TLDR
Creative, top-tier pizzas featuring a signature light and airy crust, served alongside standout appetizers like cacio e pepe crullers.
Details
Renowned for its creative menu and stellar dough, this spot is frequently cited as a top-tier destination for both traditional New York-style and light, airy square pizzas [20, 22]. Diners consistently praise the high quality of the pies, often describing the experience as an "underrated gem" that manages to maintain accessibility despite its culinary acclaim [20, 21]. Beyond the pizza, the menu features standout appetizers like mozzarella sticks and a unique cacio e pepe cruller that draws significant praise [38, 44].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on high-quality Italian-American fare, with specific accolades for the pepperoni slice, al pastor pizza, and the "Nellie" pizza topped with shallots [4, 9, 29]. Customers frequently highlight the "thick, pillow-like" crust of the square pies and the overall excellence of the dough across all offerings [24, 25, 41]. In addition to pizza, the mozzarella sticks and the light, satisfying cacio e pepe cruller are highly recommended additions to the meal [38, 44].
The pepperoni slice, the al pastor pizza with pineapple ricotta, and the "Nellie" shallot pizza are frequently lauded [4, 9, 29]. For non-pizza items, the cacio e pepe cruller and mozzarella sticks are widely recommended [38, 44].
Patrons overwhelmingly hold a positive view of the restaurant, frequently highlighting its consistent quality and status as an underrated local favorite [20, 31]. While generally lauded, a small minority have noted that the flavor profiles can be quite salty or unconventional for some tastes [25, 33].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01meatball sliders3 mentions
- 02cheese slice2 mentions
- 03pepperoni slice2 mentions
- 04al pastor pizza2 mentions
- 05ramp pizza2 mentions
- 06classic pizza2 mentions
Caveats
Some diners have noted that the price point can be relatively high [9] and the flavor combinations might be too bold or salty for those expecting a more traditional, standard NY slice [25, 33].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About STRETCH PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Pizza Event Space Help With Stretch Pizza Nyc
"This comment states that the Domino Park location of Stretch Pizza will remain open."
NeutralFrom post: Pizza Event Space Help With Stretch Pizza Nyc
"A bot welcomed the user to the subreddit and explained that their post was filtered for review. This is a standard automated response and does not contain opinions on restaurants."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For Best Mozzarella Sticks
"Stretch Pizza was suggested as a place with good mozzarella sticks."
PositiveFrom post: Whats Your Favorite Thick Crust Pizza Slice In Nyc
"This commenter recommended Stretch Pizza for its lovely thick, pillow-like crust and thin bottoms."
PositiveFrom post: Whats Your Favorite Thick Crust Pizza Slice In Nyc
"The commenter suggested Stretch Pizza for a thick crust NYC slice, describing the dough as light and airy."
Positive