Masterful sourdough-crust pies and a stellar natural wine list in a cozy, candlelit setting. A top-tier Bushwick destination for pizza lovers seeking exceptional quality.
Legendary Brooklyn coal-oven pizza and calzones known for massive lines, elite hype, and an old-school atmosphere.
Top-tier New York style pizza in Sunnyside. A dependable local favorite perfect for a slice crawl.
High-quality, no-wait pizza alternative to NYC's most crowded spots. Featuring signature slices like vodka and hot honey pepperoni.
Famous for ultra-crispy, heavily loaded pepperoni squares, this NYC staple is a polarizing SoHo go-to for Sicilian-style slices.
Consistently top-rated NYC slices with a standout crust. A go-to local favorite for a perfect cheese or specialty pie.
An iconic NYC pizza staple famous for its signature crust and reliable, nostalgic slices. A go-to for consistent quality across multiple locations.
A beloved Brooklyn gem serving up authentic Italian-American pizza. Highlights include a top-tier Romano white pizza and a must-try potato pizza.
Thin-crust slices featuring inventive toppings like hot honey, burrata, and vodka sauce. A standout slice shop on the Lower East Side.
Crispy, blistered NY-style slices featuring premium Italian toppings. A trendy West Village go-to with long lines and exceptional burrata pizza.
Historic, coal-fired pies in the heart of SoHo. A legendary NYC institution for traditional, charred-crust pizza.
Fluffy, four-day fermented dough meets a modern "New Wave" NY slice. A Park Slope staple for standout pizza and meatballs.
Coal-fired pizza landmark w/ a historic NYC taste. Once a top spot, now a chain w/ solid pies, but less char.
A historic, no-frills Queens institution serving classic NY-style slices since 1962. A must-visit for those seeking an authentic, old-school pizzeria experience.
Expertly charred, foldable NY-style slices in a converted garage setting. Renowned for creative toppings like red onion and honey or classic clam pies.
Specializing in tangy, cheeseless marinara slices and robust tomato pies, this St. Marks favorite is a go-to for unique, char-forward NYC pizza.
Cheap eats that don't break the bank. Grab a classic NYC slice that's surprisingly good for the price.
Iconic, family-run 70s-style spot serving classic NYC-style slices with a signature cracker-thin, salty crust. Renowned for its authentic neighborhood atmosphere and legendary owner.
Unique slice creations & amazing sandwiches. A must-try for pizza lovers.
Massive, foot-long jumbo slices since 1981. Famous for satisfyingly greasy, late-night comfort in NYC.
Modern Roman-style al taglio with a signature fluffy, bread-like crust and experimental, premium toppings.
Iconic thin-crust pizza w/ cracker-like crunch. Famous for plain & vodka pies. A Staten Island classic.
Elevated by a unique, flavorful sourdough crust and consistently high-quality slices. A perfect, underrated stop for an authentic and accessible NYC pizza experience.
A stylish Upper West Side hybrid serving charred Neapolitan-style pies and creative cocktails. Famous for its clam pizza, chocolate cake, and weekend brunch.
Crown Heights' go-to for a solid, reliable pizza slice. A true neighborhood gem.
Flushing's hidden gem: a no-nonsense pizza joint w/ a killer crust-to-sauce ratio & greasy cheese since the '70s.
Buzzy Williamsburg slice shop serving standout NY-style pizza, famous for unique toppings like zesty lemon white slices and crispy breadcrumb-topped tomato pies.
Century-old, family-run legend serving iconic coal-oven pizza in Coney Island. Limited weekend hours, takeout only, and a must-visit for classic NYC slice enthusiasts.
An inventive fusion of Neapolitan-style pizza topped with authentic Indian flavors, formerly a go-to for East Village foodies.
Magic in the sauce & stretchy cheese. Your go-to for a consistently good slice in the East Village.
A unique pizza experience from the makers of Lucali, offering a different, often doughier, style with standout options like the square ricotta broccoli rabe [1, 2].
Sunnyside's premier Mexican bakery-cafe, famous for pillowy, cloud-like conchas, authentic tamales, and innovative sourdough pastries.
Brooklyn's beloved neighborhood pizzeria, a true gem with standout pizza. Enjoyed best in good weather, thanks to ample outdoor seating.
Brooklyn's best-kept pizza secret, serving up quality slices that rival the city's top spots. A must-try for pizza aficionados, especially if you're planning a trip to the area.
Great value pizza w/ a unique vibe. Don't miss the breakfast focaccia!
Go-to neighborhood pizzeria for 10+ yrs. Consistently good Neapolitan pies w/ great chew. Reliable & comforting.
Unique pizza pies w/ creative vegan slices. A late-night guilty pleasure, but prices are up & quality can be hit-or-miss.
Italian pizza meets Vietnamese pho & banh mi – a unique Bronx culinary fusion w/ standout sandwiches & satisfying noodle soups.
Iconic NYC slice joint on St. Mark's Place - a no-frills, go-to for classic New York-style pizza.
Neighborhood gem w/ a legendary chicken parm hero. A must-try Red Hook favorite!
High-quality, crave-worthy slices in the East Village. A rising local favorite with a reputation for excellence that challenges established city staples.
Classic NY slices & sensational chicken rolls w/ a unique sesame crust. Don't miss the wings!
Unique pizza omakase experience; innovative & fun.
Hand-crafted slices and over-the-top hero sandwiches from the team behind a local bagel favorite, though consistency remains a point of contention for many.
