Creative pies, amazing crust, and unique toppings. A truly underrated pizza experience.
This pizza joint offers a unique take on classic pies with creative toppings and an exceptionally well-crafted crust. Reviewers rave about the airy, crisp texture of their dough and the inventive flavor combinations, positioning it as a standout in the city's pizza scene. Whether you opt for a traditional slice or one of their more adventurous whole pies, expect a satisfying and memorable meal.
This establishment is celebrated for its pizza, with a strong emphasis on its high-quality dough, which is frequently described as having an airy and crisp texture. While traditional slices and classic pizzas are well-loved, many users also recommend exploring their more inventive whole pies with unique flavor combinations. The meatball sliders and a potato chip salad have also received positive mentions.
"Highly recommended are the pizzas with unique toppings, such as the 'Nellie' pizza with shallots and the 'Ploughman' pizza. The pepperoni slice and cheese slice also receive frequent praise, as do the meatball sliders and potato chip salad."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the pizza, particularly its exceptional crust and creative topping combinations. It's frequently described as underrated and a top-tier pizza destination.
Important Note
Some users found the pizzas to be a bit dry, suggesting they could benefit from more sauce or cheese. One comment noted that while appetizers like sliders and mozzarella sticks were good, they were considered a bit pricey for the value.
"The user mentioned Stretch Pizza has a cacio e pepe cruller that is really good, describing it as light and satisfying."
Positive"Stretch Pizza in the Nomad/Flatiron area is listed as a restaurant where walk-ins are often successful."
Positive"A short, enthusiastic confirmation that Stretch is 'SO GOOD'."
Positive"Stretch pizza is highly praised for its deliciousness, with a focus on its crust. The commenter also notes that their Detroit-style pizza is satisfying and mentions the possibility of the owner, Wylie Dufresne, preparing specials."
Positive"Stretch is recommended, with a link provided to its location."
Positive"This user praised Stretch Pizza, highlighting it as a great overall experience and expressing amazement at how easy it is to get in despite the chef's celebrity status and the quality of the pies."
Positive"This commenter suggested Stretch Pizza as a worthwhile walk for those seeking traditional New York style pizza, contrasting it with Detroit style."
Positive"The commenter expressed enthusiasm for data and data-driven insights, possibly in relation to the restaurant list."
Neutral"Stretch Pizza is suggested as a pizza option."
Positive"The commenter recommended Stretch Pizza and noted it is still very underrated."
Positive"This user recommended Stretch Pizza, located next to Milu, as an excellent option for pizza."
Positive"The user mentions that Stretch Pizza has two takeout locations for slices outside of a restaurant setting."
Neutral"Stretch Pizza is recommended."
Neutral"Stretch Pizza is recommended as funky in a good way, serving great slices."
Positive"This commenter recommends not overlooking the meatballs at Stretch Pizza."
Positive"After visiting Stretch Pizza based on a recommendation, the commenter found the dough on both square and regular pies to be stellar."
Positive"This commenter has not tried the counter slices but finds the 'neo neo pies' at Stretch Pizza excellent for lunch dates or family outings."
Positive"The commenter visits Stretch Pizza monthly for its lack of lines and praises the taste and consistency of their plain slices, noting they are bready and salty."
Positive"Stretch Pizza is ranked among the top 10 pizza places by this commenter."
Positive"The commenter agrees with a previous sentiment regarding the comparison of Stretch Pizza to L'Industrie."
Neutral
