Classic Italian near Lincoln Center w/ amazing pizza & antipasto bar. A true pre-show gem!
This Italian eatery is a classic choice near Lincoln Center, known for its vibrant atmosphere and timeless appeal. It's a go-to spot for pre-show dining and has been a significant part of New York's culinary scene for years. The restaurant boasts a large antipasto bar and a full bar, making it a versatile option for various occasions.
This Italian restaurant offers a range of classic dishes, with specific highlights including their thin-crust pizza and a beloved chocolate mousse (though no longer served tableside). Some diners also rave about the pancakes, calling them the 'best in the city.' However, there are dissenting opinions, with some finding the food quality to be subpar compared to neighboring establishments.
"Highly recommended dishes include the thin-crust pizza, the antipasto bar, and the chocolate mousse. The pancakes are also specifically called out as a must-try."
Customers have mixed feelings, with some praising specific dishes like pizza and mousse, while others find it to be a last resort and not as good as other nearby options.
Important Note
Some reviewers feel the quality has declined and consider it a last resort compared to other nearby dining options.
"This user expressed surprise that Cafe Fiorello had not been mentioned yet in the discussion about lasagna."
Neutral"The original poster confirmed that Cafe Fiorello was not the restaurant they were looking for."
Negative"The user asked if the restaurant in question was Cafe Fiorello."
Neutral"Cafe Fiorello is highly recommended by this user as a favorite place for old-school Italian dining."
Positive"This commenter states that Cafe Fiorello's pancakes are the 'best in the city'."
Positive"Cafe Fiorello is mentioned as a possible breakfast spot near Lincoln Center."
Positive"Cafe Fiorello is recommended, with a specific mention to try the pancakes."
Positive"Cafe Fiorello is suggested as a dining option."
Neutral"This commenter expressed disappointment after reading about Cafe Fiorello's mousse, as it raised their hopes but was no longer served tableside."
Negative"Cafe Fiorello previously served an amazing mousse with homemade whipped cream, though it is no longer served tableside. The commenter later clarified that while not served tableside, the mousse is still excellent and generously portioned with whipped cream."
Positive"A user agreed that Cafe Fiorello is a great option for solo dining."
Positive"Fiorellos near Lincoln Center was recommended as a dining option, with a general suggestion to avoid the Times Square area."
Positive"Sitting at the antipasti bar at Cafe Fiorello before a show at Lincoln Center is recommended as a good solo dining option."
Positive"This commenter recommends Cafe Fiorello, highlighting its superior chicken parm and overall quality compared to Carmine's. They also mention the restaurant has a large antipasto bar and can handle high-volume food service, suggesting it would be suitable for the user's catering needs."
Positive"Fiorello's, located across the street from Lincoln Center, is recommended and used by the commenter even when not attending an event there."
Positive"Cafe Fiorello is described as a solid spot."
Positive"Cafe Fiorello is mentioned as a dining option."
Neutral"Cafe Fiorello is suggested as a dining option."
Positive"The user is asking for opinions on Fiorello, having heard good things about it."
Neutral"This user strongly advises against Cafe Fiorello, stating it has significantly declined in quality and should only be considered as a last resort."
Negative
