Uniquely creative pizzas with an unparalleled crust, praised as a must-try hidden gem.
Discover a pizza haven where the crust is consistently hailed as the best in NYC, offering a perfect balance of crispness and chew. Dive into inventive pies with unique topping combinations that push culinary boundaries, like the acclaimed al pastor with pineapple ricotta or the 'Ploughman' with its distinct blend of flavors. Even the more traditional slices receive high marks for their quality and airy texture, making it a go-to spot for pizza aficionados seeking something special.
This pizza establishment is lauded for its creative and well-executed pizzas, with many customers specifically praising the exceptional quality of the crust. Unique topping combinations are frequently mentioned as a highlight, contributing to a memorable dining experience. While most feedback is positive, a few comments suggest some of the more experimental pizzas might be hit-or-miss, and one user found the slices to be just okay for the price. The meatball sliders and potato chip salad are also mentioned as standout items.
"The 'Ploughman' pizza, featuring ham, horseradish, red onion, and smoked cheddar, is highly recommended. The potato chip salad and meatball sliders are also frequently praised as must-try items."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the pizza, frequently highlighting its exceptional crust and unique topping combinations. While some find the price point a bit high, the overall consensus is that the quality and creativity justify the cost.
Important Note
Some customers find the price point for the pizzas to be on the higher side, and a few find the more experimental topping combinations to be hit-or-miss.
"Expresses a strong positive sentiment towards Stretch, calling it 'the truth'."
Positive"The author lists Stretch Pizza for its vanilla soft serve with cinnamon oat crumble and caramel sauce."
Neutral"Had a positive experience during a recent visit, highlighting the al pastor pizza with pineapple ricotta as amazing. However, noted the price point as a bit high."
Positive"Stated that slices cost around $5-$6 depending on toppings, considering them well worth the price."
Positive"Confirmed that Stretch recently started selling slices on weekdays after 11:30 AM, providing a photo as evidence."
Positive"Expressed a negative opinion about the appearance of a slice."
Negative"Asked about the price of slices as they found ordering a whole pizza to be too much."
Neutral"The pizza at Stretch is considered extremely underrated by the commenter."
Positive"Inquired if Stretch on Park Avenue sells pizza by the slice."
Neutral"Commenter noted that some kitchen staff previously worked at Pizza Motto and considers Stretch a solid establishment."
Positive"Visited for lunch and was very impressed with the pepperoni slice, exceeding expectations. The crust was noted as crisp and airy, with the added cheese enhancing the experience."
Positive"The commenter lists Stretch Pizza as a personal favorite that is within the user's budget excluding drinks."
Positive"Stretch Pizza is listed as a place to get soft serve."
Neutral"Stretch Pizza is highly praised for its potato, ham, and horseradish pizza, described as "out of this world," though the commenter notes it might have many ingredients."
Positive"The commenter suggests getting a few slices of pizza at the bar at Stretch Pizza."
Positive"Stretch Pizza is surprisingly recommended for its meatballs, despite being primarily a pizza place."
Positive"The meatball sliders at Stretch Pizza are noted as a personal favorite by a commenter."
Positive"The user makes a playful remark, suggesting to keep Stretch Pizza a secret, implying it's a hidden gem."
Positive"Stretch Pizza is the commenter's favorite spot because it lacks hype, allowing for a quality slice or pie without fuss."
Positive"A user describes the Caesar salad at Stretch as delicious, highlighting the use of tahini in the dressing."
Positive
