Underrated pizza gem w/ incredible crust. Creative whole pies, must-try meatball sliders & unique potato chip salad.
This pizza joint is a highly regarded spot, frequently lauded for its exceptional crust, which many describe as airy and crisp. Customers rave about the creative whole pies, with specific mentions of the 'Nellie' pizza and the 'Ploughman' pizza, as well as their surprisingly delicious meatball sliders and potato chip salad. While some find the regular slices to be a bit pricey, the overall consensus leans towards a unique and high-quality pizza experience that is considered underrated by many.
The pizza is the star, with a focus on creative whole pies and excellent crust. Specific recommendations include the 'Nellie' and 'Ploughman' pizzas. Sides like meatball sliders and the potato chip salad are also frequently highlighted. While some find slices a bit pricey, the overall quality is highly regarded.
"Highly recommended dishes include the 'Nellie' pizza (with shallots), 'The Ploughman' pizza, meatball sliders, and the potato chip salad. The crust itself is also a major draw."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the pizza, particularly its crust and creative whole pie options. Many consider it a standout, though some note the price point for slices can be a bit high.
Important Note
Some users find the regular slices to be a bit pricey for the portion size, and one user noted that inventive toppings might not appeal to everyone.
"This user recommended Stretch Pizza, located next to Milu, as an excellent option for pizza."
Positive"The user mentions that Stretch Pizza has two takeout locations for slices outside of a restaurant setting."
Neutral"Stretch Pizza is recommended."
Neutral"Stretch Pizza is recommended as funky in a good way, serving great slices."
Positive"This commenter recommends not overlooking the meatballs at Stretch Pizza."
Positive"After visiting Stretch Pizza based on a recommendation, the commenter found the dough on both square and regular pies to be stellar."
Positive"This commenter has not tried the counter slices but finds the 'neo neo pies' at Stretch Pizza excellent for lunch dates or family outings."
Positive"The commenter visits Stretch Pizza monthly for its lack of lines and praises the taste and consistency of their plain slices, noting they are bready and salty."
Positive"Stretch Pizza is ranked among the top 10 pizza places by this commenter."
Positive"The commenter agrees with a previous sentiment regarding the comparison of Stretch Pizza to L'Industrie."
Neutral"Responding to a query about Stretch Pizza's quality, this commenter states it is excellent, comparing it favorably to L'Industrie."
Positive"This commenter is asking for recommendations on unique dishes at Stretch Pizza and clarification on which items are square pies versus round pies."
Neutral"The commenter finds Stretch Pizza outstanding, specifically craving their 'Nellie pizza' with shallots despite usually preferring plain slices."
Positive"This commenter has a neutral to slightly negative opinion, stating that Stretch Pizza is good if you like salty pizza."
Negative"A short, emphatic comment urging others to stop discussing Stretch Pizza, implying a desire to keep it a hidden gem."
Neutral"This commenter is questioning if Stretch Pizza is genuinely good or only considered 'good' in a similar vein to L'Industrie."
Neutral"The commenter finds Stretch Pizza amazing and is glad it doesn't have long lines, but worries about its survival due to lack of hype."
Positive"Stretch Pizza is highly praised as one of the best pizza places, with excellent NY style whole pies, outstanding square pies, and great appetizers, salads, and soft serve."
Positive"This commenter believes Stretch Pizza is in the upper tier of pizza places in NYC and deserves more recognition for its creative offerings and normal slices, which they consider top-tier."
Positive"The commenter describes Stretch Pizza as a good pie, noting its interesting ingredient combinations. They highlight the uniquely light square pie crust and suggest the lunch slices are particularly competitive and top-tier."
Positive
