Must-try pizza w/ an incredible crust; inventive pies & classic slices that r surprisingly good. Don't sleep on the sliders or potato chip salad!
This pizza joint is a true gem, consistently praised for its exceptional crust that's both airy and crisp. Whether you're in the mood for a classic slice or an inventive whole pie, this spot delivers a satisfying experience. Don't miss out on their creative flavor combinations and consider trying their highly-rated meatball sliders or unique potato chip salad for a complete meal.
The pizza is the star here, with many customers raving about the incredibly airy and crisp crust. While classic slices and pies are well-loved, the restaurant also offers creative and unique flavor combinations that many find delicious. Dishes like the meatball sliders and potato chip salad also receive high marks. One unique item mentioned is a Caesar salad with a tahini dressing.
"The pizza itself is highly recommended, especially for its crust. Specific mentions include the 'Nellie' pizza with shallots, the 'ploughman' pizza, and the al pastor pizza with pineapple ricotta. The potato chip salad and meatball sliders are also frequently recommended."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the pizza, particularly its exceptional crust, and highly recommend various creative pies. There are very few negative comments, with most criticisms focusing on the price or an occasional off-night.
Important Note
Some customers find the prices to be a bit high, and a few have noted that inventive toppings might not appeal to everyone, especially when trying to showcase classic New York pizza to visitors.
"Stretch Pizza was suggested as a place with good mozzarella sticks."
Positive"This commenter recommended Stretch Pizza for its lovely thick, pillow-like crust and thin bottoms."
Positive"The commenter suggested Stretch Pizza for a thick crust NYC slice, describing the dough as light and airy."
Positive"This commenter recommended Stretch Pizza for its lovely thick, pillow-like crust and thin bottoms, suitable for thick square slices."
Positive"This commenter described the stretch square pizza as light and airy with a lovely thick, pillow-like crust."
Positive"The user mentioned Stretch Pizza has a cacio e pepe cruller that is really good, describing it as light and satisfying."
Positive"Stretch Pizza in the Nomad/Flatiron area is listed as a restaurant where walk-ins are often successful."
Positive"A short, enthusiastic confirmation that Stretch is 'SO GOOD'."
Positive"Stretch pizza is highly praised for its deliciousness, with a focus on its crust. The commenter also notes that their Detroit-style pizza is satisfying and mentions the possibility of the owner, Wylie Dufresne, preparing specials."
Positive"Stretch is recommended, with a link provided to its location."
Positive"This user praised Stretch Pizza, highlighting it as a great overall experience and expressing amazement at how easy it is to get in despite the chef's celebrity status and the quality of the pies."
Positive"This commenter suggested Stretch Pizza as a worthwhile walk for those seeking traditional New York style pizza, contrasting it with Detroit style."
Positive"The commenter expressed enthusiasm for data and data-driven insights, possibly in relation to the restaurant list."
Neutral"Stretch Pizza is suggested as a pizza option."
Positive"The commenter recommended Stretch Pizza and noted it is still very underrated."
Positive"This user recommended Stretch Pizza, located next to Milu, as an excellent option for pizza."
Positive"The user mentions that Stretch Pizza has two takeout locations for slices outside of a restaurant setting."
Neutral"Stretch Pizza is recommended."
Neutral"Stretch Pizza is recommended as funky in a good way, serving great slices."
Positive"This commenter recommends not overlooking the meatballs at Stretch Pizza."
Positive
