Underrated pizza spot w/ best crust in NYC. Creative pies & classic slices shine; don't miss the unique soft serve.
This pizza joint is a hidden gem that offers a delightful pizza experience. Reviewers consistently rave about the incredible crust, often described as airy, crisp, and the best they've ever had. While some find the inventive toppings hit-or-miss, the classic pizzas are a reliable favorite, and even the more unique creations like the 'Nellie' pizza with shallots and the 'Old Town' mushroom-pumpernickel pie receive high praise. Don't miss out on their unique soft serve with creative toppings either!
This establishment is lauded for its pizza, with particular emphasis on its outstanding crust, which is frequently described as the best in NYC. Customers appreciate both classic and creative pizza options, with standouts including the 'Nellie' pizza and the 'Old Town' pie. The soft serve with unique toppings is also a hit. While most feedback is positive, some find the more experimental flavor combinations to be inconsistent.
"The crust is universally praised. Standout dishes include the 'Nellie' pizza, 'The Ploughman', 'Old Town' (Mushroom/Pumpernickel), and the 'al pastor pizza' with pineapple ricotta. Meatball sliders, potato chip salad, and the vanilla soft serve with unique toppings are also recommended."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the pizza, particularly its exceptional crust. While some innovative toppings receive mixed reviews, the overall sentiment is highly positive, with many considering it a favorite.
Important Note
Some users found the more inventive or 'gimmicky' pizza toppings to be a hit-or-miss, and one user found the pizza to be too salty. The price point for whole pies is noted as being higher than traditional NYC slices.
"A short, enthusiastic confirmation that Stretch is 'SO GOOD'."
Positive"Stretch pizza is highly praised for its deliciousness, with a focus on its crust. The commenter also notes that their Detroit-style pizza is satisfying and mentions the possibility of the owner, Wylie Dufresne, preparing specials."
Positive"Stretch is recommended, with a link provided to its location."
Positive"This user praised Stretch Pizza, highlighting it as a great overall experience and expressing amazement at how easy it is to get in despite the chef's celebrity status and the quality of the pies."
Positive"This commenter suggested Stretch Pizza as a worthwhile walk for those seeking traditional New York style pizza, contrasting it with Detroit style."
Positive"The commenter expressed enthusiasm for data and data-driven insights, possibly in relation to the restaurant list."
Neutral"Stretch Pizza is suggested as a pizza option."
Positive"The commenter recommended Stretch Pizza and noted it is still very underrated."
Positive"This user recommended Stretch Pizza, located next to Milu, as an excellent option for pizza."
Positive"The user mentions that Stretch Pizza has two takeout locations for slices outside of a restaurant setting."
Neutral"Stretch Pizza is recommended."
Neutral"Stretch Pizza is recommended as funky in a good way, serving great slices."
Positive"This commenter recommends not overlooking the meatballs at Stretch Pizza."
Positive"After visiting Stretch Pizza based on a recommendation, the commenter found the dough on both square and regular pies to be stellar."
Positive"This commenter has not tried the counter slices but finds the 'neo neo pies' at Stretch Pizza excellent for lunch dates or family outings."
Positive"The commenter visits Stretch Pizza monthly for its lack of lines and praises the taste and consistency of their plain slices, noting they are bready and salty."
Positive"Stretch Pizza is ranked among the top 10 pizza places by this commenter."
Positive"The commenter agrees with a previous sentiment regarding the comparison of Stretch Pizza to L'Industrie."
Neutral"Responding to a query about Stretch Pizza's quality, this commenter states it is excellent, comparing it favorably to L'Industrie."
Positive"This commenter is asking for recommendations on unique dishes at Stretch Pizza and clarification on which items are square pies versus round pies."
Neutral
