extremely difficult to obtain, often requiring persistent calling, connections, or very flexible timing. Some diners find the food to be underwhelming given the hype and price, while the ambiance and exclusivity are primary draws for others. There are also reports of aggressive behavior from other patrons and issues with staff conduct.
"This user mentioned that The Polo Bar encourages jackets but does not require them."
Neutral"This user recommended the Polo Bar."
Positive"This user recommended Polo Bar and Bathtub Gin."
Positive"This user recommended Polo Bar."
Positive"This user recommended Polo Bar for its cozy vibe."
Positive"This user clarifies that while waiting in line for a table at Polo Bar might not be standard, walking in at the bar could be a possibility."
Neutral"The original poster expressed surprise at the possibility of waiting in line for a spot at Polo Bar."
Neutral"Polo Bar is mentioned as a suggestion, with a note that while reservations might not be possible, walking in at the bar could be an option."
Neutral"The commenter strongly recommends Polo Bar if the user's concierge can secure a reservation there."
Positive"Polo Bar is recommended as an American dining option in Midtown."
Positive"Found Polo Bar's food and drinks to be good but detests the reservation process, arrogant service, and 'waspy' vibe."
Negative"Suggests calling Polo Bar closer to the date as people often cancel reservations."
Neutral"Criticizes Polo Bar's ambiance, calling it 'sad and mid' and comparing it to a 'nursing home cafeteria' due to the older clientele."
Negative"Offers to help the original poster secure a table at Polo Bar, mentioning there are ways to get tables beyond the initial release."
Neutral"Describes Polo Bar's food as 'awful' and 'country club tier', and dislikes the reservation process, service, and vibe."
Negative"Unable to get a reservation at Polo Bar after trying unsuccessfully."
Negative"States they were never a fan of Polo Bar's food."
Negative"The Polo Bar is listed as a restaurant suggestion for the anniversary occasion."
Neutral"Polo Bar is listed as a restaurant that the commenter has really enjoyed for ball-out meals, noting it's hard to get into and pricey but has good food and a great vibe for celebrating."
Positive
