An iconic Brooklyn destination for legendary upside-down Sicilian squares and house-made spumoni served in a classic, nostalgic outdoor setting.
Viral NYC hotspot redefining pizza and sandwiches with crispy, thick-crust slices and house-baked semolina bread. Famous for its rotating daily specials and cult-favorite chicken cutlet vodka sandwiches.
Iconic, cash-only brick-oven pizzeria in Brooklyn known for its thin-crust pies and calzones, requiring dedicated early-arrival strategy due to legendary wait times.
Exceptional sourdough-crust pizza delivering authentic NYC flavor. An underrated, accessible gem that outshines tourist-heavy area options.
Century-old coal-oven legend in Coney Island, famous for traditional pies and historic atmosphere. Limited weekend-only hours for takeout.
Blistered, foldable NY-style slices featuring premium toppings like burrata. A West Village & Williamsburg staple that draws massive crowds.
Iconic square Sicilian slices featuring heavily-loaded, crispy pepperoni. A polarising city staple known for both its bold flavors and significant public controversy.
Sunnyside's go-to for pillowy, cloud-like conchas and authentic tamales. A must-visit gem for traditional Mexican pan dulce and inventive seasonal pastries.
Exceptional whole-pie only spot in Greenpoint known for its distinctively saucy, thin-crust New York style pizza.
Massive, foot-long jumbo slices that are the definition of satisfyingly greasy. A legendary late-night neighborhood staple offering incredible value.
Flushing's hidden gem: a no-nonsense pizza joint w/ a killer crust-to-sauce ratio & greasy cheese since the '70s.
A Carroll Gardens gem serving up expertly charred, foldable slices and unique pies like clam and honey-drizzled Partanna in a converted garage setting.
Historic NYC landmark since 1905, pioneering the classic coal-oven pizza experience in the heart of SoHo.
Legendary thin-crust pizza institution serving classic NY slices since 1956. The perfect casual stop for travelers near JFK and beach-goers.
Indulgent, premium burgers and celebrated American fare. A long-standing staple for groups and those seeking a serious, crowd-pleasing meal.
Authentic Neapolitan pies with a blistered crust and a standout, celiac-safe gluten-free menu. A go-to for casual outdoor dining in the heart of FiDi.
Crispy, thin-crust grandma slices and fluffy 'New Wave' NY-style pies. A neighborhood favorite for pizza enthusiasts in Park Slope.
A chic cocktail lounge meets authentic, charred-crust Neapolitan pizza in a nostalgic throwback setting.
Modern, fluffy, bread-like Roman-style pizza al taglio with creative toppings. An experimental, upscale square slice experience near Union Square.
A top-tier NYC pizza joint, frequently lauded as one of the city's best.
Underrated neighborhood pizza joint, praised as a go-to for classic, no-frills slices that rival hyped spots. Simple, old-school perfection.
Tangy marinara pizza slices & classic NY style. Some like it charred, others find it a bit much.
Cheap eats that don't break the bank. Grab a classic NYC slice that's surprisingly good for the price.
Unique slice creations & amazing sandwiches. A must-try for pizza lovers.
Sourdough pizza w/ tangy, charred crust & natural wine list [1, 2]. Bushwick neighborhood favorite.
Coal-fired pizza landmark w/ a historic NYC taste. Once a top spot, now a chain w/ solid pies, but less char.
Iconic thin-crust pizza w/ cracker-like crunch. Famous for plain & vodka pies. A Staten Island classic.
Crown Heights' go-to for a solid, reliable pizza slice. A true neighborhood gem.
Staten Island institution since '37. Top NYC pizza & classic Italian-American dishes. Groups welcome!
NYC's best kept secret for killer pizza slices & amazing lunch deals. Don't miss the vodka slice!
Unique lemon-zest white slices & clam pie specialists.
Unique Indian-Italian fusion pizza w/ Neapolitan crust & Indian toppings. Faves incl. Masala Neapolitan & Chicken Tikka.
Magic in the sauce & stretchy cheese. Your go-to for a consistently good slice in the East Village.
Brooklyn's unhyped pizza gem w/ identical pie to a famous neighbor, minus the wait. Killer calzones too!
A beloved Brooklyn gem serving up authentic Italian-American pizza. Highlights include a top-tier Romano white pizza and a must-try potato pizza.
A unique pizza experience from the makers of Lucali, offering a different, often doughier, style with standout options like the square ricotta broccoli rabe [1, 2].
Iconic Sunnyside destination serving up top-tier New York-style pizza. A must-visit for those seeking the best slices in Queens.
NYC's beloved pizza joint, known for its unique pies & reliable comfort food. A nostalgic favorite, still going strong across multiple locations.
Brooklyn's beloved neighborhood pizzeria, a true gem with standout pizza. Enjoyed best in good weather, thanks to ample outdoor seating.
Brooklyn's best-kept pizza secret, serving up quality slices that rival the city's top spots. A must-try for pizza aficionados, especially if you're planning a trip to the area.
Great value pizza w/ a unique vibe. Don't miss the breakfast focaccia!
Go-to neighborhood pizzeria for 10+ yrs. Consistently good Neapolitan pies w/ great chew. Reliable & comforting.
Unique pizza pies w/ creative vegan slices. A late-night guilty pleasure, but prices are up & quality can be hit-or-miss.
Italian pizza meets Vietnamese pho & banh mi – a unique Bronx culinary fusion w/ standout sandwiches & satisfying noodle soups.
Iconic NYC slice joint on St. Mark's Place - a no-frills, go-to for classic New York-style pizza.
Neighborhood gem w/ a legendary chicken parm hero. A must-try Red Hook favorite!
Classic NY slices & sensational chicken rolls w/ a unique sesame crust. Don't miss the wings!
Unique pizza omakase experience; innovative & fun.
