A top NYC pizza contender with perfect well-done slices & incredible marinara, hailed as a local gem.
In the bustling pizza landscape of NYC, Diamond Slice emerges as a strong contender, consistently earning high praise from patrons. Many consider it a personal favorite and a top-tier spot, with particular acclaim for its well-executed slices. The marinara slice, in particular, has been described as 'incredible,' and the classic well-done slice is often called 'perfect.' The pizzeria is also lauded for its fair prices and a pleasant, relaxed, and unpretentious atmosphere, making it a local gem. While the vast majority of feedback is positive, a few diners have noted potential drawbacks, such as a dry pizza, insufficient cheese, or a crust that's too thin. One reviewer even likened the taste to plain bread. Despite these minor criticisms, Diamond Slice remains a highly recommended destination for pizza lovers seeking quality and value.
Diamond Slice is celebrated for its exceptional pizza, with many customers regarding it as a top-tier establishment. The 'well-done slice' is frequently cited as 'perfect,' and the 'marinara slice' has been described as 'incredible.' While the overall sentiment is highly positive, a few customers have noted that the pizza can be dry, lacking sufficient cheese, or having a crust that is too thin. Some expressed a desire for more salt in the grated cheese, while others found the overall flavor profile to be lacking, comparing it to plain bread. The 'caesar slice' is a notable recommendation, though it's best enjoyed fresh.
"The 'well-done slice' is frequently cited as 'perfect,' and the 'marinara slice' is described as 'incredible.' The 'caesar slice' is also a notable recommendation, though it's best enjoyed fresh."
Customers overwhelmingly praise Diamond Slice, frequently mentioning it as a top contender in the NYC pizza scene and even a personal favorite. Many highlight the quality of the pizza, with specific mentions of the 'well-done slice' being 'perfect'. Some find it underrated, better, cheaper, nicer, and quicker than other popular spots. However, a minority found the pizza too dry, lacking cheese, or too thin, with one commenter describing it as tasting just like bread. There are also preferences for specific elements like the sauce or a desire for more salt in the grated cheese. The 'caesar slice' is particularly praised but noted to be best fresh. The atmosphere is described as nice, relaxed, and unpretentious, with fair prices.
Important Note
Some customers found the pizza dry, lacking cheese, or too thin, with one reviewer describing it as tasting like plain bread. The 'caesar slice' is best enjoyed fresh.
"The commenter concurs with the preference for Diamond Slice over Chrissy's, reinforcing its positive standing."
Positive"Diamond Slice is explicitly recommended as an alternative option, suggesting trying it over Paulie Gee's."
Positive"The commenter prefers Diamond Slice over Chrissy's, indicating a positive comparative preference."
Positive"Diamond Slice is explicitly recommended as a place to 'check out' while in Greenpoint."
Positive"Diamond Slice is listed as one of several recommended pizza spots."
Positive"This user expresses strong liking for Diamond Slice in Greenpoint."
Positive"This user recommends Diamond Slice."
Positive"Diamond Slice is included in a list of recommended pizzerias."
Positive"The author states they like Diamond Slice Pizza, noting that pizza preference is subjective."
Positive"Recommends Diamond Slice as a good option for tomato slices, mentioned as part of a list of preferred pizzerias."
Positive"States that Diamond Slice is one of their favorite pizza places, listing it alongside Fini as a top choice."
Positive"Describes the marinara slice at Diamond Slice in Greenpoint as incredible, a strong positive endorsement."
Positive"The user found Diamond Slice quite flavorless, tasting just like bread."
Negative"The commenter thinks the slice pictured from Diamond Slice is burnt."
Negative"Recommended as a top pick for a European visitor seeking experiences distinctly NYC or less common in Europe."
Positive"Recommended implicitly as a pizza place that offers a distinct American/NYer experience."
Positive"A plain slice at Diamond Slice costs $3.75."
Neutral"The user feels the crust at Diamond Slice is too thin and it doesn't have enough cheese."
Negative"The user hasn't seen a slice like the one at Diamond Slice in a while."
Positive"The commenter thinks the sauce at Diamond Slice looks amazing and asks about the taste."
Positive"Recommends Diamond Slice for pizza in Brooklyn."
Positive"The commenter notes that Diamond Slice looks like Lucia pizza."
Neutral"The commenter thinks the crust looks good but the slice needs more cheese."
Negative"The commenter finds the slice from Diamond Slice looks perfect and very similar to F&F Pizzeria."
Positive"The user really likes the caesar slice at Diamond Slice, but notes it's better fresh as they don't reheat it."
Positive"User finds Diamond Slice really good, with fair prices and a nice, relaxed, unpretentious space. They feel lucky to be local."
Positive"In response to a comment about dryness, this user states a preference for slices light on dairy but wished for slightly higher salt content in Diamond Slice's grated cheese."
Neutral"The commenter thanks the original poster for the recommendation and plans to try Diamond Slice, noting the NYC pizza scene is strong."
Positive"The commenter finds Diamond Slice better, cheaper, nicer, and quicker than Chrissy's Pizza, jokingly asking people not to spread the word to keep lines short."
Positive"The user describes the well-done slice from Diamond Slice as 'perfect'."
Positive"The commenter believes Diamond Slice is very underrated."
Positive"This user found the pizza at Diamond Slice too dry and lacking sufficient cheese."
Negative"The user considers Diamond Slice a new top 5 personal contender after visiting."
Positive
