Next.js logo

CAFE FIORELLO

Last Updated: 3 months ago

Phone: (212) 595-5330

Address: 1900 BROADWAY 10023

TLDR

Italian near Lincoln Center, praised for thin-crust pizza & chocolate mousse, but criticized by some for declining quality.

Sentiment Overview(Based on 11 Reddit comments)

36% Positive18% Neutral45% Negative

Tags

italian 5pizza 3View All

Neighborhoods

Upper West Side

Details

Cafe Fiorello, an Italian eatery located near Lincoln Center, offers a dining experience that garners mixed reactions from patrons. While some customers rave about specific dishes like their thin-crust pizza, lentils, corn, and a decadent chocolate mousse, others feel the quality has diminished significantly over time. The restaurant is conveniently situated for pre-show meals, with some recommending it for this purpose. However, there are strong opinions suggesting it's a last resort compared to other establishments in the area. Despite the divided opinions on food quality, the thin-crust pizza and full bar remain highlights for some, even evoking nostalgic feelings.

Food Overview

Cafe Fiorello is an Italian restaurant that receives mixed reviews for its food. It's noted for its thin-crust pizza, which some find amazing, and other dishes like lentils, corn, and a chocolate mousse that one reviewer called 'not to be missed.' However, a significant portion of feedback suggests a decline in quality, with multiple comments advising against it as a dining option, especially when compared to other nearby restaurants. Free chocolates are also mentioned as a perk.

Highlights / Recommended

"Customers highly recommend the thin-crust pizza, lentils, corn, and the chocolate mousse. Free chocolates are also a noted perk."

Customer Sentiment

Customer opinions on Cafe Fiorello are divided. While some patrons praise its thin-crust pizza, lentils, corn, and chocolate mousse, and consider it a good option for pre-show dining, others strongly advise against it, citing a significant decline in quality and suggesting it as a last resort compared to nearby establishments. One user's 'very Italian landlord' recommended it.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

This thread discusses late-night dining options near Lincoln Center. Cafe Fiorello is mentioned as a place that is 'not recommended' and considered a 'last resort' compared to other nearby restaurants like Bar Boulud and Cafe Luxembourg.
One user highly recommends Cafe Fiorello for specific dishes, including amazing pizza, lentils, corn, and a chocolate mousse that is 'not to be missed.' They also mention the restaurant offers free chocolate.
A user expresses their love for Cafe Fiorello's thin-crust pizza and its full bar, mentioning a nostalgic connection to the restaurant.
One commenter strongly advises against Cafe Fiorello, stating that it has 'sucked for a long time' and is not comparable to other options. This sentiment is echoed by another user who suggests it has declined significantly and should only be a last resort.

Recent Mentions

From post: Dinner Before Date Night At The Met

"This user strongly advises against Cafe Fiorello, stating it has significantly declined in quality and should only be considered as a last resort."

Negative
May 13, 2025View Comment →

From post: Dinner Before Date Night At The Met

"Cafe Fiorello was suggested with a link to its website."

Neutral
May 13, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Unpretentious Classic Italians Pasta Or Pizza

"Mentions Cafe Fiorello as a recommendation from their 'very Italian landlord'."

Positive
May 13, 2025View Comment →

From post: Upper West Side For The Night Where Should I Go

"The author recommends Cafe Fiorello for a pre-show meal."

Positive
May 6, 2025View Comment →

From post: What Are Some Of The Best Sit Down Pizza Places

"User loves Cafe Fiorello's thin crust pizza and full bar, partly for nostalgic reasons."

Positive
Apr 16, 2025View Comment →

From post: Late Night Lincoln Center Area

"Commenter strongly disagrees with a positive review, stating the place "sucks" and isn't comparable to the other two options."

Negative
Apr 10, 2025View Comment →

From post: Late Night Lincoln Center Area

"Positively reviewed for its amazing pizza, lentils, corn, and chocolate mousse; also mentions free chocolate."

Positive
Apr 10, 2025View Comment →

From post: Late Night Lincoln Center Area

"Food considered not as good as Bar Boulud."

Negative
Apr 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: Late Night Lincoln Center Area

"Not recommended, considered a last resort compared to Bar Boulud and Cafe Luxembourg for a post-show meal."

Negative
Apr 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: Late Night Lincoln Center Area

"Explicitly advised against choosing this option compared to the other two mentioned."

Negative
Apr 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: Dinner For 1015 Ppl Walking Distance To Lincoln

"Cafe Fiorello is right nearby"

Neutral
Mar 13, 2025View Comment →