Epic crust, creative pies & unexpected gems like potato chip salad. This pizza spot is a must-try for serious foodies.
This pizza joint is a culinary gem, consistently lauded for its exceptional crust that boasts an airy and crisp texture. Reviewers rave about the creative whole pies, with specific mentions of the 'Ploughman' and 'Old Town' pizzas. While the classic pizzas are superb, the inventive options offer a unique twist, though some find them to be hit-or-miss. Beyond pizza, the potato chip salad and meatball sliders are also highly recommended.
Known for its pizzas with a standout crust, Stretch Pizza offers both classic and inventive whole pies, with the 'Ploughman' and 'Old Town' varieties receiving high praise. While most customers rave about the pizzas, some suggest that the more experimental toppings can be hit-or-miss. Other popular dishes include the potato chip salad and meatball sliders.
"The standout recommended dishes include the incredible crust on all their pizzas, specifically the 'Ploughman,' 'Old Town,' and 'al pastor' pizzas. The potato chip salad and meatball sliders are also frequently mentioned as must-tries."
Overwhelmingly positive, with customers frequently praising the exceptional crust and unique pizza creations. Some minor drawbacks include a perceived price point for certain items and occasional inconsistency with experimental toppings.
Important Note
While most reviews are positive, a few users felt the pizza was just 'okay' or not worth the price, suggesting it might be a matter of personal preference or an off night.
"The user agreed with the recommendation for Stretch Pizza, stating it is underrated. This comment is in response to a recommendation for Stretch Pizza."
Positive"The user recommended Stretch Pizza for pizza delivery. The original post was looking for pizza recommendations near Koreatown for a karaoke party."
Positive"Lists Stretch Pizza as a pizza place to consider in Williamsburg before Joe's."
Positive"The user recommended Stretch Pizza as a good dining option in the area."
Positive"Stretch Pizza is listed as a dining option."
Neutral"Expresses a strong positive sentiment towards Stretch, calling it 'the truth'."
Positive"The author lists Stretch Pizza for its vanilla soft serve with cinnamon oat crumble and caramel sauce."
Neutral"Had a positive experience during a recent visit, highlighting the al pastor pizza with pineapple ricotta as amazing. However, noted the price point as a bit high."
Positive"Stated that slices cost around $5-$6 depending on toppings, considering them well worth the price."
Positive"Confirmed that Stretch recently started selling slices on weekdays after 11:30 AM, providing a photo as evidence."
Positive"Expressed a negative opinion about the appearance of a slice."
Negative"Asked about the price of slices as they found ordering a whole pizza to be too much."
Neutral"The pizza at Stretch is considered extremely underrated by the commenter."
Positive"Inquired if Stretch on Park Avenue sells pizza by the slice."
Neutral"Commenter noted that some kitchen staff previously worked at Pizza Motto and considers Stretch a solid establishment."
Positive"Visited for lunch and was very impressed with the pepperoni slice, exceeding expectations. The crust was noted as crisp and airy, with the added cheese enhancing the experience."
Positive"The commenter lists Stretch Pizza as a personal favorite that is within the user's budget excluding drinks."
Positive"Stretch Pizza is listed as a place to get soft serve."
Neutral"Stretch Pizza is highly praised for its potato, ham, and horseradish pizza, described as "out of this world," though the commenter notes it might have many ingredients."
Positive"The commenter suggests getting a few slices of pizza at the bar at Stretch Pizza."
Positive
